Adler v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEAL

CITATION:      ADLER v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS [2004]  NSWCCA 352 revised - 04/11/2004

FILE NUMBER(S):
2004/1927

HEARING DATE(S):               23 August 2004

JUDGMENT DATE: 15/10/2004

PARTIES:
Stephen Rodney ADLER v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P Grove J Barr J   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          2003/48

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     James J

COUNSEL:
Appellant: J K Sher / N Perram
Crown:  D Fagan SC/ M Wigney

SOLICITORS:
Appellant: Gilbert & Tobin
Crown: Director of Public Prosecutions

CATCHWORDS:
Application for permanent stay of criminal proceedings - Corporations Act 2001 - prior civil penalty proceedings - whether abuse of process - whether double jeopardy - scope and validity of s1317P.

LEGISLATION CITED:
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss1311, s1317P and 1400
Evidence Act 1995, s140(2)

DECISION:
Leave to appeal granted.  Appeal dismissed.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE COURT OF
CRIMINAL APPEAL

CCA 2004/1927

MASON P
GROVE J
BARR J

Friday 15 October 2004

Rodney Stephen ADLER v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS (CTH)

BACKGROUND

The appellant was a director of HIH Insurance Ltd, a public company carrying on business as an insurer. The appellant was arraigned by the Commonwealth Director of Prosecutions (DPP) on an indictment containing five counts of offences under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Act) involving stock market manipulation and the making of false or misleading statements in relation to securities.

Before James J, the appellant sought an order that the criminal proceedings be permanently stayed on the ground that they were an abuse of process because of exposure to double jeopardy. It was submitted that as a result of earlier proceedings brought by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) under the civil penalty provisions of the Act, the appellant had already been punished for the conduct which is now the subject of the criminal charges brought by the DPP.

The Crown submitted that there were differences between the elements of the civil causes of action and the elements of the criminal offences, and that the two sets of proceedings had different purposes. The Crown also placed reliance on s1317P of the Act which permits criminal proceedings to be started against a person for conduct that is substantially the same as conduct constituting a contravention of a civil penalty provision, even where a declaration of contravention has already been made.

James J refused the appellant’s application for a permanent stay. In the Court of Appeal the appellant sought leave to appeal from James J’s orders, submitting that his Honour erred in his reasoning in a number of respects. Reliance was placed on The Queen v Carroll(2002) 213 CLR 635 as authority for the proposition that commonality of facts, and not elements of the offence, are relevant to the rule against double jeopardy. Submissions were also received as to the validity of s 1317P.

HELD

Per Mason P (Grove and Barr JJ agreeing) dismissing the appeal:

1. The decision in Pearce v The Queen(1998) 194 CLR 610 is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Adler v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWCCA 352
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Adler, a former director and shareholder of HIH Insurance Ltd, applied for a permanent stay of the criminal proceedings brought against him by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). Adler contended that the criminal proceedings should be permanently stayed on the basis of abuse of process and double jeopardy, as he had already been subject to civil penalty proceedings for the same conduct. The High Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether the prior civil penalty proceedings brought by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) constituted a sufficient punishment for the alleged misconduct to warrant a permanent stay of the criminal proceedings, and whether the proposed criminal proceedings would amount to double jeopardy.

The High Court held that the prior civil penalty proceedings did not amount to a sufficient punishment to warrant a permanent stay of the criminal proceedings. The Court held that the civil penalty proceedings and the criminal proceedings were distinct and separate legal processes, each with its own purpose and consequences. The Court emphasised that the primary purpose of civil penalty proceedings is to enforce compliance with statutory provisions and to protect the public interest, while the purpose of criminal proceedings is to punish the offender and to deter similar conduct in the future. The Court also found that the civil penalty proceedings did not provide the same level of deterrence and punishment as criminal proceedings, and therefore, the criminal proceedings should proceed. Furthermore, the Court held that the proposed criminal proceedings did not constitute double jeopardy, as the elements of the offences in the criminal proceedings were not identical to those in the civil penalty proceedings.

The High Court dismissed Adler's application for a permanent stay of the criminal proceedings. The Court held that the prior civil penalty proceedings did not amount to a sufficient punishment for the alleged misconduct, and that the criminal proceedings should proceed. The Court also held that the criminal proceedings did not amount to double jeopardy, as the elements of the offences in the criminal proceedings were not identical to those in the civil penalty proceedings. The Court's decision emphasised the importance of distinguishing between civil penalty proceedings and criminal proceedings, and the need to ensure that each legal process serves its own distinct purpose and consequences.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant sought an order that the criminal proceedings be permanently stayed. The basis of the alleged abuse of process was that as a result of earlier civil proceedings brought by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), the appellant had already been punished for the conduct that is the subject of the criminal charges brought by the DPP.factual background The factual background leading to both the past civil proceedings and present criminal proceedings was set out by James J in his reasons of 5 March 2004:[18] HIH Insurance Ltd (“HIH”) was a listed public company carrying on the business of an insurer.[19] Mr Raymond Williams, who was also a defendant in the civil proceedings, was a director of HIH and the Chief Executive Officer of HIH.[20] Between 16 April 1999 and 26 February 2001 Mr Adler was a director of HIH. Mr Adler was also an “officer” of HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd (“HIHC”), a subsidiary of HIH, within the meaning of the expression “officer” in the Corporations Act.[21] Adler Corp or Mr Adler had a large shareholding in HIH. From at least the beginning of the year 2000 the price of shares in HIH had been declining.[22] On 9 June 2000 Mr Adler sent Mr Williams a fax in which he said that a company named Drenmex (a company associated with Mr Adler) would like to borrow the sum of ten million dollars for the purpose of venture capital and share trading. …[23] Later on the same day Mr Williams sent a fax to Mr Adler, saying that he would arrange for the funds which had been requested to be transmitted to Mr Adler. …[24] On HIH’s copy of Mr Williams’ fax Mr Williams wrote a note to Mr Fodera, an executive director of HIH, who was also a defendant in the civil proceedings, asking Mr Fodera to arrange for the funds to be transferred to Drenmex.[25] On 14 June 2000 Mr Adler sent a fax to Mr Williams, saying that it would not be appropriate to use Drenmex and “the name of the company that has been incorporated is Pacific Eagle Equity Pty Ltd” (“PEE”). PEE was in fact not incorporated until the following day. Mr Adler was its only director and Adler Corp was the holder of its one issued share.[26] On the morning of 15 June 2000 Mr Adler instructed a stock broker to purchase two million shares in HIH at market in the name of PEE. Pursuant to these instructions 1,873,661 shares in HIH were purchased at an average price of $1.0062 per share.[27] At the hearing of the civil proceedings Mr Howard, the General Manager Finance of HIH, gave evidence, which Santow J accepted, about conversations he had had on 15 June 2000 with Mr Fodera, Mr Adler, again with Mr Fodera, with Mr Williams and finally with Mr Cubbin, the head of Accounts Payable and Management Accounting in HIH. …[28] On 15 June 2000 a cheque for $10,000,000 was drawn by HIHC in favour of PEE and delivered to Mr Adler and was banked in a bank account which had been opened for PEE.[29] Between 16 June and 30 June (or possibly 5 July) further shares in HIH were purchased by PEE through the same stock broker, on instructions given by Mr Adler. These purchases included purchases on 16 June 2000 of 951,339 shares at an average price of $1.0192 per share and purchases on 19 June 2000 of 425,000 shares at an average price of $1.018 per share.[30] The total number of shares in HIH purchased between 15 June 2000 and 30 June 2000 was 3,924,545 shares for a total price including stamp duty and brokerage of $3,991,856.21, all of which was paid out of the $10m which had been paid by HIHC to PEE.[31] Between 14 June 2000 and about mid July 2000 the decline in the traded price of shares in HIH was arrested and the share price slightly increased but thereafter the traded price of shares in HIH again declined.[32] As he was the controller of PEE Mr Adler was required by s 205G of the Corporations Law then in force to notify the Australian Stock Exchange of the purchases of shares in HIH and Mr Adler did promptly notify the Stock Exchange. Mr Adler did not notify the Stock Exchange that the acquisition of the shares had been financially assisted by HIH or HIHC. As a result of Mr Adler’s notification to the Stock Exchange there were reports in the financial press that Mr Adler had bought many shares in HIH.[33] On 19 June 2000 a Mr Mellish, a journalist with the Australian Financial Review, contacted Mr Adler and had a conversation with Mr Adler. When asked by Mr Mellish why he had bought shares in HIH, Mr Adler said that shares in HIH were “undervalued in the long term … I think there will be a weakness for another week or two and that will give me a chance to get some volume”. …[34] On 20 June 2000 Mr Mellish had a further conversation with Mr Adler about the purchases of HIH shares, in which Mr Adler said:“I want people to know I am a committed insurance person. People think I have sold out and I’ve got my money and gone. That’s not true. I am making a number of statements about buying these shares. I believe in the company. I’m putting my money up which shows I believe in the industry. I think the company can be a billion dollar company again.”[35] At the time of the payment of the $10m by HIHC to PEE the terms on which the payment was made had not been reduced to writing and had not been finalised.[36] On 7 July 2000 PEE entered into a deed poll prepared by solicitors, constituting the Australian Equities Unit Trust (“the AEUT”). The HIH shares which had been purchased by PEE were treated as an asset of the AEUT.[37] Under the trust deed of the AEUT there were “A” class units and “B” class units, with different rights and entitlements. Four “A” class units were issued to Adler Corp or another company associated with Mr Adler. One “B” class unit was issued to HIHC.[38] Mr Adler caused PEE as trustee of the AEUT to acquire from Adler Corp, at cost, shares in companies called dstore Ltd, Planet Soccer International Ltd and Nomad Telecommunications Ltd and also caused PEE as trustee of the AEUT to make unsecured loans to morehuman Pty Ltd, Pacific Capital Partners Pty Ltd, Intagrowth Fund No 1 and PCP Ensor No 2 Pty Ltd, with all of which Mr Adler was associated. The funds used for all of these seven transactions came out of the payment of $10m by HIHC to PEE on 15 June 2000.The civil proceedings

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The provisions in the Corporations Law did not themselves create offences. But they provide the definition of presently relevant offences in light of the combined operation of ss1311 and 1400 of the Corporations Act. The appellant sought an order that the criminal proceedings be permanently stayed. The basis of the alleged abuse of process was that as a result of earlier civil proceedings brought by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC), the appellant had already been punished for the conduct that is the subject of the criminal charges brought by the DPP.factual background The factual background leading to both the past civil proceedings and present criminal proceedings was set out by James J in his reasons of 5 March 2004:[18] HIH Insurance Ltd (“HIH”) was a listed public company carrying on the business of an insurer.[19] Mr Raymond Williams, who was also a defendant in the civil proceedings, was a director of HIH and the Chief Executive Officer of HIH.[20] Between 16 April 1999 and 26 February 2001 Mr Adler was a director of HIH. Mr Adler was also an “officer” of HIH Casualty and General Insurance Ltd (“HIHC”), a subsidiary of HIH, within the meaning of the expression “officer” in the Corporations Act.[21] Adler Corp or Mr Adler had a large shareholding in HIH. From at least the beginning of the year 2000 the price of shares in HIH had been declining.[22] On 9 June 2000 Mr Adler sent Mr Williams a fax in which he said that a company named Drenmex (a company associated with Mr Adler) would like to borrow the sum of ten million dollars for the purpose of venture capital and share trading. …[23] Later on the same day Mr Williams sent a fax to Mr Adler, saying that he would arrange for the funds which had been requested to be transmitted to Mr Adler. …[24] On HIH’s copy of Mr Williams’ fax Mr Williams wrote a note to Mr Fodera, an executive director of HIH, who was also a defendant in the civil proceedings, asking Mr Fodera to arrange for the funds to be transferred to Drenmex.[25] On 14 June 2000 Mr Adler sent a fax to Mr Williams, saying that it would not be appropriate to use Drenmex and “the name of the company that has been incorporated is Pacific Eagle Equity Pty Ltd” (“PEE”). PEE was in fact not incorporated until the following day. Mr Adler was its only director and Adler Corp was the holder of its one issued share.[26] On the morning of 15 June 2000 Mr Adler instructed a stock broker to purchase two million shares in HIH at market in the name of PEE. Pursuant to these instructions 1,873,661 shares in HIH were purchased at an average price of $1.0062 per share.[27] At the hearing of the civil proceedings Mr Howard, the General Manager Finance of HIH, gave evidence, which Santow J accepted, about conversations he had had on 15 June 2000 with Mr Fodera, Mr Adler, again with Mr Fodera, with Mr Williams and finally with Mr Cubbin, the head of Accounts Payable and Management Accounting in HIH. …[28] On 15 June 2000 a cheque for $10,000,000 was drawn by HIHC in favour of PEE and delivered to Mr Adler and was banked in a bank account which had been opened for PEE.[29] Between 16 June and 30 June (or possibly 5 July) further shares in HIH were purchased by PEE through the same stock broker, on instructions given by Mr Adler. These purchases included purchases on 16 June 2000 of 951,339 shares at an average price of $1.0192 per share and purchases on 19 June 2000 of 425,000 shares at an average price of $1.018 per share.[30] The total number of shares in HIH purchased between 15 June 2000 and 30 June 2000 was 3,924,545 shares for a total price including stamp duty and brokerage of $3,991,856.21, all of which was paid out of the $10m which had been paid by HIHC to PEE.[31] Between 14 June 2000 and about mid July 2000 the decline in the traded price of shares in HIH was arrested and the share price slightly increased but thereafter the traded price of shares in HIH again declined.[32] As he was the controller of PEE Mr Adler was required by s 205G of the Corporations Law then in force to notify the Australian Stock Exchange of the purchases of shares in HIH and Mr Adler did promptly notify the Stock Exchange. Mr Adler did not notify the Stock Exchange that the acquisition of the shares had been financially assisted by HIH or HIHC. As a result of Mr Adler’s notification to the Stock Exchange there were reports in the financial press that Mr Adler had bought many shares in HIH.[33] On 19 June 2000 a Mr Mellish, a journalist with the Australian Financial Review, contacted Mr Adler and had a conversation with Mr Adler. When asked by Mr Mellish why he had bought shares in HIH, Mr Adler said that shares in HIH were “undervalued in the long term … I think there will be a weakness for another week or two and that will give me a chance to get some volume”. …[34] On 20 June 2000 Mr Mellish had a further conversation with Mr Adler about the purchases of HIH shares, in which Mr Adler said:“I want people to know I am a committed insurance person. People think I have sold out and I’ve got my money and gone. That’s not true. I am making a number of statements about buying these shares. I believe in the company. I’m putting my money up which shows I believe in the industry. I think the company can be a billion dollar company again.”[35] At the time of the payment of the $10m by HIHC to PEE the terms on which the payment was made had not been reduced to writing and had not been finalised.[36] On 7 July 2000 PEE entered into a deed poll prepared by solicitors, constituting the Australian Equities Unit Trust (“the AEUT”). The HIH shares which had been purchased by PEE were treated as an asset of the AEUT.[37] Under the trust deed of the AEUT there were “A” class units and “B” class units, with different rights and entitlements. Four “A” class units were issued to Adler Corp or another company associated with Mr Adler. One “B” class unit was issued to HIHC.[38] Mr Adler caused PEE as trustee of the AEUT to acquire from Adler Corp, at cost, shares in companies called dstore Ltd, Planet Soccer International Ltd and Nomad Telecommunications Ltd and also caused PEE as trustee of the AEUT to make unsecured loans to morehuman Pty Ltd, Pacific Capital Partners Pty Ltd, Intagrowth Fund No 1 and PCP Ensor No 2 Pty Ltd, with all of which Mr Adler was associated. The funds used for all of these seven transactions came out of the payment of $10m by HIHC to PEE on 15 June 2000.The civil proceedings