Jiao v Barge

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA236/05

BETWEENYI HUA JIAO & ORS


Appellants

ANDIVAN BARGE


Respondent

Hearing:21 June 2006

Court:Glazebrook, Robertson and Ellen France JJ

Counsel:A C Beck for Appellants


M J Fisher for Respondent

Judgment:19 July 2006 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        APPEAL IS DISMISSED.

BThe respondent is to have costs in respect of this hearing and the hearing on 31 May 2006 of $9,000 together with usual disbursements against all the appellants jointly and severally.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Robertson J)

Table of Contents

Para No

INTRODUCTION  [1]
THE PARTICIPANTS  [5]
FACTUAL SCENARIO  [6]
THE APPELLANTS’ CASE  [50]
EVIDENTIAL MATTERS  [51]
THE ELEMENTS OF THE ALLEGED WRONG  

           
(A)   INDUCING BREACH OF CONTRACT  [55]
           (B)  UNLAWFUL MEANS CONSPIRACY  [68]
CONSEQUENTIAL REMEDIES  [78]
RESULT  [88]

Introduction

[1]       The appellants appeal against some of the orders made by Priestley J in the High Court at Auckland on 27 October 2005 following a hearing which had extended over 12 days in February and March of that year.

[2]       The heart of that case was an application for specific performance of an agreement for the sale and purchase of a property at 45 Anzac Avenue, Auckland.  The building was owned by Freeport Developments Limited (“Freeport”) and the purchaser under the contract was the respondent Ivan Barge.  The order made for performance of the contract and matters consequential on the transfer are now not in contention.

[3]       In addition, however, Priestley J found that (in an endeavour to avoid that agreement for sale and purchase being effected) the current appellants wrongly induced and procured Freeport to breach its contract with Mr Barge, and that all the defendants in the Court below were involved in an unlawful means conspiracy causing loss to Mr Barge.  Freeport has since been placed into liquidation in somewhat unusual circumstances, but that does not impact on this appeal.

[4]       The appeal relates solely to issues of inducement and an unlawful means conspiracy involving the present appellants.

The participants

[5]       Priestley J at [5] to [13] described the parties to the proceedings.  Following his approach, but adapting them to reflect the position on appeal, we identify the relevant people in the dispute:

(a)       The respondent Mr Barge

Mr Barge was the stipulated purchaser in an agreement for sale and purchase dated 4 March 2002 (“the agreement”) between himself and Freeport to purchase the building in Anzac Avenue for $1.1m.

(b)       Freeport (not a direct party to the appeal)

(i)Freeport was at all material times the registered proprietor of the building.

(ii)      Freeport was initially a shelf company, incorporated by the Auckland solicitors, Knight Coldicutt, for use by that firm’s clients.  In July 2000 Yen Fa Chen (“Mrs Chen”) sought advice from Knight Coldicutt about the best mechanism to use for property development in New Zealand.  As a result Mrs Chen and Ta Wen Lin became the owners of 67.5 and 12.5 of Freeport’s shares respectively, with four other shareholders each of whom held five shares…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jiao v Barge and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NZCA 168
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Jiao v Barge, the Court of Appeal of New Zealand dismissed the appeal by the appellants against certain orders made by Priestley J in the High Court at Auckland. The original case involved an application for specific performance of a contract for the sale and purchase of a property at Anzac Avenue, Auckland. The appellants argued against the findings that they had induced Freeport to breach its contract with Mr Barge and that they were involved in an unlawful means conspiracy causing loss to Mr Barge. The Court of Appeal found that the appellants' actions constituted an unlawful procurement of a breach of contract and an unlawful means conspiracy. The Court rejected the appellants' argument that there was no basis for concluding that they induced Freeport to breach its contract with Mr Barge or that they were party to an unlawful means conspiracy. The Court held that the evidence supported the conclusion that the appellants had deliberately interfered with Mr Barge's contract with the intent to harm or bring pressure on him. The Court also held that the appellants had conspired to injure Mr Barge through unlawful means, specifically by inducing the breach of contract and failing to comply with statutory obligations regarding mortgagee sales. The appeal was dismissed, and the respondent was awarded costs of $9,000 against the appellants jointly and severally.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established