Cusack v London Borough of Harrow

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

     

    Summary


    Trinty Term
    [2013] UKSC 40
    On appeal from: [2011] EWCA Civ 1514

    JUDGMENT

    Cusack (Respondent) v London Borough of Harrow (Appellant)
    before
    Lord Neuberger, President
    Lord Mance
    Lord Sumption
    Lord Carnwath
    Lord Hughes
    JUDGMENT GIVEN ON

    19 June 2013

    Heard on 23 April 2013
    Appellant
    Stephen Sauvain QC
    Tom Weekes
    (Instructed by Sharpe Pritchard)
      Respondent
    Patrick Green QC
    Noel Dilworth
    (Instructed by Patrick J Cusack & Co)
    LORD CARNWATH (with whom Lord Sumption and Lord Hughes agree)
    Introduction
  1. Since 1969 Mr Cusack has practised as a solicitor at 66 Station Road, Harrow ("the property"). Station Road, part of the A409, is a single carriage road in each direction flanked by a pedestrian footway. At some unknown date the former front garden was turned into a forecourt open to the highway, which has since then been used for parking cars of staff and clients. This involves cars crossing the footway to gain access, and backing into the road when leaving.
  2. The house had been built in around 1900 as a dwelling. In 1973 a personal permission was granted on appeal to Mr Cusack to use the ground floor as offices, subject to a condition requiring cessation by 31 August 1976. It was noted that the ground floor had been used for that purpose "for some time", and permission was only sought for a temporary period to enable Mr Cusack to continue his work in the local court. One of the objections had related to traffic generation, but the inspector did not think that "use of these rather limited premises has added materially to traffic hazard over the last two years". Following the expiry of that permission the use as an office has continued and has become "established" in planning terms.
  3. The present dispute began in January 2009, when the London Borough of Harrow ("the council"), as highway authority, wrote to Mr Cusack asserting that the movement of vehicles over the footway caused danger to pedestrians and other motorists. In March 2009 he was informed that the council were planning to erect barriers from 36 to 76 Station Road to prevent vehicles from driving over raised kerbs and footways. After some initial confusion as to the statutory basis for their proposed action, they settled on section 80 of the Highways Act 1980. Mr Cusack began proceedings in the county court for an injunction to prevent the erection of the barriers outside his house. Judge McDowall and on appeal Maddison J found in favour of the council, but their decisions were reversed by the Court of Appeal. Pursuant to an undertaking given by the council to the county court, no barriers have yet been erected outside number 66, although they have been erected outside some other adjoining properties.
  4. Apart from statute, Mr Cusack, as owner of property fronting on to the highway, would have had a common law right of access without restriction from any part of the property (see Marshall v Blackpool Corporation [1935] AC 16, 22 per Lord Atkin).…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cusack v London Borough of Harrow and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] UKSC 40
Decision Date