Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Preliminary Issue)

ABIGROUP CONTRACTORS PTY LTD v HARDESTY & HANOVER INTERNATIONAL LLC & ORS (No 2)

[2009] SASC 132

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Anderson

19 May 2009

PROCEDURE - COSTS - DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE - ORDER FOR COSTS ON INDEMNITY BASIS

TOMLIN ORDER - INTENT OF ORDER REGARDING REIMBURSEMENT

Application by plaintiff for costs thrown away on trial of preliminary issue, including the costs of the expert determination - costs sought on an indemnity basis.

Held: Plaintiff entitled to order for costs on a party and party basis only.

Application for reimbursement of amount paid by plaintiff pursuant to Tomlin Order - whether outcome contemplated by terms of order or agreement between the parties.

Held: Intent of order was to provide for reimbursement of monies in the event that defendant's counterclaim dismissed.

Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 s 264(4), referred to.
Colgate-Palmolive Co v Cussons Pty Ltd (1993) 46 FCR 225, applied.
Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC [2008] SASC 244; Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC & Ors [2009] SASC 95, discussed.

ABIGROUP CONTRACTORS PTY LTD v HARDESTY & HANOVER INTERNATIONAL LLC & ORS (No 2)
[2009] SASC 132

Civil

ANDERSON J.

Introduction

  1. On 8 April 2009 I delivered judgment in this matter on a preliminary issue: see Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC & Ors [2009] SASC 95. In that decision I held that the dispute resolution procedure provided for in the contract between the parties (the CSA) had not been followed. I held that an expert who made a determination had no jurisdiction and that his determination was not enforceable. A second determination was made by the same expert, but on a different dispute, and it was agreed that the decision in the first matter would apply equally to the second.

  2. As a result of my decision, Abigroup claims an entitlement to its legal costs incurred in defending the expert determinations commenced by Hardesty & Hanover International LLC (“HHI”). It claims costs on an indemnity basis. In addition Abigroup claims the repayment to it by HHI of the sum of $516,631.72 and $3,583 paid to Mr Fullerton (the expert) pursuant to a Tomlin Order, which was made by Gray J in earlier hearings between the parties.

  3. My decision in this matter followed a hearing by the Full Court resulting in an order for a separate trial on the issue of whether the expert determination was binding upon both parties.

    Background

  4. The first document filed in the dispute between the parties was a summons issued by Abigroup (FDN 1) in which it sought various orders, including “a declaration that clause SC12 of the contract between the plaintiff and the first defendant is void and that expert determination of the dispute should be conducted in accordance with clause GC8 of the contract”. From the outset, those two clauses, which relate to dispute resolution procedures,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover Internatio... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] SASC 132
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC (No 2) involved a dispute over the binding nature of an expert determination in a contract between the parties. The case reached the court following a summons by Abigroup seeking a declaration that a specific clause in the contract was void and that the dispute should be resolved via another clause. Hardesty & Hanover International LLC filed a cross-action to enforce the expert determination as final and binding. After a hearing by the Full Court, an order was made for a separate trial to determine the binding nature of the expert determination. Following the judgment, Abigroup sought costs incurred in challenging the expert determination, which it successfully argued was invalid.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Abigroup, having successfully challenged the binding nature of the expert determination, was entitled to costs. Abigroup argued that since it prevailed on the issue and the matter was separate from other unresolved issues, it should be awarded its costs. In contrast, Hardesty & Hanover International LLC contended that the issue of costs was not before the court as it was not part of the preliminary issue argued. The court had to decide whether the unsuccessful party should bear the costs of the successful party's challenge to the expert determination.

The court found in favour of Abigroup, ruling that the unsuccessful party should bear the costs of the successful party's challenge to the expert determination. The reasoning was that Abigroup's success in proving the expert determination was invalid warranted an award of costs. The court rejected the argument that costs were not an issue in the preliminary hearing, emphasising that Abigroup's challenge to the expert determination was justified and it was entitled to its costs as a result of its success. The court's decision ensured that the unsuccessful party bore the costs of the successful party's challenge, aligning with the principle that costs generally follow the event.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

My decision in this matter followed a hearing by the Full Court resulting in an order for a separate trial on the issue of whether the expert determination was binding upon both parties.Background The first document filed in the dispute between the parties was a summons issued by Abigroup (FDN 1) in which it sought various orders, including “a declaration that clause SC12 of the contract between the plaintiff and the first defendant is void and that expert determination of the dispute should be conducted in accordance with clause GC8 of the contract”. From the outset, those two clauses, which relate to dispute resolution procedures, have been at the forefront of the argument between the parties. HHI then issued a cross-action (counterclaim) (FDN 9) which set out all the background facts relating to the CSA between the parties and the circumstances which led to an unsuccessful mediation. The whole basis of the cross-action was to obtain a declaration that the determination by the expert was final and binding upon Abigroup. After I delivered judgment in this matter I made orders on the cross-action in Abigroup’s favour. Subject to any successful appeal, that is a final decision on those matters. In broad terms the matters argued before me on the preliminary issue related to the contractual obligations of the parties, and in particular whether the referral for expert determination by HHI was in breach of the terms of the CSA. I found that it was.Abigroup’s entitlement to legal costs Abigroup now seeks the costs incurred in successfully challenging the expert determination. It has been successful in its argument and has judgment in its favour on the counterclaim. On the face of it there seems to be no valid reason why it is not entitled to its costs. The costs are related to a separate issue isolated from any other issues which remain to be determined in the trial. Costs normally follow the event. The event in this instance is Abigroup’s success in arguing that the expert determinations were invalid. Abigroup points out that there are paragraphs in its statement of claim, (FDN 12) which mirror paragraphs in the cross-action on which judgment has already been given. Abigroup seeks to have judgment on the claim on paragraphs 44 and 50 and then on paragraphs 53 to 84 of the statement of claim. It says that these matters have been finally determined in its favour and that it is therefore entitled to judgment. Mr Fenwick Elliott has submitted that the issue argued before me was limited to a declaration sought in respect of the binding effect of the expert determination. He argues that costs, being a claim for damages, was not an issue. Mr Fenwick Elliott has overlooked a fundamental point, namely, that his client has lost on the preliminary issue. Abigroup should be entitled to its costs. It is not to the point that HHI sought the declaration and that Abigroup did not seek any order for a separate trial on any of its claims. Mr Fenwick Elliott argued that it was Abigroup that challenged the jurisdiction of the expert. He is quite right, of course, but again, that is irrelevant. Abigroup claimed a breach of the contract and the first step it took was to challenge the jurisdiction of the expert. It has ultimately been shown to be justified in the stand it took. I reject the argument that this disentitles Abigroup to costs.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANDERSON J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ANDERSON J