Evans v Clutha District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA19/2019
 [2020] NZCA 5

BETWEEN

MAXINE MAY EVANS
Appellant

AND

CLUTHA DISTRICT COUNCIL
Respondent

Hearing:

16 October 2019

Court:

Miller, Simon France and Hinton JJ

Counsel:

G A Paine and M J Taylor-Cyphers for Appellant
D R Tobin for Respondent

Judgment:

4 February 2020 at 1.00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is dismissed.

BThe respondent is entitled to costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Hinton J)

  1. An oak tree and a sequoia in the Christie Street playground in Balclutha remain the subject of judicial scrutiny. 

  2. On 3 May 2018, the Clutha District Council resolved that the two trees be removed.  Ms Evans applied for judicial review of that decision which was declined by Nation J on 17 December 2018.[1]  The matter has now come to this Court on appeal.  In the meantime, the Council has agreed to leave the trees pending resolution of the proceedings.

Background

[1]EvansvClutha District Council [2018] NZHC 3355.

  1. The two trees are situated on a pocket reserve in a suburban area in Balclutha.  The reserve is about 1600m².  It fronts Christie Street and is surrounded by three neighbouring lots each about half the size of the reserve.  Mr and Mrs Ross live in one of the neighbouring lots.  The two trees are adjacent to the Ross property.  Photos show the trees well exceeding the height of the Ross dwelling, the sequoia leaning towards it and the oak with branches extending over the boundary.  Arborists say the oak is about 14.5 metres high and the sequoia about 20 metres.  The trees are about 45 years old and the arborists describe them as young.  Though there is no evidence as to likely ultimate size it is clear that they will grow substantially larger, especially the sequoia.

  2. Mr and Mrs Ross have complained to the Council about the trees for some years.  In February 2014, following a complaint made in 2013, the Council resolved “that the trees be pruned and that a root curtain be installed to avoid the root interference to the neighbouring property”.  This followed an arborist (Mr Glenn of Asplundh) advising the Council he had inspected the trees and there was “a minor amount of pruning” that could be done to the oak.  He said the oak is “quite vigorous and is growing out toward the boundary”.  

  3. On 22 January 2018 Mr and Mrs Ross wrote another letter of complaint to the Council.  The letter referred to their having raised issues “on many occasions” with the Council.  It referred to reports of trees falling and killing people elsewhere, to dead pieces in the sequoia, to the oak tree getting bigger and black discharges from the oak tree onto the roof of their property.

  4. The Council obtained a report from the community facilities supervisor.  The supervisor said the trees had been monitored…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Evans v Clutha District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZCA 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Evans v Clutha District Council involved a challenge to the decision of the Clutha District Council to allow the felling of two trees within a public reserve. The Council's decision was contested on the basis that it did not adequately consider the statutory requirements for decision-making as set out in the Local Government Act 2009 (Vic). Specifically, the plaintiff argued that the Council failed to comply with the statutory obligations to identify reasonably practicable options and to consider the views of those likely to be affected. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria, which was required to determine whether the Council's decision met the statutory standards for decision-making under the Act.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Clutha District Council had complied with the statutory requirements for decision-making when it decided to allow the felling of the two trees. This involved examining whether the Council had appropriately identified all reasonably practicable options in accordance with s 77(1)(a) of the LGA and whether it had adequately considered the views of those likely to be affected, as required by s 78(1) of the LGA. The court needed to determine if the Council's actions were in line with the statutory obligations and if the decision-making process met the legislative standards.

The court found that the Clutha District Council had complied with the statutory requirements for decision-making. The decision-making process was assessed against the statutory standards, and it was determined that the Council had identified reasonably practicable options for the felling of the trees in accordance with s 77(1)(a) of the LGA. Additionally, the court found that the Council had taken into account community views, thus meeting the requirement under s 78(1) of the LGA. The court emphasised that while consultation is encouraged, it is not mandatory, and the Council had the discretion to decide how it would consider the views of the community. The court concluded that the Council's decision-making process was appropriate and in compliance with the statutory obligations.

As a result of the court's determination, the plaintiff's challenge to the Council's decision was dismissed. The court upheld the Council's decision to allow the felling of the trees, finding that it had properly followed the statutory requirements for decision-making under the Local Government Act 2009 (Vic).

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 76 provides:76 Decision-making(1) Every decision made by a local authority must be made in accordance with such of the provisions of sections 77, 78, 80, 81 and 82 as are applicable.(2) Subsection (1) is subject, in relation to compliance with sections 77 and 78, to the judgments made by the local authority under section 79.(3) A local authority—(a)must ensure that, subject to subsection (2), its decision‑making processes promote compliance with subsection (1); and(b) in the case of a significant decision, must ensure, before the decision is made, that subsection (1) has been appropriately observed.(4) For the avoidance of doubt, it is declared that, subject to subsection (2), subsection (1) applies to every decision made by or on behalf of a local authority, including a decision not to take any action.…(6) This section and the sections applied by this section do not limit any duty or obligation imposed on a local authority by any other enactment. In Minotaur the Court summarised s 76 in the following way:[33] Relevantly, for present purposes, subs (1) and (2) provide that consultation decisions must be made in accordance with ss 78 and 82, subject, in the case of compliance with section 78, to the ameliorating effect of s 79. Subsection (3) sets two standards of performance. In respect of “significant decisions”, the local authority must ensure that the provisions contained in subs (1) have been “appropriately observed”. This is the higher of the two standards. Where the matter is not “significant”, the standard is more aspirational: decision-making is only required to “promote compliance” with the provisions referred to in subs (1). Even that lower standard is subject to s 79 as noted.(Emphasis added.) Although trees are highly valued, a decision regarding felling these trees does not fall into the category of a significant decision. The evidence was that usually decisions regarding tree removal are made by a Council officer and not by the Council itself. Further, following consultation over the draft reserves management plan, no members of the community had identified these particular trees (or indeed any trees) within the Clutha district as requiring special protection. Section 77(1)(a) of the LGA provides that a local authority must, in the course of the decision-making process, seek to identify all reasonably practicable options for the achievement of the objective of the decision. In this case, prior to making the decision, the Council received a report from the community facilities supervisor. That report referred to the Asplundh report and gave the Council the three options referred to earlier: do nothing, fell the sequoia and retain the oak, or fell both trees. Options were identified therefore in terms of s 77(1). Section 78(1) requires a local authority to give consideration to the views of persons likely to be affected or with an interest, but as this Court in Minotaur made clear, the section does not generate an obligation to consult or indeed to adopt any particular consultation process or procedure. Rather, the Court stated “consultation is one of a number of options for obtaining information about the views and preferences of those affected or with an interest”.[6] In this case, the Council was required to take into account community views, but was left with a wide discretion about how it did that.[6]Minotaur, above n 5, at [36].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.