Wholesale Distributors Ltd v Songle Supermarket Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2014-404-002551 [2014] NZHC 2548

BETWEEN

WHOLESALE DISTRIBUTORS

LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

SONGLE SUPERMARKET LIMITED First Defendant

DAVID GLENN BROWN Second Defendant

SONIA PAULINE BROWN Third Defendant

MATTHEW DAVID IGGULDEN AND AMANDA KATHLEEN IGGULDEN Fourth Defendants

Hearing: 8 October 2014

Appearances:

Bret Gustafson and Rebecca Hopkins for the Plaintiff

Philip Rzepecky for the First to Third Defendants (appearance excused)

Kelly Quinn and Stephanie Thompson for the Fourth
Defendants

Judgment:

17 October 2014

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF MOORE J

This judgment was delivered by  on 17 October 2014 at 1:00pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/ Deputy Registrar

Date:

WHOLESALE DISTRIBUTORS LIMITED v SONGLE SUPERMARKET LIMITED & ORS [2014] NZHC

2548 [17 October 2014]

[1]      Wholesale  Distributors  Limited  (“WDL”)  is  a  division  of  Progressive Enterprises Limited.   It is the franchisor for a group of supermarkets known as SuperValue and FreshChoice.

[2]      One of its SuperValue stores is situated in the Coromandel holiday town of

Pauanui.  It is the only supermarket in that community.

[3]      The franchisee and owner of the business is Songle Supermarket Limited (“Songle”), the first defendant.  The shareholders of Songle are David and Pauline Brown, the second and third defendants.

[4]      In 2007 Songle entered into a franchise agreement with WDL when Songle purchased the Pauanui SuperValue store.  The term of the franchise agreement was

10 years although after that initial term the agreement could be either renewed or would roll over on a yearly basis.

[5]      The provisions of the franchise agreement included, amongst others, terms covering the following topics:

(a)       a prohibition on carrying out any other trading activity; (b)     WDL’s rights on the sale of the business by Songle;

(c)       WDL’s rights on termination of the franchise agreement.

[6]      Clause  11.5  of  the  franchise  agreement  deals  with  the  obligations  on  a franchisee when it wishes to dispose of its interest in premises which are the subject of a franchise agreement.  The franchisee must, in the first instance, offer its interest to WDL and only if declined by WDL may it offer its interest to third parties subject to  WDL’s  written  approval  and  the  requirement  that  any offer  to  a  third  party includes a term giving WDL a right of first refusal identical to clause 11.5(b).

[7]      Clause 11.5 is reproduced in its entirety below:

Clause 11.5

Where an Offer Notice has been given by the Franchisee and declined by WDL then the Franchisee may(subject to clause 11.4) offer its interest in the Premises to a third party if:

(a)       WDL   gives   its   written   approval,   such   approval   not   to   be unreasonably withheld by WDL in the case of a respectable and responsible party with the financial resources in the reasonable opinion of WDL to meet the commitments with respect to the Premises and the Business; and

(b)       the offer include a term requiring the third party to give WDL a right of first refusal identical to this clause 11 (but substituting the third party’s name for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wholesale Distributors Ltd v Songle Supermarket Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2548
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Wholesale Distributors Limited (WDL), a franchisor for a group of supermarkets known as SuperValue and FreshChoice, sued Songle Supermarket Limited, the franchisee of its Pauanui store, as well as the store's shareholders, the Browns, and the proposed purchasers of the store, the Igguldens, for breach of contract and for interference with contractual relations. WDL sought an interim injunction preventing Songle from settling the sale of the supermarket to the Igguldens. WDL argued that Songle breached its franchise agreement by entering into the sale agreement without WDL's approval, by failing to include a right of first refusal for WDL in the sale agreement, and by not satisfying WDL of compliance with the franchise agreement. WDL further argued that the Igguldens' conduct interfered with the franchise agreement by causing Songle to breach it. The High Court of New Zealand found that there was not a serious question to be tried in relation to the second cause of action. The Court found that the Igguldens did not know their conduct would induce a breach and that they were entitled to rely on the terms of the sale agreement. The Court further found that the balance of convenience lay in favour of the Igguldens, as WDL's losses were quantifiable and the Igguldens faced significant personal and commercial losses if the injunction was granted. The Court refused WDL's application for an interim injunction.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established