470 St Kilda Road Pty Ltd v Robinson

Link copied
Case Copied 61 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

470 St Kilda Road v Robinson [2013] FCA 1420

Citation: 470 St Kilda Road v Robinson [2013] FCA 1420
Parties: 470 ST KILDA ROAD PTY LIMITED (ACN 006 075 341) v GLENN ROY ROBINSON; GLENN ROY ROBINSON; CHUBB INSURANCE COMPANY OF AUSTRALIA LIMITED (ACN 003 710 647)
File number: VID 284 of 2012
Judge: KENNY J
Date of judgment: 20 December 2013
Catchwords:

INSURANCE  - Directors’ and Officers’ liability insurance contract - Whether exclusion clause for acts or omissions “in the rendering of, or actual or alleged failure to render any professional services to a third party” applied – Whether “project management” is a profession within the meaning of that word in the contract – Principles relating to construction of exclusion clauses in contracts of insurance  – Meaning of “service”, “profession” and “professional service” - Whether cross-claimant’s conduct was done in the “rendering of a service” – Whether conduct done in the rendering of a “professional service” – Exclusion clause held not to apply – Separate Question answered “no”.

EVIDENCE – Objection to admissibility of expert report on basis that expert opinion intruded impermissibly on the judicial function of the Court – Opinions provided included construction of contract clauses in contest - Objection upheld - Application by cross-respondent under s 144(1)(b) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) to tender bundle of documents – Documents admitted into evidence.

Legislation: Building and Construction Industry Security of Payments Act 2002 (Vic)
Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)
Cases cited: Chemetics International Ltd v Commercial Union Assurance Company of Canada (1984) 11 DLR (4th) 754 Vero Insurance Ltd v Power Technologies Pty Ltd (2007) 14 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-745
Transfield Services (Australia) Pty Ltd v Hall (2008) 75 NSWLR 12
Major Engineering Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd (2011) 282 ALR 363
The Life Insurance Company of Australia Ltd v Phillips (1925) 36 CLR 60
Toomey v Scolaro’s Concrete Constructions Pty Ltd (in liq) (No 5) (2002) 12 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-519
Eastern Creek Holdings Pty Ltd v Axis Specialty Europe Ltd (2010) 16 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-854
Baulderstone Hornibrook Engineering Pty Ltd v Gordian Runoff Ltd [2008] NSWCA 243
Royal Brompton Hospital NHS Trust v Hammond (No 9) [2002] EWHC 2037
Trustees of Ampleforth Abbey Trust v Turner & Townsend Management Ltd [2012] EWHC 2137
Allstate Life Insurance Co v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (No 6) (1996) 64 FCR 79
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Vines (2003) 48 ACSR 291
Prentice v Cummins (2002) 124 FCR 67
McCann v Switzerland Insurance Australia Limited (2000) 203 CLR 579
CGU Insurance Limited v Porthouse (2008) 235 CLR 103 Darlington Futures Limited v Delco Australia Pty Ltd (1986) 161 CLR 500
Selected Seeds Pty Ltd v QBEMM Pty Ltd (2010) 242 CLR 336
North v Marina (2003) 11 BPR 21
Fitzpatrick v Job (2007) 14 ANZ Insurance Cases 61-731 Trickett v Queensland Insurance Co Ltd [1936] AC 159
Bashtannyk v New India Assurance Co…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read 470 St Kilda Road Pty Ltd v Robinson and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 1420
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of 470 St Kilda Road Pty Ltd v Robinson involved a dispute over a directors' and officers' liability insurance policy. The central issue was whether an exclusion clause in the insurance policy applied to exclude coverage for an act or omission that was part of the rendering of professional services to a third party. Specifically, the question was whether the act of providing a statutory declaration in support of a progress claim was done in the rendering of professional services. The case also addressed an evidentiary issue concerning the admissibility of an expert report on the interpretation of contract clauses. The court was required to determine the meaning of certain terms in the insurance policy, such as "service", "profession", and "professional service", and whether the exclusion clause applied to the facts of the case.

The court's reasoning focused on the construction of the exclusion clause and the interpretation of the terms "service", "profession", and "professional service". The court found that the statutory declaration was not an act done in the rendering of professional services, but rather a final product arising from the detailed analyses and collations that underpinned it. The court held that the exclusion clause did not apply because the act of providing the statutory declaration was not part of the rendering of professional services. Additionally, the court ruled that the expert report was inadmissible because it intruded on the judicial function of the court by providing opinions on the construction of contract clauses. The court also allowed the tender of a bundle of documents under section 144(1)(b) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth).

The final orders of the court determined that the statutory declaration was not an act or omission in the rendering of professional services, and thus the exclusion clause did not apply. The court also ordered the parties to file an agreed minute of order as to costs or, if they could not agree, to file and serve submissions as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The question ordered to be separately answered be determined as follows:

Question:

Whether the cross-claimant’s statutory declaration made on 12 December 2011 was an actual or alleged act or omission “in the rendering of, or actual or alleged failure to render any professional services to a third party”, within the meaning of exclusion IV(A)(v) of the Directors’ and Officers’ Liability Coverage Section of the Policy of Insurance referred to in the statement of cross-claim as policy of insurance number 93301062.

Answer:

No.

2. On or before 17 January 2014, the parties file an agreed minute of order as to costs or, failing agreement, file and serve submissions as to costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Included in volume 2 of the Tender Bundle was Mr Robinson’s affidavit, sworn on 6 July 2012.BACKGROUND The following facts were agreed between the parties. At the relevant time, Mr Robinson was employed by Reed Constructions Australia Pty Ltd (“Reed”) – a company now in liquidation – as its Chief Operating Officer (“COO”). Reed Construction was in the business of constructing medium to large buildings and other construction projects. Mr Robinson became Reed’s COO in April 2011. Before that date he had been Reed’s National Operations Director. Mr Robinson had commenced working with the Reed Group companies in 1987 as a Site Foreman. He re-joined the Reed Group in 1993 as a Project Supervisor, after spending three years with Baulderstone Hornibrook as a Site Manager. Mr Robinson was not at any time a director of Reed or any other company in the Reed Group. In or about October 2010, the applicant in the principal proceeding, 470 St Kilda Road Pty Ltd, and Reed entered into a written design and construct contract (“the D&C Contract”) relating to a construction project known as the ‘Leopold Project’ situated at 470 St Kilda Road in Melbourne. 470 St Kilda Road Pty Ltd was the ‘Principal’ and Reed was the ‘Contractor’ under the D&C Contract. Reshape Development Pty Ltd (“Reshape”) was appointed as the Principal's Representative under the D&C Contract. The Building and Construction Industry Security of Payments Act 2002 (Vic) (“the SOP Act”) applied to the D&C Contract. The terms of the D&C Contract were contained in a formal instrument of agreement with annexures titled ‘Design and Construction Contract for Major Domestic Building Projects in Victoria AS4902-2000 As Amended’ and dated 25 October 2010. Under the terms of the D&C Contract: (a) Reed was required to claim payments for work performed under the D&C Contract on a progressive basis (“progress claims”); and (b) 470 St Kilda Road Pty Ltd could request that Reed provide documentary evidence in support of progress claims. From time to time, Mr Robinson made statutory declarations in support of progress claims that included details of payments made to subcontractors. 470 St Kilda Road Pty Ltd requested that Reed provide documentary evidence in support of Progress Claim No 15. In December 2011, Aaron Tranter, who was at that time employed by Reed as the Contracts Manager for the Leopold Project, requested that Mr Robinson execute a statutory declaration in support of Progress Claim No 15. Mr Robinson made a statutory declaration on 12 December 2011 in support of Progress Claim No 15 (“the Statutory Declaration”). Reed submitted the Statutory Declaration to Reshape on 12 December 2011. Reshape issued a Certificate of Payment for Progress Claim No 15 in the amount of $1,426,641.70 (inclusive of GST) to 470 St Kilda Road Pty Ltd on 21 December 2011. Chubb issued a directors and officers liability insurance policy to Reed Building Group Pty Ltd and its subsidiaries (which included Reed) for the policy period 25 July 2011 at 4 pm to 25 July 2012 at 4 pm (“the D&O Policy”). Mr Robinson falls within the definition of an ‘Insured Person’ under the D&O Policy.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In summarising its argument about the D&C Contract, senior counsel for Chubb contended that:[T]he institution … of all the necessary systems relating to quality, health, safety, completion of work, quality of work, payment of subcontractors, all the necessary systems, are integral parts of the project management system that has to be put in place by the contractor. The provision of the statutory declaration that was the method of supplying the evidence under clause 38 is an aspect of that overall system of project management that the contractor is obliged to put in place and pursuant to those systems the contractor delivers a range of services to the building owner, not least of which is a project efficiently and safely completed on time with no outstanding claims from subcontractors or others. Senior counsel for Chubb argued:[T]he effect of Mr Robinson’s affidavit and his questions and answers is that a large part of the contractual task was the project management of this project which required the establishment of systems for a whole range of matters including payment claims and payments to subcontractors. Those systems included insuring, so far as possible, that contracts were back to back so you had similar obligations cast on the subcontractor as the principal contractor had and Mr Robinson says that he relied on the company’s systems and project managers individually for the information that underpinned the statutory declaration that he deposed to. He is at the very apex of a large pyramid and there are a lot of work and systems that the statutory declaration was founded upon and they had to be good because of the liability that he was exposing both himself and the company to by making a statutory declaration.(Included in volume 1 of the Tender Bundle was a document setting out questions apparently addressed to Mr Robinson and answers). Chubb submitted that, in the present case, it was important to recognise that the question posed by the exclusion clause was not whether the act or omission is the rendering of a professional service but whether the act or omission is in the rendering of, or failure to render, any professional services. Chubb contended that “it may give rise to error to focus too narrowly upon the act or omission in question and to consider only whether, of itself and in isolation, it bears a professional character”. Rather, so Chubb said, the act or omission must be characterised by reference to the overall context in which it occurred. Viewed in this way, Chubb submitted that the provision by Reed of documentary evidence in accordance with cl 38.1 of the D&C Contract was a step in the rendering of project management services, and therefore professional services, by Reed to 470 St Kilda Road Pty Ltd. At the hearing, senior counsel for Chubb submitted that:The act [of providing the Statutory Declaration] can’t be divorced from what it’s supported by because the phrase is whether that action was committed in the course of rendering, and so if it is simply the product of all of the detailed analyses and collations that underpin it, it’s not distinct. It’s not separate from. It’s the final product that arose in the course of rendering those professional services, and they are being rendered to the third party because in a condensed short form, as required by the banks and the contractor – and the owner, the contractor is providing effectively a certificate in the form of the statutory declaration that this is the financial position.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.