Abigroup Contractors P/L v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Preliminary Issue)

ABIGROUP CONTRACTORS P/L v HARDESTY & HANOVER INTERNATIONAL LLC & ORS

[2009] SASC 95

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Anderson

8 April 2009

CONTRACTS - BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS - THE CONTRACT - CONSTRUCTION OF PARTICULAR CONTRACTS AND IMPLIED CONDITIONS - SETTLEMENT OF DISPUTES

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - ILLEGAL AND VOID CONTRACTS - EFFECT OF ILLEGALITY OR INVALIDITY - SEVERANCE

ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION - REFERRAL FOR EXPERT DETERMINATION

Counterclaim by defendant seeking declaration that expert determination binding and payment of amount in determination - trial of preliminary issue of enforceability of expert determination - whether expert had jurisdiction to make determination - whether dispute resolution clause in contract void for uncertainty - whether first limb of dispute resolution clause severable.

Held: Dispute resolution procedure not followed - expert did not have jurisdiction to make determination - expert determination not enforceable - dispute resolution clause void for uncertainty - clause not severable. Declaration refused.

Laing & O'Rourke (BMC) Pty Ltd v Transport Infrastructure [2007] NSWSC 723, distinguished.
Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC [2008] SASC 369, considered.

ABIGROUP CONTRACTORS P/L v HARDESTY & HANOVER INTERNATIONAL LLC & ORS
[2009] SASC 95

Civil

ANDERSON J.

Introduction

  1. In this matter the Full Court ordered a separate trial on the issue of whether an expert determination, purportedly made pursuant to the terms of a contract between the parties, is binding upon both parties.

  2. The basic facts relevant to the background of this dispute can be found in the judgment of the Full Court: Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC [2008] SASC 369.

  3. Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd (“Abigroup”) contracted with Hardesty & Hanover International LLC (“HHI”) to provide both construction support services and design services. Certain issues arose between the parties after construction commenced and it was agreed by the parties that they would attempt to resolve these issues by referring them to a mediator. The mediation took place but was unsuccessful.

  4. HHI claims that it then correctly invoked the process of expert determination provided for in the contract. Abigroup objected to the process because, it argued, the mediation process had by agreement replaced the process of expert determination provided for in the contract. Abigroup disputed the jurisdiction of the expert to hear and determine the matters referred to him by HHI.

  5. Abigroup claims that what was referred to the expert did not constitute the dispute between the parties. It claims that the process was contrived and that what was presented unilaterally to the expert was a sham.

  6. The main thrust of the argument by HHI is that it was entitled by the terms of the contract to have individual disputes determined at any time by reference to an expert for a speedy resolution of the individual issues. Further, it argues that such an expert determination is final and binding.

  7. There have been two such expert determinations to date, with a potential third…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abigroup Contractors P/L v Hardesty & Hanover International... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 95
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Abigroup Contractors P/L v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC involved the parties in a dispute over the enforceability of an expert determination in relation to contractual obligations arising from the design and construction of two opening bridges spanning the Port River at Port Adelaide. The dispute centred on the validity of expert determinations made following failed mediation proceedings, and the enforceability of the dispute resolution clause within the Consultant Services Agreement (CSA) between Abigroup and Hardesty & Hanover International LLC (HHI). The primary issue before the court was whether the dispute resolution procedure was followed correctly, whether the expert had jurisdiction to make the determination, and whether the dispute resolution clause in the contract was void for uncertainty and, if so, whether it was severable.

The court found that the dispute resolution procedure was not followed, as the mediation process had replaced the first stage of the dispute resolution provisions. Therefore, the expert did not have jurisdiction to make the determination. Furthermore, the court held that the dispute resolution clause in the contract was void for uncertainty because it did not clearly specify the method of resolution, and it was not severable from the rest of the contract. As a result, the expert determination was not enforceable.

In conclusion, the court refused the declaration sought by HHI that the expert determination was binding and that payment of the amount in the determination was due. The court held that the dispute resolution procedure was not followed, the expert did not have jurisdiction, and the dispute resolution clause in the contract was void for uncertainty and not severable.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

It will be necessary to examine precisely what dispute or disputes were referred to the mediator and then to examine the nature and extent of the disputes which were later individually referred to the expert for his determination.Background The issues between the parties stem from the design and construction of two opening bridges spanning the Port River at Port Adelaide. The State of South Australia (“SA”) engaged Abigroup to build the bridges. Before Abigroup had been awarded the contract with SA, it engaged Hardesty & Hanover LLP (“HHL”) to design certain aspects of the bridges to enable it to tender for the contract. An agreement known as the Tender Services Agreement (“TSA”) was entered into between HHL and Abigroup. Later, after being awarded the contract by SA, Abigroup contracted with HHI for the provision of specialist consultancy services related to Abigroup’s performance of the contractual obligations which it owed to SA. HHI was a company controlled by the same personnel who also controlled HHL. HHI was incorporated, amongst other reasons, for the purpose of this contract. The agreement reached was known as the Consultant Services Agreement (“CSA”). A specific term of that agreement, Part 7, clause 1, was that HHL’s obligations under the earlier TSA became part of HHI’s obligations under the CSA. Although the question in this preliminary issue is the dispute relating to the validity of expert determinations, there were earlier issues between the parties which led up to the significant issues the subject of the litigation between the parties. Abigroup had earlier alleged deficiencies in design by HHI. These deficiencies related to what has become known as the ship impact claim. Abigroup claimed that HHI had not made sufficient provision in its design for the type of ship impact envisaged by the parties, and as a result Abigroup alleged that it was put to extra expense because of the suggested design deficiencies by HHI. In addition to that design dispute there was a dispute in relation to consultancy fees. Abigroup claimed that it had overpaid fees and sought to recover those additional fees and it also disputed HHI’s assertion of its entitlement to additional fees for the future. Both of those areas of dispute were referred to mediation. As I have earlier indicated, the mediation was unsuccessful. I have briefly referred to the nature of the issues which arose following the mediation in my earlier remarks. However, it will be necessary to set later out in more detail the history of the disputes as they emerged.The issues As the arguments on both sides were developed, the issues appeared to narrow down somewhat. It seems that there is no real dispute that the contract (CSA) by its terms does provide for serial determinations by an expert. The issue is whether what was referred to the expert in this matter represents the actual disputes which existed between the parties and were the subject of the mediation. In other words, was the subject matter of each expert determination validly before the expert in accordance with the dispute resolution procedures of the contract? Abigroup has submitted that what was referred to the expert was part of a sham because the reference to the expert was a contrived dispute which had never been properly notified in accordance with the terms of the contract.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANDERSON J
Mr Walsh submitted that HHI’s claim for CSS crystallised in its invoices to Abigroup, and that a single fee for CSS was mediated, that fee being the amount claimed in Invoice 9A. Once the mediation failed, Mr Walsh submitted that HHI artificially divided up the amount in Invoice 9A into two notice of disputes in order to achieve a series of binding expert determinations.Conclusions on notices of dispute(i) CSS1 and Notice of Dispute 1 There are several differences between CSS1 and Notice of Dispute 1. The former sought a change order for an additional $466,091.00 for CSS in addition to the CSA lump sum for the period through to 31 December 2006. Notice of Dispute 1 claims fees for CSS totalling $275,861.15 (including interest) for the period through only to 1 December 2006. Notice of Dispute 1 then claims $159,390.00 for detailed design work up to 1 December 2006 based on Change Order requests made in March 2006. These design work fees were not included in CSS1 though they were raised at the mediation. I find that Notice of Dispute 1 was not a notification of a fee claim directly from CSS1 but that it was an artificial combination of claims, including design work which was not the subject of CSS1.(ii) CSS2 and Notice of Dispute 2 CSS2 requested an adjustment to the CSA lump sum of $704,146.00 for CSS completed in January 2007 and for future work through to 31 August 2007. Notice of Dispute 2, however, claimed fees in the amount of $473,712.79 (including interest) for CSS for the period January through to the end of March 2007. Accordingly, Notice of Dispute 2 was a retrospective claim for fees for a different time period than CSS2, which sought a change to the CSA lump sum largely on an anticipatory basis. I find that the two do not align and it is not correct to regard one as the sequel to the other.(iii) Summary Both counsel referred me to judicial statements of what had been held in other matters to constitute a sham on the particular facts of those cases. I do not believe that it is helpful in this case to consider those definitions of a sham. A sham can take on different shades of meaning depending on the facts of the individual case. In this matter I would prefer to describe the method used by HHI as a contrivance, even though Abigroup has pleaded a sham. A contrivance by definition – see Macquarie Dictionary, 3rd edition – is a plan or a scheme or an expedient. To contrive is to plan with ingenuity or to devise or to invent. Mr Fenwick Elliott makes the point in his submissions that what was done by his client was open and transparent. Something may be open and transparent but nevertheless a contrivance. I consider that this was a plan by HHI to bring a dispute within the boundaries of the expert’s jurisdiction, namely, under $500,000. It was an expedient or an invention to achieve a purpose. It is not what was intended by the parties to the contract. The real significance of what took place is that the mediation delineated the dispute. The mediation in turn had replaced the first stage of the dispute resolution provisions contained in clause SC 12. It is the reference to the expert of something quite different from the dispute mediated which is the problem for HHI, as I see it, regardless of whether it is called a plan, a contrivance or a sham.The terms of the contract

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ANDERSON J