Hardesty & Hanover International LLC v Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

HARDESTY & HANOVER INTERNATIONAL LLC & ORS v ABIGROUP CONTRACTORS PTY LTD

[2010] SASC 44

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Sulan, The Honourable Justice Vanstone and The Honourable Justice Layton)

26 February 2010

CONTRACTS - GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES - ILLEGAL AND VOID CONTRACTS - EFFECT OF ILLEGALITY OR INVALIDITY

CONTRACTS - BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS - THE CONTRACT - CONSTRUCTION OF PARTICULAR CONTRACTS AND IMPLIED CONDITIONS - SETTLEMENT OF DISPUTES

Contract containing clauses dealing with the procedure to resolve disputes between the parties - whether expert determination purporting to be made pursuant to the dispute resolution procedure is enforceable - whether dispute resolution clause void for uncertainty.

Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 50, referred to.
Nitschke Nominees v Hahndorf Golf Club (2004) 88 SASR 334; Re Roberts (1881) 19 Ch D 520, considered.

HARDESTY & HANOVER INTERNATIONAL LLC & ORS v ABIGROUP CONTRACTORS PTY LTD
[2010] SASC 44

Full Court:       Sulan, Vanstone and Layton JJ

  1. SULAN J:             This is an appeal from a judgment of Anderson J on a discrete issue in complex commercial litigation, which was commenced in this Court in February 2008. 

  2. The litigation has been the subject of a judgment on interlocutory matters by Gray J, which was appealed to the Full Court.  Consequent upon the orders of the Full Court, a separate trial was ordered in respect of one issue which was heard and determined by Anderson J and is now the subject of this appeal.  It is unfortunate that both time and cost have been expended on matters which could have been determined in the substantive proceedings which, at this stage, have not progressed.

    Background

    General

  3. The dispute arises out of the construction of twin bridges across the Port River at Port Adelaide.  The State government engaged Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd (“Abigroup”) to design and construct the bridges which were to span the Port River and provide access to both rail and road traffic across the Port River.  Abigroup engaged Hardesty and Hanover LLP (“HHL”) to provide certain design services in relation to the opening sections of the rail and road bridges for the purposes of enabling Abigroup to price and submit a response to an invitation to tender for the project.  HHL is a limited liability partnership and is associated with Hardesty and Hanover International LLC (“HHI”), which is a limited liability company incorporated in the United States of America and holding itself out as having expertise as a bridge design engineer.

  4. Abigroup alleges that, on 3 June 2004, it entered into a contract with HHL pursuant to which HHL agreed to provide expert advice in respect of the tender phase of the project.  Abigroup alleges that the preliminary design work performed by HHL did not comply with the invitation to tender for the project and that it suffered loss and damage due to the negligence of HHL in the performance of the contract.  Abigroup alleges loss and damage in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hardesty & Hanover International LLC v Abigroup Contractors... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] SASC 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hardesty & Hanover International LLC v Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd, the dispute arose from a contractual relationship between Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd and Hardesty & Hanover International LLC (HHI), concerning the design and construction of twin bridges across the Port River at Port Adelaide. The conflict centred on HHI's alleged failure to deliver compliant preliminary design work during the tender phase, which led to Abigroup's claim for damages amounting to $2,851,704.13. The matter was complex, involving multiple agreements, expert determinations, and significant financial disputes. The primary legal issue before the court was whether the dispute resolution procedures outlined in the Consultant Services Agreement (CSA) were valid and enforceable, particularly whether the expert determination made by Mr Fullerton was binding on Abigroup.

The court examined the specific clauses in the CSA governing dispute resolution. It was determined that clause 8.1 of the CSA required parties to negotiate disputes in good faith and, if unresolved, refer the matter to an expert determination by the Australian Commercial Disputes Centre (ACDC), provided the amount awarded did not exceed $500,000. Clause SC12, on the other hand, outlined a different process involving meetings between representatives of the parties at various management levels, culminating in an expert determination if disputes remained unresolved. The court considered whether these clauses were void for uncertainty or whether the expert determination process had been correctly followed.

The court found that the dispute resolution clause in the CSA was not void for uncertainty and that the expert determination process was followed correctly. The court held that Mr Fullerton's determination was indeed binding on Abigroup. It was concluded that the procedures set out in the CSA were clear and provided a structured pathway for resolving disputes, and that the expert determination was properly executed according to the agreement's terms. The court also dismissed Abigroup's contention that the determination was not binding because it exceeded the $500,000 limit, finding that the clause allowing for binding determinations up to that amount was sufficiently clear and enforceable.

Ultimately, the court upheld the enforceability of the expert determination, ruling that HHI was entitled to the payment of $499,839.88, plus interest, fees for the expert, and additional costs. This decision brought to a close the issue of the enforceability of the expert determination, which had been a significant point of contention between the parties.

Background

Background to the litigation

The litigation has been the subject of a judgment on interlocutory matters by Gray J, which was appealed to the Full Court. Consequent upon the orders of the Full Court, a separate trial was ordered in respect of one issue which was heard and determined by Anderson J and is now the subject of this appeal. It is unfortunate that both time and cost have been expended on matters which could have been determined in the substantive proceedings which, at this stage, have not progressed.BackgroundGeneral The dispute arises out of the construction of twin bridges across the Port River at Port Adelaide. The State government engaged Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd (“Abigroup”) to design and construct the bridges which were to span the Port River and provide access to both rail and road traffic across the Port River. Abigroup engaged Hardesty and Hanover LLP (“HHL”) to provide certain design services in relation to the opening sections of the rail and road bridges for the purposes of enabling Abigroup to price and submit a response to an invitation to tender for the project. HHL is a limited liability partnership and is associated with Hardesty and Hanover International LLC (“HHI”), which is a limited liability company incorporated in the United States of America and holding itself out as having expertise as a bridge design engineer. Abigroup alleges that, on 3 June 2004, it entered into a contract with HHL pursuant to which HHL agreed to provide expert advice in respect of the tender phase of the project. Abigroup alleges that the preliminary design work performed by HHL did not comply with the invitation to tender for the project and that it suffered loss and damage due to the negligence of HHL in the performance of the contract. Abigroup alleges loss and damage in the sum of $2,851,704.13, consequent upon the breach of contract and negligence. On 8 July 2005, Abigroup won the tender to design and construct the bridges. It entered into Heads of Agreement with Transport SA, the South Australian government instrumentality assigned the task of building the bridges. On 3 November 2006, HHI entered into an agreement with Abigroup, referred to as the Consultant Services Agreement (“CSA”), pursuant to which HHI agreed to provide services in relation to the opening spans of the road and rail bridges, including a detailed design and construction support service for the project. Abigroup alleges that HHI failed to exercise due skill in the performance and completion of its obligations under the CSA. In general terms, the CSA provides that Abigroup is required to pay a progressive fee to HHI with a mechanism for progress payments to be adjusted if the scope of services provided by HHI is varied. HHI is entitled to monetary compensation for variations. The agreement provides that the adjusted fee is to be agreed or, if the parties fail to agree an adjustment to the fee and Abigroup directs HHI to proceed with the work, then the fee will be adjusted according to the rates set out in the agreement, or based on reasonable rates as valued by Abigroup. If HHI disagrees with Abigroup’s valuation, the CSA provides procedures for the resolution of disputes. The Dispute Resolution Procedures in the CSA has a primary focus on this appeal. In particular, whether the process provided for in the CSA was followed.The dispute resolution provisions

Decision

Reasons for decision

VANSTONE J
On 7 March 2008, HHI commenced a cross-action against Abigroup seeking a declaration that the expert determination made on 28 February 2008 was binding upon Abigroup, and seeking payment of $499,839.88, plus interest, plus $8217.50 in respect of fees of the expert, and a further $3583 by way of fees for the expert. HHI made application that the issue of whether Mr Fullerton’s determination was binding be tried separately.[4] HHI also sought summary judgment in respect of its cross‑action. [4] Supreme Court Rules 2006, r 211.The decision of Gray J The issue for Gray J was the application for a separate trial on the issue of enforceability of the expert determination and an urgent determination of that preliminary issue. During the course of the proceedings before Gray J, the parties agreed that Abigroup would pay an amount of $516,631.72, which was made up of the primary claim, plus interest, to HHI. HHI was to provide an irrevocable guarantee by a bank securing Abigroup’s position in respect of the abovementioned payment, so that if ultimately HHI failed in its claim, Abigroup would be guaranteed repayment. That guarantee was to be irrevocable and for a period of four years. The parties entered into a written agreement on 26 May 2008, which was annexed as a schedule to the order of Gray J, in which he stayed the application for summary judgment. Clause 4 of that agreement provided as follows:[5]The parties agree that this agreement does not to (sic) settle the question of whether Determination No. 1 is binding upon the plaintiff or if the First Defendant is or was ever entitled to any payment from the Plaintiff having regard to the issues in the proceeding, or vice versa, and that these questions still require resolution by the court. This agreement is accordingly made without prejudice to the plaintiff’s contentions that no money is due from the Plaintiff to the First Defendant but rather monies are due from the First Defendant to the Plaintiff, and without prejudice to the First Defendant’s contention that, absent this agreement, it would have been entitled to summary judgment.[5] AB 1156. On 30 May 2008, Gray J advised the parties that he did not intend to make an order for separate trials on the preliminary issue of the validity of the expert’s determination. He published reasons on 8 September 2008. In his reasons, he referred to the compromise to which I have earlier referred. He said:[6]In the course of the interlocutory proceedings, substantial progress was made toward a compromise involving a payment by Abigroup to HHI in respect of the amount determined by the expert, but subject to a secured obligation to repay in the event that HHI is ultimately unsuccessful in its claims. Earlier attempts by the parties to negotiate a settlement of this aspect of the matter had been unsuccessful, but a settlement at least in principle has now been reached. Abigroup is prepared to make a payment and it has required what appears to be reasonable security. As HHI has no assets in the jurisdiction, a guarantee from a bank within the jurisdiction has been sought. Negotiations continued for several weeks, culminating in an agreement in principle. The agreement, however, is yet to be executed. HHI has suggested in an unspecified way that the sub-prime collapse in the United States has caused a problem in providing a bank guarantee. However, what is clear is that Abigroup is prepared to make payment, subject to the secured obligation to repay in the event that the Court determines such an entitlement. This arrangement has taken the urgency out of HHI’s application. The problem with giving effect to the arrangement is a problem arising from HHI’s assets being out of the jurisdiction.Against this background, the Court has explored the way to progress this difficult and complex litigation in a commercially expedient manner. Both parties are content to adopt a procedure designed to achieve this end. Abigroup, for its part, is content to agree to a fast-track procedure for the entire litigation. In its view, the proceedings could, with appropriate resourcing and priority, be ready for trial in October 2008.[6] AB 1177 [11] – [12].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: VANSTONE J

I can deal with each of the three issues I have identified relatively briefly.Operation of SC12 I am not persuaded that the judge’s finding as to SC12 was in error. I set out relevant parts of the two clauses.8.DISPUTE RESOLUTION8.1Settlement of DisputesIf a dispute or difference arises between the parties in relation to any matter the subject of this Agreement (“Dispute”), any party seeking to resolve the Dispute must do so strictly in accordance with the provisions of this clause.•A party seeking to resolve a Dispute must notify the existence and nature of the Dispute to the other party (“Notice of Dispute”).•Upon receipt of a Notice of Dispute the parties must negotiate in good faith to resolve the Dispute.If the parties fail to resolve the dispute or difference within seven (7) days after receipt by the other party of the Notice of Dispute, each party shall within a further seven (7) days nominate senior personnel to meet at a mutually convenient location.The senior personnel shall use their reasonable endeavours to resolve the dispute or difference and failing resolution of the dispute or difference shall explore and, if possible, agree on methods of resolving the dispute or difference by other means. At any such conference each party shall be represented by a person having authority to agree to a resolution of the dispute or difference. In the event that the dispute or difference cannot be resolved to the mutual satisfaction of the parties within twenty eight (28) days from commencement of the meeting of senior personnel then either party may refer the dispute for Expert Determination administered by the Australian Commercial Disputes Centre (ACDC). The Expert Determination shall be conducted in accordance with the ACDC Expert Determination Guidelines which set out the procedures to be adopted, the process of selection of the expert and the costs involved. Those guidelines are incorporated as terms of this Agreement. The expert determination shall be final and binding provided;(i) neither party gives notice to the other party within fourteen (14) days of the Expert Determination that they intend to refer the matter to arbitration or litigation and;(ii) the amount awarded does not exceed $500,000.Nothing in Clause 8 prejudices the right of either party to seek urgent injunctive or declaratory relief from a court in connection with a Dispute without first having complied with this Clause 8.Despite the existence of a Dispute, each party must continue to perform its obligations under this Agreement. In particular, [Abigroup] must continue to comply with its payment obligations, except that [Abigroup] is entitled to withhold its reasonable assessment of the amount the subject of the Dispute.andSC12ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTIONIn substitution of the provisions of Clauses GC 12(c) and GC 12(d) of the Agreement, within 7 days of a party receiving the notice referred to in Clause GC 12(b) of the Agreement, the Abigroup Representative and [Hardesty’s] Representative must meet and, in good faith, attempt to resolve the dispute or difference. If, within 14 days of this meeting, the dispute or difference is not resolved, the Division Managers (or their equivalents) of the parties must meet within 7 days of the expiry of that 14 day period and, in good faith, attempt to resolve the dispute or difference. If, within 21 days of the Division Manager’s meeting, the dispute or difference is not resolved, the General Managers (or their equivalents) of the respective parties must meet within 7 days of the expiry of that 21 day period and, in good faith, attempt to resolve the dispute or difference. (italics added)SC12.1Dispute resolution(a)Unless otherwise agreed, if, within 14 days of the General Managers’ meeting under Clause SC12, the dispute or difference is not resolved, it must:(i) be dealt with in accordance with this Clause SC 12.1; and(ii) be determined by an independent expert in the relevant field agreed upon and appointed jointly by Abigroup and [Hardesty].(b)If, within 7 days of the end of the period referred to in Clause SC 12.1(a) Abigroup and [Hardesty] cannot agree on the appointment of a person to act as the Independent expert, they must appoint the person nominated (on the application by either party) by the Chairperson or other senior officer for the time being of the Institution of Engineers, Australia or his or her nominee.(c)The dispute or difference must be referred to the expert (agreed or nominated pursuant to Clause SC 12.1(b)) by written notice in the form of Attachment 1 signed by both Abigroup and the Chief Executive Officer of [Hardesty].…(g)Abigroup and [Hardesty] must share equally the costs of the expert determination process.(h)Any determination made by an expert pursuant to this Clause SC 12.1 is final and binding upon Abigroup and [Hardesty] except where the determination:(i) requires a party to pay an amount in excess of $500,000; or(ii) relates to a dispute or difference with respect to a Claim for greater than $2,000,000.in which event the expert is deemed to be giving a non-binding appraisal and either party may commence litigation in respect of the dispute if it has not been resolved within 28 days of the expert giving his or her decision.