Wholesale Distributors Ltd v Songle Supermarket Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA599/2014
[2014] NZCA 565

BETWEEN

WHOLESALE DISTRIBUTORS LIMITED
Appellant

AND

SONGLE SUPERMARKET LIMITED
First Respondent

DAVID GLENN BROWN
Second Respondent

SONIA PAULINE BROWN
Third Respondent

MATTHEW DAVID IGGULDEN AND AMANDA KATHLEEN IGGULDEN AS TRUSTEES OF THE AKP INVESTMENTS TRUST
Fourth Respondents

Hearing:

18 November 2014

Court:

Randerson, White and Venning JJ

Counsel:

D J Chisholm QC and R J Hopkins for Appellant
P R Rzepecky for First, Second and Third Respondents (excused from appearance)
K M Quinn and S M Thompson for Fourth Respondents

Judgment:

27 November 2014 at 4:00 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application by the fourth respondents for leave to adduce further evidence on appeal is declined except to the extent stated in [11] of this judgment.

BThe appeal is allowed.

CThe appellant is entitled to an interim injunction until further order of the High Court restraining the first, second and third respondents from selling the Pauanui SuperValue business to the fourth respondents other than in a manner complying with cl 11.5 of the franchise agreement between the appellant and the first, second and third respondents.

DThe appellant is entitled to costs against the fourth respondents for a standard appeal on a Band A basis with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Randerson J)

Introduction

  1. For some years the first respondent (Songle) has operated a SuperValue supermarket at Pauanui on the Coromandel Peninsula under a franchise granted by the appellant (WDL).[1]  On 14 July 2014, Songle agreed to sell the business for $1,280,000 to a trust of which the fourth respondents, Mr and Mrs Iggulden are trustees.  Amongst other things, the sale and purchase agreement (ASP) was conditional on WDL’s consent to the purchase of the business by the Igguldens and to the transfer of the franchise agreement.

    [1]Songle is owned by the second and third respondents, Mr and Mrs Brown, who were also the guarantors of Songle’s obligations under the franchise agreement.

  2. The relevant clause in the ASP provided:

    Clause 23 – Wholesale Distributors Ltd Approval

    This agreement is conditional upon Wholesale Distributors Ltd consenting to the Purchaser as acquiring the business and the transfer of the Franchise Agreement to the Purchaser or its nominee on terms and conditions satisfactory to the Purchaser.  This condition is to be fulfilled by the 15th day of September 2014.  This condition is inserted for the sole benefit of the Purchaser. 

  3. The franchise agreement completed in 2007 between WDL and Songle included (in cls 11.1 to 11.4) a right of first refusal in WDL’s favour if Songle wished to sell the business.  These clauses also provided for Songle to give an “Offer Notice” in that event.  This did not occur but it is not in dispute for present purposes that cl 11.5 nevertheless applies:

    11.5     Where an Offer Notice has been given by the Franchisee and declined by WDL then the Franchisee may (subject to clause 11.4) offer its interest in the Premises to a third…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wholesale Distributors Ltd v Songle Supermarket Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZCA 565
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Wholesale Distributors Limited (WDL) brought an appeal against the refusal of an interim injunction by Moore J in the High Court of New Zealand. WDL, the franchisor, had granted a franchise to Songle Supermarket Limited (Songle), operated by David and Sonia Brown, to operate a supermarket under the SuperValue banner in Pauanui. The Browns had agreed to sell the supermarket to the Igguldens, who intended to operate it under the Four Square banner, a competitor of SuperValue. The sale was conditional on WDL's consent, as per the terms of the franchise agreement. WDL opposed the sale under the Four Square banner and sought an injunction to prevent the sale until the conditions were met.

The central legal issue was whether there was a serious question to be tried regarding Songle's alleged breach of the franchise agreement by proceeding with the sale without WDL's approval. The Court of Appeal found that it was arguable that Songle breached the agreement by not obtaining WDL's consent and that the Igguldens, despite their waiver of a specific condition in the sale agreement, could not absolve Songle of its obligation to comply with the franchise agreement. The appeal court also held that the balance of convenience and overall justice favoured granting the injunction. Damages would not be an adequate remedy for WDL, as they stood to lose ongoing franchise fees and the goodwill associated with the SuperValue brand. Conversely, while the Igguldens would face financial and personal difficulties, the Court of Appeal found that this situation was largely of their own making.

The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and granted an interim injunction, restraining the Browns and Songle from completing the sale to the Igguldens unless WDL's approval was obtained in accordance with the franchise agreement. WDL was also awarded costs against the Igguldens for the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established