Trustees Executors Limited v Fund Managers Canterbury Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2014-485-4040 [2016] NZHC 2194

BETWEEN

TRUSTEES EXECUTORS LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

FUND MANAGERS CANTERBURY LIMITED

First Defendant

DELOITTE Second Defendant

DELOITTE LIMITED Third Defendant

GRAEME MAIN Fourth Defendant

ALEXANDER DONALD MCBEATH, PAUL ERNEST MCEWAN, ALAN WILLIAM PRESCOTT, GEOFFREY READ THOMAS, ANDREW HENDRA YOUNG and OLIVER RODERICK MATSON

Fifth Defendants

AND

YOGESH MODY
First Third Party (Struck Out)

AIG INSURANCE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Second Third Party

Hearing: 26 April 2016

Counsel:

C M Stevens and I Tokmadzic for Plaintiff
I G Hunt and D R Weatherley for First and Fifth Defendants
J E Standage for Second and Third Defendants
H D P van Schreven for Fourth Defendant
A C Challis for Second Third Party

Judgment:

16 September 2016

TRUSTEES EXECUTORS LIMITED v FUND MANAGERS CANTERBURY LIMITED [2016] NZHC 2194 [16 September 2016]

JUDGMENT OF ELLIS J

I direct that the delivery time of this judgment is

2 pm on the 16th day of September 2016

Table of Contents

Background  [5] Canterbury Mortgage Trust Group Investment Fund  [5] The Trust Deed  [7] The Mortgage Management Agreement  [19] The Guidelines  [23] Manuals  [28] The Directors  [29] Mr Main  [31] Suspension of the Fund  [33]

The insurance policies and the claim  [34] The D&O Policy   [37] The PI Policy   [44] The claims   [49] The preliminary question  [56] The law  [60] General principles  [60] Relevant authorities  [63] Analysis: this case  [64] Interpreting Endorsement 005  [64] Conclusion  [84]

[1]      The Canterbury Mortgage Trust Group Investment Fund (the Fund) was suspended on 4 June 2008.  It was wound up in early 2009.  This proceeding forms part of the legal fall-out.   In it, the trustee of the Fund sues the company charged with managing the Fund, together with its directors and general manager for alleged breaches of duty and other obligations.   Consequential  issues of indemnity and insurance have arisen.  In particular, there is a dispute about whether insurance cover for the claims against the directors and general manager is excluded by an endorsement on the company’s “Directors and Officers” insurance policy.

[2]      On 22 February 2016 Williams J ordered (by consent) that there be a hearing of a preliminary question under r 10.15 in relation to that issue.

[3]      Although the key legal documents were before me by consent, no evidence was filed in relation to the preliminary question itself.   Rather, the relevant background  was  the  subject  of  an  agreed  (for  the  purposes  of  the  preliminary question only) statement of facts.   That agreed statement largely comprised a summary of the legal documents.  No formal case was stated in terms of r 10.20.1

[4]      Although my rehearsal of the background below is based on that agreed statement I have interpolated other aspects of the legal documents which I also regard as relevant.

Background

Canterbury Mortgage Trust Group Investment Fund

[5]      The Canterbury Mortgage Trust (the CMT) was established on 12 July 1999. Trustees Executors Ltd (TEL) was the trustee of the CMT. The CMT was a unit trust which was the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trustees Executors Limited v Fund Managers Canterbury Limite... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 2194
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Trustees Executors Limited (the plaintiff) brought an action against Fund Managers Canterbury Limited (FMC) and others, alleging breaches of duty and other obligations related to the management of the Canterbury Mortgage Trust Group Investment Fund. The plaintiff sought damages and consequential indemnity and insurance issues were also raised. The directors and general manager of FMC (the defendants) were insured under a Directors and Officers Liability Insurance policy (the D&O Policy) which contained an endorsement excluding cover for loss in connection with any claim arising out of the insured's performance of professional services for others for a fee. The preliminary question before the court was whether the giving of the certificates and confirmations constituted the performance of professional services for others for a fee within the meaning of the endorsement. The court found that the giving of the certificates and confirmations did constitute the performance of professional services for others for a fee and that cover for the claims against the directors and general manager was therefore excluded by Endorsement 005 of the D&O policy. The court further found that the claims against the directors and general manager would be covered by the Professional Indemnity policy.