Woolley v Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND BLENHEIM REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WAIHARAKEKE ROHE

CIV 2018-406-14

[2021] NZHC 2690

BETWEEN

PHILIP JOHN WOOLLEY

Plaintiff

AND

FONTERRA CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 15–26 February 2021

Appearances:

P A Morten and M A Robertson for Plaintiff

J Anderson QC, M D Branch and K F Shaw and for Defendant

Judgment:

8 October 2021


JUDGMENT OF ISAC J


TABLE OF CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION  [1]

Preliminaries  [7]

FACTUAL FINDINGS  [13]

Dairy industry context  [13]

The dairy farming season  [14]

Farm dairy effluent (FDE) management  [16]

Effluent irrigation  [23]

The Woolley dairy farms  [27]

The milk supply contract between Mr Woolley and Fonterra  [32]

The resource consents for Glenmae and construction of the effluent ponds – the

certification saga begins  [41]

Environmental issues begin to emerge on the Woolley dairy farms: 2011-2013        [65]

Problems with effluent on Tuamarina  [67]

Effluent problems arise on Glenmae: 2012-2014  [90]

MDC applies for enforcement orders and Fonterra issues an EIP  [96]

WOOLLEY v FONTERRA CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LIMITED [2021] NZHC 2690 [8 October 2021]

The 4 April 2014 Environment Court decision  [104]

The enforcement order  [113]

4 April 2014 – 9 June 2014 - drop testing on pond 1 and the 9 June 2014 procedural

order  [116]

Fonterra decides to suspend milk collection  [131] Mr Talbot completes his drop test and reports — Mr Woolley engages Opus  [134] Mr and Mrs Woolley move dairy cows onto Glenmae and begin milking them       [142]

Marlborough District Council threatens Fonterra with prosecution if it collects milk from Glenmae  [151]

Opus’ 1 August 2014 reports  [159]

Opus’ 5 September 2014 certification of the effluent system  [197] Mr Woolley’s and Fonterra’s response to the 5 September engineer’s certificate [216] Mr Woolley abandons certification and commissions a new weeping wall system [237] Mr Woolley appoints receivers – a new effluent system is designed and installed [249] The Environment Court’s 10 July 2015 ruling  [267]

Mr and Mrs Woolley’s subsequent conviction and sentencing  [276]

ANALYSIS  [282]

Mr Woolley’s claim and the issues for determination  [282]

FIRST ISSUE: VALIDITY OF FONTERRA’S SUSPENSION NOTICE               [291]

Discussion  [300]

SECOND ISSUE: DID THE ENGINEER’S CERTIFICATE MEET THE TERMS OF THE ORDER?  [316]

Introduction  [316]

The status of the Environment Court decisions in this case  [320] Was the Opus certificate sufficient to discharge the enforcement order?  [325] Mr Woolley’s case  [325]

Fonterra’s case  [330]

Analysis – overview  [337]

Comparison of the certificate against the terms of the enforcement order             [339]

Order A(1): the effluent system has generally been installed and is functioning according to the design in the resource consent  [344]

Order A(2): the dimensions of the ponds given on the plans are correct and layout on the ground corresponds with the application for resource consent  [353]

Order A(3): the two ponds are functioning as holding ponds, ie they are impermeable and are not discharging to the ground and/or groundwater around or beneath the ponds [360]

Order A(4): there are no holes in the ponds and walls  [364]

Order…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Woolley v Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZHC 2690
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerns the exercise of a contractual discretion. At the centre of the dispute is a dairy farm called Glenmae, owned by the plaintiff, Mr Woolley. Over a period of years Mr Woolley found it difficult to comply with his obligations under the Resource Management Act 1991 when operating Glenmae and two other dairy farms. The local authority, the Marlborough District Council (MDC or Council in this judgment), successfully obtained enforcement orders from the Environment Court in relation to two of them. It also successfully prosecuted Mr Woolley for several offences against the RMA. In 2015 this resulted in an order of the Environment Court prohibiting Mr Woolley from involvement in the day-to-day management of a dairy farm for a period of ten years. Mr Woolley had a supply contract with Fonterra, the defendant. By mid-2014 Glenmae was the subject of an enforcement order prohibiting the use of its dairy shed and effluent system until Mr Woolley obtained an engineer’s certificate confirming the effluent system was functioning properly. As a result of the enforcement order, Fonterra suspended milk collection from Glenmae and served a notice to that effect on Mr Woolley. In this proceeding Mr Woolley alleges Fonterra was in breach of the supply contract by refusing to collect milk from Glenmae in the 2014/15 season. Mr Woolley says that he complied with the terms of the enforcement order on 5 September 2014 when he obtained an engineer’s certificate. He says that after that date Fonterra was not entitled to maintain its suspension of milk collection and that it exercised its contractual discretion to do so unreasonably. Mr Woolley further says that Fonterra’s notice of suspension was invalid. I have found that Mr Woolley’s claim must fail for four reasons. First, contrary to a finding of the Environment Court in July 2015, I have concluded that the engineer’s certificate obtained by Mr Woolley did not meet the requirements of the Environment Court’s enforcement orders and, accordingly, he remained in breach of its terms, and those of the resource consent itself, after 5 September 2014. Second, Fonterra’s exercise of its contractual discretion was not unreasonable in the circumstances. Third, its notice suspending milk collection was properly issued and effective. Finally, I have concluded that Mr Woolley’s own unlawful conduct — milking in breach of the enforcement orders — is a necessary pre-condition of his claimed loss. Accordingly, any losses Mr Woolley claims to have suffered are the result of his own unlawful conduct and are not recoverable. Mr Woolley’s claim is dismissed for four reasons:(a)The engineer’s certificate he obtained did not meet the requirements of the Environment Court’s enforcement orders, and so he remained in breach of its terms and the resource consent after 5 September 2014;(b)Fonterra’s exercise of its contractual discretion was not unreasonable in the circumstances;(c)Fonterra’s notice suspending milk collection was properly issued and effective; and(d)Mr Woolley’s own unlawful conduct is a necessary pre-condition of his claimed loss, and is not recoverable.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.