Trustpower Ltd (formerly Bay Energy) v Electricity Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2016-485-580 [2016] NZHC 2914

BETWEEN

TRUSTPOWER LIMITED (FORMERLY

BAY ENERGY) Applicant

AND

ELECTRICITY AUTHORITY First Respondent

MERIDIAN ENERGY LIMITED Second Respondent

Hearing: 14 and 15 September 2016

Appearances:

J Farmer QC and B A Davies for applicant
A R Galbraith QC and L A OʼGorman for first respondent
J D Every-Palmer and T Mijatov for second respondent

Judgment:

2 December 2016

JUDGMENT OF CULL J

Contents

Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................ [1] PART I: BACKGROUND TO THE PROCEEDING ...................................................................................... [5] The parties......................................................................................................................................................... [10] The regulatory framework............................................................................................................................... [14] The Code ........................................................................................................................................................... [16] The Charter....................................................................................................................................................... [20] The TPM process to date.................................................................................................................................. [30] The Authority’s strategy announcement ......................................................................................................... [39] The Consultation Papers .................................................................................................................................. [42] The TPM Paper ............................................................................................................................................. [43] The DGPP Paper........................................................................................................................................... [44] Trustpower’s requests ...................................................................................................................................... [45] Further Consultation Opportunity.................................................................................................................. [48] PART II: THE PARTIES’ POSITIONS .......................................................................................................... [49] Trustpower’s position ....................................................................................................................................... [49] Grounds of review ......................................................................................................................................... [52] The process has “gone off the rails” ............................................................................................................. [57] Consultation was inadequate ........................................................................................................................ [60]

The Authority’s position................................................................................................................................... [67]

TRUSTPOWER LIMITED v ELECTRICITY AUTHORITY [2016] NZHC 2914 [2 December 2016]

Meridian’s position ........................................................................................................................................... [74] Reviewability of a procedural decision ........................................................................................................... [78] PART III: ANALYSIS ...................................................................................................................................... [82] The Authority’s duty of consultation .............................................................................................................. [86] Court’s intervention at a preliminary stage.................................................................................................. [100] Has this decision-making process gone seriously off the rails? ................................................................... [108] Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................................... [117] Result ............................................................................................................................................................... [125] APPENDIX 1 – CONSULTATION PROCESS FOR DEVELOPING THE TPM (FIGURE 8)

Introduction

[1]      Trustpower has applied for judicial review of the “process decisions” of the Electricity Authority  (the Authority)  refusing  to  grant  Trustpower’s  request  for extensions of time for written submissions, cross-submissions and an oral hearing on two consultation papers, which were promulgated by the Authority in May 2016 to industry participants. They are:

(a)       Transmission Pricing Methodology: second issues paper (the TPM Paper) dated 17 May 2016; and

(b)      Review of distributed generation pricing principles consultation paper

(the DGPP Paper) dated 17 May 2016.1

[2]      The Authority has received submissions from industry participants, including Trustpower, but has not yet made substantive decisions in relation to the May consultation  papers.    In  seeking  to  review  the Authority’s  procedural  decision, Trustpower contends that the consultation process was meaningless, being limited, insufficient and inadequate.  The Authority in reply submits that the decision is not reviewable because the substantive decision has not yet been made.

[3]      Meridian Energy (Meridian) as intervenor and second respondent, joins the Authority in submitting that the application for judicial review is premature.  In the alternative, both the Authority and Meridian submit that the decisions about consultation were not unlawful or unreasonable.

[4]      The judgment is divided into three parts.  Part I explains the background to the proceeding and the regulatory framework of the electricity industry.   Part II describes the parties’ positions and the actions of the Authority to date.   Part III analyses the issues and explains the reasons for my decision.

PART I: BACKGROUND TO THE PROCEEDING

[5]      The electricity industry in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Trustpower Ltd (formerly Bay Energy) v Electricity Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 2914
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Trustpower, sought a judicial review of decisions made by the Electricity Authority (Authority) in relation to consultation on two consultation papers: the Transmission Pricing Methodology (TPM) paper and the Distributed Generation Pricing Principles (DGPP) paper. The Authority had rejected Trustpower's requests for extensions of time for written submissions, cross-submissions, and an oral hearing on the papers. Trustpower contended that the consultation process was inadequate, being limited, insufficient, and inadequate. The Authority and Meridian, the second respondent, submitted that the application for judicial review was premature and in the alternative, that the decisions about consultation were not unlawful or unreasonable. The Court found that the Authority's consultation process was at a preliminary stage, and the Court should only intervene if there was an irretrievable flaw in the consultation process or if the decision-making process had gone off the rails. The Authority had not reached its decision on the submissions it had received and had announced it would consult further on refinements to the proposal for the new TPM guidelines. The Authority had also moved the implementation date in relation to the DGPP proposal to April 2018 at the earliest. The Court concluded that the process had not seriously gone off the rails or that any flaws in the process were irretrievable, such that the Court should intervene at this stage. The application for judicial review was declined.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established