R (Stirling) v Haringey London Borough Council

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

Michaelmas Term

[2014] UKSC 56

On appeal from: UKSC 2013/0116

JUDGMENT

R (on the application of Moseley (in substitution of Stirling Deceased)) (AP) (Appellant) v London Borough of Haringey (Respondent)

before

Lady Hale, Deputy President


Lord Kerr
Lord Clarke
Lord Wilson
Lord Reed

JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

29 October 2014

Appellant Respondent
Ian Wise QC Clive Sheldon QC
Jamie Burton Heather Emmerson
Samuel Jacobs
(Instructed by Irwin (Instructed by Legal
Mitchell LLP) Services, The London
Borough of Haringey)

LORD WILSON (with whom Lord Kerr agrees)

Introduction

1.         When Parliament requires a local authority to consult interested persons before making a decision which would potentially affect all of its inhabitants, what are the ingredients of the requisite consultation?

2.         Until 1 April 2013 there was a scheme in England for the payment of Council

Tax Benefit (“CTB”) for the relief, in whole or in part, of certain persons

from their annual obligation to pay council tax. The scheme was made by the Department for Work and Pensions and the duty of local authorities was only to operate it. From 1 April 2013, however, local authorities were required to

operate a new scheme, entitled a Council Tax Reduction Scheme (“CTRS”),

which they were required to have made for themselves. Before making a CTRS, local authorities were required to consult interested persons on a draft of it. Between August and November 2012 the London Borough of Haringey

(“Haringey”) purported to consult interested persons on its draft CTRS,

following which it made the scheme in substantial accordance with its draft.

3.         In these proceedings two single mothers, who were resident in Haringey and who until 1 April 2013 had been in receipt of what I will describe as full CTB (by which I mean at a level which had relieved them entirely of their obligation to pay council tax), applied for judicial review of the lawfulness of the consultation which Haringey had purported to conduct in relation to its draft CTRS. The women asked the court to quash the decision which on 17 January 2013 Haringey had made in the light of the consultation; and my

reference in paragraph 8 below to the “default scheme” will explain why the

quashing of the decision would have been very much in their interests. On 7 February 2013 Underhill J dismissed their application: [2013] EWHC 252 (Admin); [2013] ACD 62. The judge had allowed them to be anonymised as

“M” and “S”. The latter appealed to the Court of Appeal, which ruled that

she was not entitled to anonymity and should be referred to by name, Ms Stirling. On 12 February 2013, with astonishing alacrity referable no doubt to the deadline of 1 April 2013, the court heard the appeal. On 22 February 2013, by a judgment of Sullivan LJ with which Sir Terence Etherton, the Chancellor of the High Court, agreed, and by a judgment of Pitchford LJ in which he disagreed with one aspect of the reasoning of Sullivan LJ but concurred in the proposed result,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R (Stirling) v Haringey London Borough Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] UKSC 56
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court was asked to determine whether the London Borough of Haringey (Haringey) had properly consulted with interested parties before implementing a Council Tax Reduction Scheme (CTRS) which reduced the level of relief from council tax for certain residents. The primary issue was whether Haringey's consultation process met the statutory requirement to consult "such other persons as it considers are likely to have an interest in the operation of the scheme." The Court needed to decide whether Haringey's consultation, which did not mention alternative options for meeting the shortfall in government funding, was lawful and sufficient.

The Supreme Court found that Haringey's consultation process was inadequate. The consultation document and accompanying letter from Mr. Ellicott, Head of Revenues, Benefits, and Customer Services, implied that the reduction in relief from council tax was an inevitable consequence of government funding cuts, without mentioning other possible ways to address the shortfall, such as increasing council tax or cutting services. The consultation failed to provide interested parties with an understanding of the full range of options and reasons for Haringey's choices, which is essential for meaningful public participation in the decision-making process. The Court concluded that fairness required brief reference to other ways of absorbing the shortfall and the reasons for rejecting them. The consultation process was therefore found to be unlawful and insufficient.

The Court did not find it necessary to order Haringey to undertake a fresh consultation exercise for the forthcoming year, as it was unclear whether Haringey intended to revise its CTRS. However, if Haringey did intend to revise its CTRS, it would likely undertake the consultation in accordance with the Court's judgments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established