Forestview Nominees Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustees WA Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

C A T C H W O R D S

REAL PROPERTY - restrictive covenants - annexation of benefit of covenant to land - owner of shopping centre also owned surplus land - owner sold shopping centre and part of surplus adjoining land - transfer of part of surplus adjoining land contained covenant restraining transferor as registered proprietor, and its successors in title as registered proprietors, from using "remaining land" for retail sale of goods, or as showrooms - tenants of benefited land or any part of it excluded from benefit of covenant - applicants subsequent sequential purchasers of burdened land with notice of restrictive covenant - whether covenant benefiting the whole of the land necessary for benefit of covenant to pass - whether limitation of covenant to registered proprietors is an expression of contrary intention so that burden does not pass - whether method of discharge affects passing of benefit or burden.

EQUITY - equitable estates and interests - restrictive covenants.

Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) s.89
Law of Property Act 1925 (Eng) s.78
Property Law Act 1969 (WA) s.7, s.47, s.48 and s.48(1)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s.45B(1)
Transfer of Land Act 1893 (WA) s.4, s.129B and s.129B(1)

Attorney General v. T.S. Gill and Son Pty Ltd [1927] VLR 22
Austerberry v Corporation of Oldham (1885) 29 Ch D 750
In re Ballard's Conveyance [1937] 1 Ch 473
Re Barry and the Conveyancing Act [1962] NSWR 977
Brunner v Greenslade [1971] 1 Ch 993
Drake v Gray [1936] Ch 451
Federated Homes Ltd v Mill Lodge Properties Ltd [1980] 1 WLR 594
Formby v Barker [1903] 2 Ch 539
Re Gadd's Land Transfer [1966] Ch 56
Haywood v The Brunswick Permanent Benefit Building Society [1881] 8 QBD 403
Lane Cove Council v H. & W. Hurdis Pty Ltd (1955) 72 WN(NSW) 284
London County Council v Allen [1914] 3 KB 642 (CA)
London and South Western Railway Co v. Gomm (1881) 20 Ch D 562
Mander v Falcke [1891] 2 Ch 554
Marten v Flight Refuelling Ltd [1962] Ch 115
In re Nisbet and Potts' Contract [1905] 1 Ch 386
Newton Abbot Co-operative Society Ltd v Williamson & Treadgold [1952] 1 Ch 286
Osborne v Bradley [1903] 2 Ch 446
Pirie v The Registrar General (1962) 109 CLR 619
Quadramain Pty Ltd v Sevastapol Investments Pty Ltd (1976) 133 CLR 390
Renals v Cowlishaw (1878) 9 Ch D 125
Rhone v Stephens [1994] 2 AC 310

Roake v Chadha [1984] 1 WLR 40
Rogers v Hosegood [1900] 2 Ch 388
Re Royal Victoria Pavilion (Ramsgate) [1961] 1 Ch 581
Esso Petroleum Co Ltd v Harper's Garage (Stourport) Ltd (1968) AC 269
Tophams Ltd v Earl of Sefton [1967] 1 AC 50
Tulk v Moxhay (1848) 2 Ph 744; 41 ER 1143
Union of London and Smith's Bank Ltd's Conveyance Re; Miles v Easter [1933] 1 Ch 611
United Starr-Bowkett Cooperative Building Society v Clyne [1968] 1 NSWR 134
Wrotham Park Estate Company v Parkside Homes Ltd [1974] 1…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Forestview Nominees Pty Ltd v Perpetual Trustees WA Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] FCA 1164
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This appeal concerns the enforceability of a restrictive covenant preventing the construction of retail premises on land adjacent to the Warwick Grove Shopping Centre. The covenant was made between Perpetual Trustees WA Limited (Perpetual) who acquired the Shopping Centre Land and National Mutual Life Association of Australia Limited (NML) who sold it and also owned the adjoining land. The covenant was worded so as to exclude tenants of the Centre from its benefit. The object of the exclusion was to allow any variation or discharge to be negotiated directly by the registered proprietors. That exclusion has raised a question of the enforceability of the covenant against a company which has subsequently purchased the land which adjoined the shopping centre. The appellants contend that because the covenant seeks to exclude tenants of the shopping centre land from its benefits it does not touch and concern that land and therefore fails to satisfy a condition of enforceability in equity. The operation of ss.47 and 48 of the Property Law Act 1969 (WA) relating to the passing of the benefit and the burden of covenants and s.129B of the Transfer of Land Act 1893-1972 (WA) relating to the discharge or modification of covenants on the Register are also at issue in this case.The Court found that the benefit of a restrictive covenant could be allocated to different interest holders just as rights could be carved out of a freehold estate in favour of particular interest holders. An interest in land was not required to benefit every estate holder provided it benefited some of them. The question whether the covenant ran with the land was a matter of intention which could be construed by reference to the terms of the transfer and the covenant itself. The designation of the covenantor as "NML as registered proprietor" indicated an intention that the covenant should relate to the land. The exclusion of tenants from the benefit provision did not preclude the benefit of the covenant from touching and concerning the land. The covenant was indistinguishable from the covenant in Miles v Easter save as to the exclusion of lessees. The exclusion of lessees from the benefit of the covenant did not prevent the covenant from being either annexed to the Benefited Land or to touch and concern that land or to enure for its benefit. The exclusion of tenants from the benefit provision did not preclude the benefit of the covenant from touching and concerning the land. Furthermore, the authorities show that leaving aside for the moment the exclusion of lessee interests, the Restrictive Covenant was in all respects one which must be found to benefit the land. There was no argument to the contention that if the true foundation of the doctrine in Tulk v Moxhay is an extension in equity of the doctrine in Spencer's case; or the doctrine of negative easements; or the existence of an equitable charge, it must follow the benefit cannot attach to some but all of the interests in the benefited land in order for consistency to be maintained with those doctrinal foundations. Furthermore, the position recognized by the trial judge was consistent with the proposition that a registered proprietor of the fee simple can create an equitable charge which does not apply to a leasehold interest. There was no error in the conclusions of the trial judge that the exclusion of lessees from the benefit was not such as to prevent the Restrictive Covenant being either annexed to the Benefited Land or to touch and concern that land or to enure for its benefit. Unless a contrary intention was expressed, a covenant relating to any land of a covenantor or capable of being bound by him, shall be deemed to be made by the covenantor on behalf of himself, his successors in title and the persons deriving title under him or them, and, has effect as if those successors and other persons were expressed. The trial judge concluded for the purpose of s48(1) of the Property Law Act there was no contrary intention expressed or implied on the burden or covenantor's side. The effect of cl4 in the Restrictive Covenant was that the registered proprietors could effect a discharge so the interest of others interested in the land, particularly tenants, could be ignored. Consequently, it was contended, unless there was severance of the clauses providing for discharge, the parties' instrument failed because to hold them to the balance of their bargain would be to produce a completely different agreement. The trial judge's view was that the authorities showed that a covenant which binds the Burdened Land in equity binds any lessee or occupant and even a person holding title by adverse possession. Further, as a matter of construction there was nothing in the language expressing the extent of the burden of the Restrictive Covenant which in his view required a construction restricting those bound to only those who were registered proprietors. The authorities are Mander v Falcke referred to in Re Nisbett v Pott's Contract where Farwell J implicitly had no doubt that a person deriving title from the covenantor would have been bound unless that person could prove that they were a purchaser of the legal title without notice. Further the trial judge considered as a matter of construction and in equity the Restrictive Covenant would bind any lessee or occupier of the Burdened Land whether taking a registered or an unregistered interest in that property. The Court concluded that the appeal should be dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.