Wellington City Council v Minotaur Custodians Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link       

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA120/2016
[2017] NZCA 302

BETWEEN

WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL
Appellant

AND

MINOTAUR CUSTODIANS LTD
Respondent

Hearing:

16 March 2017

Court:

Brown, S France and J Williams JJ

Counsel:

A L Holloway and E B Sweet for Appellant
P S J Withnall for Respondent

Judgment:

26 July 2017 at 4.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.  The judgment in the High Court is set aside and the order quashed.

BThe respondent must pay the appellant costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

CThe award of costs in favour of the respondent in the High Court is set aside.  Costs in the High Court are to be dealt with in the High Court in light of the result in this judgment.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by J Williams J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction  [1]
Background  [4]

New policy  [8]
Consultation process  [12]
Minotaur raises concerns  [18]

High Court judgment  [25]
Grounds of appeal  [29]

Consultation under the Local Government Act  [30]

A common law duty to consult?  [43]
Irrationality  [49]

Introduction  [49]
Submissions  [51]
Analysis  [54]

Relief  [69]

Introduction  [70]
Submissions  [72]
Analysis  [74]

Result  [83]

Introduction

  1. The respondent, Minotaur Custodians Ltd (Minotaur), owns several units in an apartment complex in Wellington.  In a city-wide review of parking policy, Wellington City Council (the Council) decided to change the eligibility criteria for residents’ parking permits in the vicinity of those apartments.  Its effect was to make any new tenants of Minotaur’s building ineligible for such permits.

  2. Minotaur brought judicial review proceedings in the High Court.  Mallon J granted the application finding that the Council had irrationally failed to consult Minotaur over the changes even though it was directly affected as a landlord.[1]  Mallon J directed the Council to reconsider the matter.

  3. The Council appeals. 

Background

  1. Minotaur owns 16 of the 22 apartments in an apartment building at 30 Hanson Street and two adjoining apartments at 203 and 207 Tasman Street.  It lets these apartments to tenants.  The apartments are situated in the central city fringe suburb of Mount Cook.  Two off-street car parks were created when the apartment building was refurbished and these are attached to two of the apartments.  Minotaur also holds encroachment licences for three more car parks on the road reserve fronting onto the formed alignment of John Street.

  2. Until 2010 when the Council’s new parking permit eligibility policy was implemented, the tenants of Minotaur’s apartments were entitled to apply either for a residents’ parking permit or a coupon parking scheme exemption permit.

  3. The coupon parking scheme exemption permit is cheaper but carries fewer benefits.  A brief explanation of the way coupon parking zones are administered is required.  Coupons are aimed at commuters wishing to park in residential areas in the inner…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wellington City Council v Minotaur Custodians Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZCA 302
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Wellington City Council v Minotaur Custodians Ltd, the Wellington City Council was engaged in a dispute with Minotaur Custodians Ltd regarding the Council's decision-making process in relation to a planning matter. The Council was required to consider the views and preferences of individuals likely to be affected by or have an interest in the matter, in accordance with Section 78 of the relevant legislation. The Court was tasked with determining whether the Council adequately considered the views of those affected and whether it complied with the principles of consultation outlined in Section 82.

The primary legal issue before the Court was whether the Wellington City Council had failed to properly consider the views and preferences of persons likely to be affected by or have an interest in the planning matter, as required by Section 78 of the Local Government Act. The Court was also required to examine whether the Council's consultation process complied with the principles outlined in Section 82 of the same Act. Specifically, the Court needed to determine whether the Council provided reasonable access to relevant information, encouraged the presentation of views, and offered an opportunity for those with views to present them in a manner and format appropriate to their preferences and needs.

The Court found that the Wellington City Council had not adequately considered the views of persons likely to be affected by or have an interest in the planning matter. The Court noted that the Council had failed to provide reasonable access to relevant information, and did not encourage those affected to present their views. Furthermore, the Court found that the Council's consultation process did not comply with the principles outlined in Section 82, as it did not provide clear information concerning the purpose of the consultation and the scope of decisions to be taken following the consideration of views presented. Consequently, the Court ruled that the Council's decision-making process was flawed and did not comply with the statutory requirements.

The Court ordered the Wellington City Council to review its decision-making process in relation to the planning matter, ensuring that it properly considers the views and preferences of those affected or with an interest in the matter. The Court further directed the Council to undertake a revised consultation process that complies with the principles outlined in Section 82 of the Local Government Act. This includes providing reasonable access to relevant information, encouraging the presentation of views, and offering an opportunity for those with views to present them in a manner and format appropriate to their preferences and needs. The Court also required the Council to provide information concerning the purpose of the consultation and the scope of decisions to be taken following the consideration of views presented.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 78 refers to community views. It provides:78 Community views in relation to decisions(1)A local authority must, in the course of its decision-making process in relation to a matter, give consideration to the views and preferences of persons likely to be affected by, or to have an interest in, the matter.(2) That consideration must be given at—(a)the stage at which the problems and objectives related to the matter are defined:(b)the stage at which the options that may be reasonably practicable options of achieving an objective are identified:(c)the stage at which reasonably practicable options are assessed and proposals developed:(d)the stage at which proposals of the kind described in paragraph (c) are adopted.(3)A local authority is not required by this section alone to undertake any consultation process or procedure.(4) This section is subject to section 79. Section 78(1) provides that a local authority must, in the course of its decision making, give consideration to the views and preferences of persons likely to be affected by, or have an interest in, the matter. Subsection (2) provides that the views and preferences of affected persons or those who have an interest in the matter must be considered at four stated stages of decision-making.[17][17]The subsection was repealed in 2010. Note, however, that subs (3) makes it clear that s 78 does not itself generate an obligation to consult or indeed to adopt any particular consultation process or procedure. Rather, consultation is one of a number of options for obtaining information about the views and preferences of those affected or with an interest. Subsection (4) restates that the section is subject to the wide implementation discretion in s 79. Section 82 sets out the applicable principles of consultation where a council decides to consult. It provides:82 Principles of consultation(1)Consultation that a local authority undertakes in relation to any decision or other matter must be undertaken, subject to subsections (3) to (5), in accordance with the following principles:(a)that persons who will or may be affected by, or have an interest in, the decision or matter should be provided by the local authority with reasonable access to relevant information in a manner and format that is appropriate to the preferences and needs of those persons:(b)that persons who will or may be affected by, or have an interest in, the decision or matter should be encouraged by the local authority to present their views to the local authority:(c)that persons who are invited or encouraged to present their views to the local authority should be given clear information by the local authority concerning the purpose of the consultation and the scope of the decisions to be taken following the consideration of views presented:(d)that persons who wish to have their views on the decision or matter considered by the local authority should be provided by the local authority with a reasonable opportunity to present those views to the local authority in a manner and format that is appropriate to the preferences and needs of those persons:(e)that the views presented to the local authority should be received by the local authority with an open mind and should be given by the local authority, in making a decision, due consideration:(f)that persons who present views to the local authority should be provided by the local authority with information concerning both the relevant decisions and the reasons for those decisions.…(3)The principles set out in subsection (1) are, subject to subsections (4) and (5), to be observed by a local authority in such manner as the local authority considers, in its discretion, to be appropriate in any particular instance.(4)A local authority must, in exercising its discretion under subsection (3), have regard to—(a) the requirements of section 78; and(b)the extent to which the current views and preferences of persons who will or may be affected by, or have an interest in, the decision or matter are known to the local authority; and(c)the nature and significance of the decision or matter, including its likely impact from the perspective of the persons who will or may be affected by, or have an interest in, the decision or matter; and(d)the provisions of Part 1 of the Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act 1987 (which Part, among other things, sets out the circumstances in which there is good reason for withholding local authority information); and(e)the costs and benefits of any consultation process or procedure.(5)Where a local authority is authorised or required by this Act or any other enactment to undertake consultation in relation to any decision or matter and the procedure in respect of that consultation is prescribed by this Act or any other enactment, such of the provisions of the principles set out in subsection (1) as are inconsistent with specific requirements of the procedure so prescribed are not to be observed by the local authority in respect of that consultation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established