IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTEPOTI ROHE
CIV-2018-409-000598
[2018] NZHC 3355
BETWEEN MAXINE MAY EVANS
Plaintiff
AND
CLUTHA DISTRICT COUNCIL
Defendant
Hearing: 20 November 2018 Appearances:
G A Paine for the Applicant D R Tobin for the Respondent
Judgment:
17 December 2018
JUDGMENT OF NATION J
[1] This judgment is about an oak tree and a sequoia. Warren Buffet said, “someone is sitting in the shade today because someone planted a tree a long time ago”. I would add that someone can sit in the shade because no one cut down that tree.
[2] To some people, a tree is a symbol of the changing seasons, an enhancement to the natural environment. To others, that tree might be a nuisance, even a potential danger.
[3] It might be thought that I must decide what view should prevail. However, that is not the issue. In these judicial review proceedings, I must decide whether a duly elected authority, the Clutha District Council, lawfully exercised powers given to it by legislation in deciding to cut down the oak and the sequoia.
EVANS v CLUTHA DISTRICT COUNCIL [2018] NZHC 3355 [17 December 2018]
Background
[4] In the 1950s, the sequoia and oak were planted near the perimeter of the Christie Street Reserve in Balclutha. The Reserve is about 1,619 square metres, roughly the size of two residential sections of the sort that now surround it on three sides. About the time the trees were planted, a house was built on 15 Christie Street, which adjoins the Christie Street Reserve. No doubt, at that time, the oak and the sequoia were little trees, perhaps just saplings.
[5] In 2004, Mr and Mrs Ross purchased the house at 15 Christie Street. By then, the trees must have been taller but not as large as they are now.
[6] In 2013, Mr and Mrs Ross complained to the Council about the trees. At a meeting of the Council on 27 February 2014, the Council resolved “that the trees be pruned and that a root curtain be installed to avoid the root interference to the neighbouring property”. An arborist, Mr Glenn of Asplundh, advised the Council he had inspected the trees and there was “a minor amount of pruning” that could be done. This was as to the oak which he then described as “quite vigorous and is growing out toward the boundary”. A photograph produced with his report showed the branches of the oak extending to and probably over the fence between the Reserve and the Ross property. Mr Glenn recommended reducing the laterals growing towards the neighbour and thinning and pruning the remainder of the crown by 20 per cent to encourage growth away from the boundary. He also recommended the installation of a root curtain to ensure there was no interference with the neighbouring property.
[7] In a letter of 22 January 2018, Mr and Mrs Ross wrote to the Council referring to their earlier…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Evans v Clutha District Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NZHC 3355
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the Council's decision to remove the trees was based on a reasonable basis. The Council had information about the size of the trees, their impact on neighbouring properties, and potential safety concerns. The court held that it was not for the judiciary to review the merits of the Council's decision but to examine the decision-making process. The Council had considered the concerns of the neighbours and had a rational basis for its decision, which did not require further consultation.
Furthermore, the court ruled that the Council was not under a legal obligation to consult the community. The Local Government Act 2002 provided the Council with a broad discretion to decide whether and how to consult. The Council's decision not to consult was rational, considering the opportunity for community input during the consultation for the Balclutha Reserves Management Plan.
Additionally, the court found that the Council's decision did not breach the Reserves Act 1997. The Christie Street Reserve was primarily a pocket park for the neighbourhood's recreation and sporting activities. The Council had the discretion to manage the reserve and decide that the trees were not necessary for its primary purpose.
The court concluded that Maxine May Evans' claim for an injunction to prevent the trees from being felled must fail. The claim for relief under the Judicial Review Procedure Act was also declined. The Clutha District Council was successful in these proceedings and would normally be entitled to costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.