Easter Term
[2021] UKSC 16
On appeal from: [2019] EWCA Civ 364
Appellants Respondents Robin Mathew QC Kevin Prosser QC James Couser Stephen Ryan
Nicholas Trompeter
(Instructed by ASW (Instructed by Addleshaw Solicitors (Liverpool))
Goddard LLP (Manchester))
Appellants:-
| (1) | Rossendale Borough Council |
| (2) | Wigan Council |
Respondents:-
| (1) | Hurstwood Properties (A) Ltd |
| (2) | Hurstwood Properties (C) Ltd |
| (3) | Hurstwood Properties (I) Ltd |
| (4) | Hurstwood Properties (R) Ltd |
| (5) | Hurstwood Properties (Y) Ltd |
| (6) | Hurstwood Group 1 Ltd |
| (7) | Property Alliance Group Ltd |
LORD BRIGGS AND LORD LEGGATT: (with whom Lord Reed, Lord
Hodge and Lord Kitchin agree)
Introduction
1. The question on these appeals is whether the appellant local authorities have reasonable grounds for claiming non-domestic rates on certain empty properties from the respondent companies. In bare outline, non-domestic rates (or business rates) are charged on the occupier of a property which is not a domestic property or, if the property is unoccupied, on the owner of the property, subject to certain exceptions. The owner is defined as the person entitled to possession of the property. One of the exceptions is where the owner (as defined) is a company in liquidation, including voluntary liquidation. The respondents are the registered owners of various unoccupied commercial properties who have sought to avoid liability for business rates by means of one or other of two closely related schemes.
2. Both schemes involve setting up a special purpose vehicle (“SPV”) in the form of a company without any assets or business. The registered owner grants a short lease of the unoccupied property to the SPV. The premise of the schemes is that the SPV thereupon becomes the “owner” of the property for the purpose of the liability for business rates. The SPV is immediately put into members’ voluntary liquidation or, alternatively, is dissolved. In the liquidation version of the scheme, reliance is then placed for as long as possible on the exemption which applies where the owner of the property is being wound up. The dissolution version of the scheme relies on the fact that, upon dissolution, the lease and associated liability for rates is automatically transferred by law as bona vacantia to the Crown (or, as appropriate, to the Duchy of Lancaster or Cornwall). Meanwhile the registered owner is relieved from paying business rates, either until it terminates the lease because it has a tenant or other use for the property or until the lease is disclaimed by the liquidator or by the Crown.
3. On the assumption that the schemes work at all, both versions rely for their effectiveness over time upon administrative inertia. In the liquidation version of the scheme, the period until the necessarily onerous leases are disclaimed by the liquidator is deliberately prolonged. In the dissolution version, there may be delay before the SPV is dissolved; thereafter the scheme relies upon the unlikelihood that the local authority will find out about the dissolution for a considerable time, and then prompt the unsuspecting Crown to disclaim the lease. In either version…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Rossendale Borough Council v Hurstwood properties (A) Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2021] UKSC 16
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central question in these appeals is whether the schemes employed by the respondents are effective to make the SPVs the owners of the properties for the purpose of the liability for business rates. The Court of Appeal decided that the claims should be struck out because the leases were effective to make the SPVs the owners of the properties, and because there was no principle which would justify "piercing the corporate veil" to hold the respondents liable for the rates.
The Supreme Court has allowed the appeals and set aside the order of the judge in so far as he struck out the claims that, on the proper interpretation of sections 45 and 65(1) of the 1988 Act, the leases were ineffective to make the SPVs the owners of the relevant properties, with the result that the respondents remained liable for business rates. The Court of Appeal's decision to strike out the claims based on "piercing the corporate veil" has been left undisturbed.
The Supreme Court has concluded that, on the assumed facts, the SPVs to which leases were granted as part of the schemes did not become "entitled to possession" of the demised property for the purposes of the 1988 Act. The SPVs had no real or practical control over whether the property was occupied or not, and such control remained at all times with the respondents. The Court has held that the definition of the "owner" in section 65(1) of the 1988 Act is to be interpreted as denoting in a normal case the person who as a matter of the law of real property has the immediate legal right to actual physical possession of the relevant property. However, in the unusual circumstances of this case, identifying "the person entitled to possession" as the person with the immediate legal right to possession would defeat the purpose of the legislation. The Court has held that Parliament cannot sensibly be taken to have intended that "the person entitled to possession" of an unoccupied property on whom the liability for rates is imposed should encompass a company which has no real or practical ability to exercise its legal right to possession and on which that legal right has been conferred for no purpose other than the avoidance of liability for rates.
The Supreme Court has also held that the attempt by the local authorities to "pierce the corporate veil" is wholly misplaced. The Court has concluded that there is no principle which could justify piercing the corporate veil on the assumed facts of this case, as the interposition of the SPVs did not evade or frustrate the law, but rather caused a liability for business rates to be incurred by the SPVs by granting them a lease. The Court has held that the abuse in the present case lies in the way in which the SPVs' liability for rates is then sought to be dealt with, by the abusive processes by which the SPVs are either dissolved or put into liquidation. The law provides comprehensive remedies for abusive behaviour of that kind, which do not require the piercing of any corporate veil.