Lifestyle Equities CV & Anor v Ahmed & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 116 min read

Appellants (Appeal 2021/0147) - Ahmed and anr

Peter Knox KC

Timothy Sampson

Adam Riley

(Instructed by Ronald Fletcher Baker LLP (West End))

Respondents (Appeal 2021/0147) / Appellants (Appeal 2021/0150) - Lifestyle Equities C.V. and anr

Thomas St Quintin

Rory Brown

(Instructed by Brandsmiths (London))

 

 

Respondents (Appeal 2021/0150) - Ahmed and anr

Peter Knox KC

Laurent Sykes KC

Timothy Sampson

(Instructed by Ronald Fletcher Baker LLP (West End)

 

 

LORD LEGGATT (with whom Lord Lloyd-Jones, Lord Kitchin, Lord Stephens and Lord Richards agree):

  1. The main issues raised by this appeal and cross-appeal are these. When are directors of a company liable as accessories for causing the company to commit a tort of strict liability - in this case, trade mark infringement? In particular, is such liability also strict or does it depend on knowledge (or some other mental element)? And if directors are strictly liable, should they be ordered to account for profits made by either (i) the company or (ii) the directors themselves?
  2. I. The proceedings

    The claim

  3. The claimants are two companies who can together be called "Lifestyle". Lifestyle brought these proceedings against some 16 defendants claiming remedies for infringement of registered trade marks and passing off. Those sued included two family-owned companies, Continental Shelf 128 Ltd and Hornby Street Ltd, which both traded under the name "Juice Corporation". The defendants also included Mr Kashif Ahmed and his sister, Ms Bushra Ahmed. Mr Ahmed was the sole director of Continental Shelf and they were both directors of Hornby Street at all relevant times. Lifestyle and the Ahmeds are the respective parties to these appeals.
  4. Juice Corporation was a wholesale business which arranged for the manufacture of clothing, footwear and headgear and sold it to retailers, mainly in the UK. Mr Ahmed's role included managing the intellectual property rights of the companies. Ms Bushra Ahmed was head of sales for a "division" of Hornby Street called the "House of Brands".
  5. Lifestyle complained that the Juice Corporation companies had been offering for sale various items of clothing and footwear with logos displaying the name "Santa Monica Polo Club" and pictures of polo players riding horses. Lifestyle claimed that the use of these signs infringed trade marks registered by Lifestyle which included the words "Beverly Hills Polo Club" and depicted a polo player on a horse. Breaches of both section 10(2) and 10(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1994 were alleged. The Ahmeds were sued on the basis that they had authorised or procured the companies to do the acts complained of or had engaged in a common design with each other or the companies to cause them so to act.
  6. The judge's findings

  7. The trial was split into two parts. Both hearings took place before the same judge, Mr Recorder Douglas Campbell QC sitting as a judge of the Chancery Division. The first trial dealt with the liability of certain defendants including Hornby Street but not Continental Shelf or the Ahmeds. Hornby Street was found liable under both…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lifestyle Equities CV & Anor v Ahmed & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] UKSC 17
Decision Date