Stone & Rolls Ltd (in liq) v Moore Stephens (a firm)

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read
HOUSE OF LORDS SESSION 2008–09
[2009] UKHL 39

on appeal from:[2008] EWCA Civ 644

OPINIONS

OF THE LORDS OF APPEAL

FOR JUDGMENT IN THE CAUSE

Moore Stephens (a firm) (Respondents) v Stone Rolls Limited (in liquidation (Appellants)

Appellate Committee

Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers


Lord Scott of Foscote
Lord Walker of Gestingthorpe
Lord Brown of Eaton-under-Heywood
Lord Mance

Counsel

Appellant:  Respondent:
Michael Brindle QC QC
Mark Simpson QC Jonathan Sumption QC
David Murray Tom Adam QC
(Instructed by Norton Rose LLP) (Instructed by Barlow Lyde & Gilbert LLP)

Hearing dates:

10-12 FEBRUARY 2009

ON
THURSDAY 30 JULY 2009

HOUSE OF LORDS

OPINIONS OF THE LORDS OF APPEAL FOR JUDGMENT

IN THE CAUSE

Moore Stephens (a firm) (Respondents) v Stone Rolls Limited (in

liquidation) (Appellants)

[2009] UKHL 39

LORD PHILLIPS OF WORTH MATRAVERS

My Lords,

Introduction

1. Mr Stojevic is a fraudster. He used the appellant company, (“S&R”) as a vehicle for defrauding banks. The fraud was discovered and both S&R and Mr Stojevic were successfully sued for deceit by the principal victim, Komercni Bank SA (“the Bank”). The respondent, Moore Stephens, were S&R’s auditors. Moore Stephens accept that they owed S&R a duty to exercise reasonable skill and care in carrying out their duties as auditors. For purposes of the present argument they also accept that they were in breach of that duty and that, but for their breach, the fraud that Mr Stojevic was perpetrating through S&R would have ended earlier. In this action S&R seek to recover losses caused to them in consequence of the extension of the period of their fraudulent activity that they submit was caused by Moore Stephens’ breach of duty. Moore Stephens contend that this claim cannot succeed because it is founded on S&R’s fraud and is met by the defence commonly described by the Latin maxim “ex turpi causa non oritur actio” (“ex turpi causa”). Whether ex turpi causa provides a defence to the claim advanced by S&R is the preliminary issue raised by this appeal.

2. Although he was a ‘shadow director’ acting under power of attorney and the shares in S&R are held in the name of a family trust it has been common ground that Mr Stojevic was the sole directing mind and will and the beneficial owner of S&R.

3. I have had the benefit of reading in draft the opinion of each of your Lordships. Each has summarised the nature of the fraud perpetrated by Mr Stojevic through S&R. It involved S&R obtaining payments under letters of credit by presenting to banks false documents in relation to fictitious commodity trading. My noble and learned friend Lord Mance has explained in a little more detail how the fraud worked. When the fraud was ultimately discovered, the monies fraudulently obtained by S&R had all been paid away to other participants in the fraud. The damages awarded to the Bank against S&R and Mr Stojevic exceed $94 million. Neither defendant could satisfy the judgment. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Stone & Rolls Ltd (in liq) v Moore Stephens (a firm) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] UKHL 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The House of Lords, in a 3-2 decision, dismissed an appeal brought by the liquidators of Stone & Rolls Limited (S&R) against a decision of the Court of Appeal that had dismissed their claim against Moore Stephens, the company's auditors, for breach of duty. The appeal was dismissed on the basis of the principle of ex turpi causa, which precludes a claimant from recovering compensation for the consequences of their own illegal conduct. S&R, which had been used as a vehicle for fraud by Mr Stojevic, sought to recover losses caused by the continuation of the fraud as a result of Moore Stephens' breach of their duty of care as auditors. The Court of Appeal had struck out the claim on the basis that it was founded on S&R's own fraud and was therefore precluded by the defence of ex turpi causa. The House of Lords was divided on whether the principle applied in these circumstances. Lord Scott of Foscote and Lord Mance concluded that it did not, on the basis that the auditors' duty extended to protecting the interests of the company, including its creditors, in the event of insolvency. Lord Walker of Gestingthorpe and Lord Brown of Eaton-under Heywood held that it did apply, on the basis that the fraud should be attributed to the company, and that the company was not entitled to recover for the consequences of its own fraud. Lord Phillips of Worth Matravers concluded that ex turpi causa did provide a defence to the claim in these circumstances. The House's decision was based on the principle that the auditors' duty of care did not extend to protecting the interests of the company in circumstances where the sole shareholder and directing mind of the company was responsible for the fraud. The majority of the House concluded that the auditors' duty was owed to the company for the benefit of its shareholders and that the fact that the sole shareholder was also responsible for the fraud did not mean that the fraud should not be attributed to the company. However, the House was divided on whether the auditors' duty extended to protecting the interests of the company's creditors in the event of insolvency. The minority concluded that it did, and that the principle of ex turpi causa did not preclude the company from recovering for the consequences of its own fraud in these circumstances. The decision of the House of Lords is significant in establishing the scope of the auditors' duty of care and the extent to which the principle of ex turpi causa applies in cases of corporate fraud. It also highlights the difficulties of attributing fraud to a company and the potential consequences of such attribution for the company's ability to recover for the consequences of its own fraud. The decision is likely to have implications for the liability of auditors in cases of corporate fraud and the protection of creditors and other stakeholders in such cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.