Parliamentary
Archives,
HL/PO/JU/4/3/1152
HOUSE OF LORDS
ESSO PETROLEUM COMPANY LIMITED
v.
HARPER'S GARAGE (STOURPORT) LIMITED
Lord Reid
Lord
Morris of
Borth-y-Gest
Lord Hodson
Lord Pearce
Lord
Wilberforce
Lord Reid
my lords,
The
Appellants are a large company whose most important product is
Esso
petrol most of which is sold by them to garages and filling
stations
for resale to the public. The Respondent Company own two
garages: they
contracted with the Appellants under what are know
as solus agreements
and bound themselves for the periods of those
agreements inter alia to
sell at their garages Esso petrol
and no other. When cheaper " cut price "
petrol came on
the market they began to sell it and ceased to sell Esso
petrol.
The Appellants then raised two actions, now consolidated, to
prevent
this: they sought injunctions to restrain the Respondents
from buying other
than from them any motor fuel for resale at
these garages. On 17th March,
1955 Mocatta, J. granted an
injunction, but on appeal the Court of Appeal
set aside this order
on the ground that the ties in these agreements were in
restraint
of trade and were unenforceable. The Appellants now maintain
first
that these ties were not in restraint of trade and secondly that, if
they
were, they were in the circumstances valid and enforceable.
The
earlier agreement related to the Corner Garage, Stourport, and was
to
remain in force for 21 years from 1st July, 1962. But, as the
case with
regard to it is complicated by there being a mortgage in
security for money
lent by the Appellants to the Respondents, I
shall first consider the second
agreement which related to the
Mustow Green Garage near Kidderminster.
This agreement was to
remain in force for four years and five months from
1st July,
1963. It appears that the Appellants had a similar agreement with
the
previous owners of that garage and that this period was chosen
because
it was the unexpired period of that earlier agreement.
The main
provisions of the Mustow Green agreement are that while it
remained
in force the Respondents agreed to buy from the Appellants
their
total requirements of motor fuels for resale at that garage
and agreed to
keep it open at all reasonable hours for the sale of
Esso Motor Fuels and
Esso Motor oils, and in return the Appellants
agreed to sell to the Respon-
dents at their wholesale schedule
price at the time of delivery, and to
allow a rebate from that
price of one penny farthing per gallon payable
quarterly. There
were a number of other provisions with regard to advertis-
ing,
service at the garage etc. which I shall not specify because they do
not
appear to me to assist in determining the questions at issue.
But there are
two other provisions which I must notice. If the
Respondents wished to dis-
pose of the garage they were not to do
so except to a person who agreed to
be substituted for them for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Esso Petroleum Co Ltd v Harper's Garage (Stourport) Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1967] UKHL 1
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi