VTB Capital Plc v Nutritek International Corp & Ors (Rev 1)

Link copied
Case Copied 152 min read

    Summary


    Hilary Term
    [2013] UKSC 5
    On appeal from: [2012] EWCA Civ 808

    JUDGMENT

    VTB Capital plc (Appellant) v Nutritek International Corp and others (Respondents)
    before
    Lord Neuberger, President
    Lord Mance
    Lord Clarke
    Lord Wilson
    Lord Reed
    JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

    6 February 2013

    Heard on 12, 13 and 14 November 2012
    Appellant
    Mark Howard QC
    Paul McGrath QC
    Iain Pester
    Tony Singla
    (Instructed by Herbert Smith Freehills LLP)
    2nd Respondent
    Michael Lazarus
    Christopher Burdin
    (Instructed by SJ Berwin LLP (up to 1st December 2012) and Fried, Frank, Harris, Shriver & Jacobson (London) LLP (from 1st December 2012))
       
      4th Respondent
    Mark Hapgood QC
    Stephen Rubin QC
    James McClelland
    (Instructed by by SJ Berwin LLP (up to 1st December 2012) and Fried, Frank, Harris, Shriver & Jacobson (London) LLP (from 1st December 2012))
    LORD MANCE
    Introduction
  1. The appellant, VTB Capital plc ("VTB"), is incorporated and registered, and authorised and regulated as a bank, in England. It is majority-owned by JSC VTB Bank ("VTB Moscow"), a state-owned bank based in Moscow. The first, second and fourth respondents are, respectively, Nutritek International Corp ("Nutritek"), Marshall Capital Holdings Ltd ("Marcap BVI"), both British Virgin Islands companies, and Mr Konstantin Malofeev, a Russian businessman resident in Moscow said to be the ultimate owner and controller of both, as well as of the third respondent, Marshall Capital LLC ("Marcap Moscow"), a Russian company which has not been served.
  2. The present case arises from a Facility Agreement dated 23 November 2007 ("the Facility Agreement") entered into between VTB and a Russian company, Russagroprom LLC ("RAP"), under which VTB advanced some US$225,050,000 to RAP. The advance was primarily to enable RAP to buy six Russian dairy companies and three associated companies ("the dairy companies") from Nutritek. After making three interest payments (and no payments of capital), RAP defaulted on the loan in November 2008. VTB believes the security provided for the loan to be worth only in the region of US$32m to US$40m.
  3. VTB's case is that it was induced in London to enter into the Facility Agreement, and an accompanying interest rate swap agreement, by misrepresentations made by Nutritek, for which the other respondents are jointly and severally liable. The misrepresentations alleged are, first, that RAP and Nutritek were not under common control, and second, that the value of the dairy companies was much greater than they were in fact worth. VTB's case is that the misrepresentations were fraudulent.
  4. In order to bring proceedings in tort in England against any of the respondents, VTB required permission to effect service on them out of the jurisdiction. Permission was obtained from Master Winegarten on 11 May 2011. The first, second and fourth respondents were served, and applied to set aside the service. In response, VTB applied for leave to amend its particulars of claim to add a contractual claim, seeking to hold the respondents liable for breach of the Facility Agreement and interest rate swap, on the basis that RAP's corporate veil could in the circumstances be pierced and the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read VTB Capital Plc v Nutritek International Corp & Ors (Rev 1) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] UKSC 5
Decision Date