Hernandez v State Rail Authority of NSW

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY A MEMBER

CITATION:

Hernandez v State Rail Authority of NSW [2023] NSWPICPD 61

APPELLANT:

Albert Hernandez

FIRST RESPONDENT:

State Rail Authority of NSW

FIRST RESPONDENT’S INSURER:

QBE TMF

SECONDRESPONDENT:

Adstock Pty Ltd formerly known as GL Cooper Sales Pty Ltd

SECOND RESPONDENT’S INSURER:

Employers Mutual NSW Limited

FILE NUMBER:

A2-6144/20

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:

Acting Deputy President Geoffrey Parker SC

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:

3 October 2023

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1.     The Member’s Certificate of Determination dated 20 July 2022 is confirmed.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION – scope of remitter to a non-presidential Member for re-determination from a decision of a Presidential Member – whether renal and cardiac conditions related to ingestion of medication prescribed to treat back injury

HEARING:

On the papers

REPRESENTATION:

Appellant:

Mr D Adhikary, counsel

Wilson Fox Lawyers

First respondent:

Ms F King, solicitor

Moray & Agnew Lawyers

Second respondent:

Ms L Goodman, counsel

Rankin Ellison Lawyers

DECISION UNDER APPEAL

MEMBER:

Mr B Batchelor

DATE OF MEMBER’S DECISION:

20 July 2022

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an appeal from a Certificate of Determination dated 20 July 2022.

  2. The matter has a very long history in, firstly, the Workers Compensation Commission and, subsequently, the Personal Injury Commission. It is unnecessary to set out that history at length. The Member summarised the procedural history under the heading “Background” in his Statement of Reasons.[1]

    [1] Hernandez v State Rail Authority of NSW [2022] NSWPIC 393, decision of Member Batchelor dated 20 July 2022 (reasons).

  3. For the purpose of this appeal, it is only necessary to note two prior Certificates of Determination.

  4. On 2 June 2021 a Member (Mr Sweeney) of the Personal Injury Commission issued a Certificate of Determination[2] in the following terms:

    “1.     The applicant suffered injuries to his back arising out of and in the course of his employment with the first respondent on 18 December 1973, 16 August 1976 and 8 December 1987 in the employ of the first respondent and on 27 April 1992 in the employ of the second respondent.

    2.     As a result of these injuries the applicant aggravated a pre-existing condition of hypertension which became labile in 2001 and 2005.

    3.     The applicant has not established that he suffered a consequential medical condition of his shoulders or consequential cardiac or renal conditions as a result of the injuries in 1 above or that the need for treatment of these conditions result from these injuries.

    4. Liberty to apply, if necessary, in respect of quantification the applicant’s entitlement to compensation pursuant to section 60 in accordance with order 2.”

  5. On 17 February 2022 the Personal Injury Commission determined an appeal against the Member’s decision.[3] Deputy President Wood on appeal made the following orders:

    “1.     The Member’s Certificate of Determination dated 2…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hernandez v State Rail Authority of NSW and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICPD 61
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Hernandez v State Rail Authority of NSW, the appellant sought to appeal a decision regarding the scope of a remitter to a non-presidential member for re-determination from a decision of a Presidential Member. The appellant contended that the renal and cardiac conditions he suffered were related to the ingestion of medication prescribed to treat his back injury. The matter was heard in the New South Wales Court of Appeal. The central legal issues that the court had to address were whether the remitter appropriately confined the scope of the Member's jurisdiction and whether the Member exercised his jurisdiction correctly in accordance with the remitter. The court had to determine if the Member had misconstrued the remitter and if so, whether this amounted to a constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction.

The court examined the statutory provisions governing the remitter and the Member's duty to act in accordance with the decision and reasons provided by the Deputy President. It was noted that the Member did not consider whether the medication prescribed for the appellant's back injuries materially contributed to his renal and cardiac conditions. The court found that the Member's conclusion on the remitter's scope was a correct understanding of the matter, and thus the appellant's contention that the Member misinterpreted the remitter was rejected. The court held that the Member was correct in limiting the scope of the enquiry as directed by the Deputy President. Consequently, Ground 1 of the appeal was dismissed. The appellant's argument that the Member constructively failed to exercise jurisdiction by not considering the lumbar spine injuries as a whole was also rejected. The court determined that the Member correctly applied the remitter and did not misconstrue the nature of his jurisdiction.

The court concluded that the Member's decision was in accordance with the remitter, and there was no constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction. The appeal was dismissed, and the original decision of the Member was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

That provision, which is expressed to be an alternative to s 352(6A), provides as follows:“Alternatively, the matter may be remitted back to the non-presidential member concerned, or to another non-presidential member, for determination in accordance with any decision or directions of the Commission (including, in the case of a decision about the degree of permanent impairment resulting from an injury, a direction to refer the matter for assessment by a medical assessor under Part 7).” (emphasis added) It is important to have regard to the decision and in my view the statement of reasons for decision given by the Deputy President. The appellant’s submission at [47] that subs 352(7) confines the Member’s statutory duty to the terms of the remitter is correct. However, the subsection provides that the Member is to determine the issue remitted “in accordance with” the Deputy President’s decision. In paragraphs [192] and [193] the Deputy President said:“192… [Member Sweeney] did not take into consideration the allegation that the medication prescribed to the appellant to treat the appellant’s back injuries materially contributed to the appellant’s renal condition. Nor did he give consideration to whether the medication prescribed to treat the back injuries materially contributed to the cardiac condition.193… It follows that the Member erred by failing to determine whether the renal and cardiac conditions resulted from the ingestion of medication prescribed for the treatment of the appellant’s back injuries and/or hypertension.” (emphasis added) In my view the Member’s conclusion at reasons [97] was a correct understanding of the matter remitted for determination from Deputy President Wood. It follows that the appellant’s primary submission in respect of Ground 1 at [34], that the Member misinterpreted/misconstrued Wood DP’s decision and the scope of the remitter, is rejected. It follows the Member was correct to limit the scope of the enquiry in the manner in which he did at paragraph [97]. Ground 1 of the appeal is dismissed. The appellant submits that the confining of the issue for determination in respect of the appellant’s renal and cardiac conditions to whether they were related to the ingestion of medication prescribed to treat the appellant’s back injury only was a constructive failure by the Member to exercise jurisdiction. The appellant refers to Norrington v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited[14] at [30], a passage from Brereton JA.[14] [2021] NSWSC 548. The appellant submits that the Member erred by not having regard to the lumbar spine injuries as a whole and only considering the effects created by the appellant’s ingesting medication for treatment of his lumbar spine injuries and therefore did not have proper regard to the terms of Wood DP’s remitter. It is submitted that the Member misunderstood the nature of his jurisdiction and that he applied the wrong test because he confined the enquiry to the effects of ingesting medication only and whether this materially contributed to the disputed conditions. It followed that he misconstrued the remitter and did not address the issue of causation “for the disputed conditions on the basis of the back injuries as a whole”[15] and that he therefore failed to apply himself to the real question that was to be decided having regard to the terms of the remitter.[15] Appellant’s submissions, [44(c)].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established