JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd (in liq) v Milton

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd (in liq) v Milton [2021] QSC 59

PARTIES:

JM KELLY BUILDERS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 009 801 665

(first plaintiff)
and
KAWANA JOINERY CO PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)
ACN 010 109 038
(second plaintiff)
and
BURNS & TWIGG PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 009 658 057
(third plaintiff)
and
BPM COWLRICK PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 010 366 300
(fourth plaintiff)

v
ARNOLD VINCENT MILTON

(first defendant)
and
ARNOLD MILTON PTY LTD

ACN 001 922 603
(second defendant)

FILE NO/S:

No 8790 of 2020

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

26 March 2021

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

9 December 2020

JUDGE:

Flanagan J

ORDER:

1.    The application is dismissed.

2.    I will hear the parties as to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS – PLEADINGS – STRIKING OUT – DISCLOSING NO REASONABLE CAUSE OF ACTION OR DEFENCE – where the defendants submit that the plaintiffs have suffered no loss – where the alleged loss consists of accrued and unpaid liabilities to trade creditors incurred during a period of trading following the defendants’ alleged negligence – where it is alleged that the plaintiffs would have ceased trading if the defendants had discharged their tortious and contractual duties – where it is alleged that liabilities could not have been incurred if the plaintiffs had ceased trading – where there is no allegation of misappropriation of the plaintiffs’ assets – whether a deficit of assets to liabilities after a period of trading is a recoverable form of loss

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld), r 171, r 658

BCI Finances Pty Ltd (in liq) v Binetter (No 4) (2016) 117 ACSR 18; [2016] FCA 1351, considered
Bilta (UK) Ltd (in liq) v Nazir (No 2) [2016] AC 1; [2015] UKSC 23, considered
Re PrimeSpace Property Investment Ltd (in liq) [2017] NSWSC 386, considered
Singularis Holdings Ltd (in liq) v Daiwa Capital Markets Europe Ltd [2020] AC 1189; [2019] UKSC 50, cited
Spencer v Commonwealth (2010) 241 CLR 118; [2010] HCA 28, applied
Stone & Rolls Ltd (in liq) v Moore Stephens (a firm) [2009] 1 AC 1391; [2009] UKHL 39, considered

Travel Compensation Fund v Tambree (2005) 224 CLR 627; [2005] HCA 69, cited

COUNSEL:

C Heyworth-Smith QC, with M de Waard, for the defendants/applicants
C Wilkins, with A Psaltis, for the plaintiffs/respondents

SOLICITORS:

Mills Oakley Lawyers for the defendants/applicants
Clayton Utz for the plaintiffs/respondents

  1. The defendants apply for two orders: an order that the plaintiffs’ statement of claim be struck out pursuant to r 171(1)(a) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld) (UCPR) on the basis that it discloses no reasonable cause of action, and an order that the plaintiffs’ claim be dismissed pursuant to r 658(1).[1] 

    [1]Rule 658(1) provides that the court may, at any stage of a proceeding, on the application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd (in liq) v Milton and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QSC 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd (in liq) v Milton, the liquidators of JM Kelly Builders sought to recover damages from Milton and two other defendants for alleged negligence and breach of contract. The claim arose from a dispute over the renewal of building permits and associated financial losses incurred by the company during a period of trading following the alleged negligence. The defendants moved to strike out the statement of claim on various grounds, including the assertion that the liquidators had no standing to claim the accrued liabilities of the company as a loss.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the liquidators could recover the accrued and unpaid liabilities to trade creditors incurred during a period of trading following the defendants’ alleged negligence as a recoverable form of loss. The defendants argued that the accrued liabilities were not a loss suffered by the plaintiffs, as they had not been paid, and thus could not be recovered. The liquidators, on the other hand, contended that the liabilities constituted a loss because the company would have ceased trading if the defendants had discharged their duties, thereby avoiding the accrual of those liabilities.

The court dismissed the application to strike out the statement of claim. The court held that the liquidators had standing to bring the action under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and that the accrued liabilities to trade creditors constituted a recoverable form of loss. The court found that the liquidators had adequately pleaded the elements of the causes of action for negligence and breach of contract, including the duty of care, breach, causation, and damages. The court also noted that the liquidators had particularised the losses in the statement of claim, providing specific amounts for each category of loss.

In conclusion, the court dismissed the application to strike out the statement of claim and ordered the parties to discuss costs. The liquidators were permitted to proceed with their claim for damages arising from the accrued liabilities to trade creditors incurred during a period of trading following the defendants’ alleged negligence.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application is dismissed.

2. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This is a sufficient summary of the pleading for the purposes of determining the application.Consideration(a) Nine grounds for striking out The defendants’ written submissions identify nine defects in the statement of claim which are said to be fatal to the plaintiffs’ claim. The defendants submit that these nine defects or any one of them reveals “that the case theory on which the claim is based is fundamentally flawed”.[12][12]Defendants’ Outline of Argument, paragraph 15. Those defects are, in my words, that:1.the alleged loss is the creditors’ loss, not the plaintiffs’ loss;2.other than pursuant to the liquidation process in the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), the plaintiffs do not have standing to commence an action in the Court for recovery of the creditors’ losses;3.the statement of claim fails to adequately plead that the defendants owed the plaintiffs a duty of care to avoid pure economic loss to the plaintiffs’ creditors;4.the pleaded case is a “no transaction case” and the plaintiffs have failed to adequately plead the counterfactual (that is, what would have happened if the licences had not been renewed);5.the alleged loss has been inadequately quantified;6.the element of causation has not been satisfied because:(a) firstly, there was an intervening event, being Ms Murphy’s intentional alteration of the MFR Reports; and(b) secondly, Ms Murphy’s knowledge and conduct can be attributed to the plaintiffs and the plaintiffs cannot rely on their own wrongs to recover damages;7.the statement of claim inadequately pleads the existence, terms or breach of any contract between the parties;8.the statement of claim does not plead the essential elements of negligence against the second defendant; and9.the statement of claim does not adequately state the nature and amount of the damages sought as required by r 155 of the UCPR. The first to fifth and ninth points in the defendants’ outline are all based on the defendants’ principal complaint that a plaintiff suffers no loss by incurring a liability which it does not pay. The sixth, seventh and eighth points raise different complaints and are dealt with separately below.(b) Grounds 1 to 5 & 9 – “no loss” submission As set out at [18] above, paragraph 212 of the statement of claim pleads that each of the plaintiffs has suffered the following losses:·unrelated party trade debts;·related party trade debts;·employee entitlements; and·loan debts in favour of NAB. The loss is not further particularised, other than by providing the specific amounts that pertain to each category in respect of each plaintiff. The defendants submit that these alleged losses are properly characterised asthe creditors’ losses and are not, in law, recoverable by the plaintiffs.[13] The defendants assert that amounts which have not been paid cannot amount to a lossbut they have provided no authority in support of this submission. As explained by Ms Heyworth-Smith QC for the defendants in the course of the hearing:“… we have not referred to a particular authority to say that if a payment hasn’t been made it will not be able to be recovered, but by the same token we also say that our learned friend doesn’t have an authority to support their position in this case.”[14][13]Defendants’ Outline of Argument, paragraph 19.[14]T 1-11, lines 41-44.