Tremont Holdings Ltd v Body Corporate 401803

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA289/2014
[2015] NZCA 314

BETWEEN

TREMONT HOLDINGS LTD
Appellant

AND

BODY CORPORATE 401803
Respondent

Hearing:

28 April 2015

Court:

Harrison, Keane and Wylie JJ

Counsel:

T J Rainey and J P Wood for Appellant
S C Price and I Rosic for Respondent

Judgment:

21 July 2015 at 12.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The application to pursue the additional ground of appeal is declined.

B        The appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis together with usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Harrison J)

Introduction

  1. Body Corporate 401803 is the body corporate of the Tremont complex, a multi-unit title residential development in St Lukes, Auckland.  Tremont Holdings Ltd (Tremont) owns 20 of the 106 units within the complex.

  2. In 2008 the Body Corporate entered into three agreements with the complex developer, Vermillion Wagener Ltd, whereby it guaranteed the payment obligations of third parties associated with Vermillion under leases of three units within the complex.  Shortly afterwards, Vermillion transferred ownership of the three units to Tremont.  Vermillion and Tremont are related parties; Geoffrey Hodgkinson is the sole director of and principal shareholder in both companies.  So, in the result, Tremont as owner and lessor is the beneficiary of the Body Corporate’s guarantees.

  3. At an extraordinary general meeting held on 7 August 2013 the Body Corporate resolved to take whatever steps were necessary to terminate the three agreements and to instruct a law firm to represent it.  The Body Corporate’s legal advice was that the guarantees were ultra vires or outside its legal powers. 

  4. At a subsequent extraordinary general meeting on 26 November 2013 the Body Corporate passed ordinary resolutions: (a) removing Mr Hodgkinson and another from its committee; (b) reducing the number of members of the committee to seven and the quorum to four; (c) voting seven members on to a new committee; (d) ratifying the committee’s earlier decision to terminate the agreements; and (e) raising a special levy of $165,000 plus GST to fund the necessary legal action. 

  5. Tremont voted against all resolutions at both general meetings.  So did eight other unit owners.  The owners who voted against the resolutions owned 40 units between them. 

  6. As the other party to the impugned agreements, Tremont would be the primary defendant in any proceedings brought by the Body Corporate.  The company objected to being levied for around 18 per cent of the Body Corporate’s prospective legal costs in pursuing a claim against it.[1] 

    [1]The Body Corporate’s challenge to the validity of the agreements was subsequently upheld in the High Court: Body Corporate 401803 v Vermillion Wagener Ltd [2015] NZHC 285, (2015) 15 NZCPR 758. Muir J declared that the Body Corporate was acting ultra vires in entering into the agreements and set them aside. Summary judgment was entered for the Body Corporate. In a judgment delivered concurrently today (Vermillion Wagener Ltd v Body Corporate 401803 [2015] NZCA…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Tremont Holdings Ltd v Body Corporate 401803 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZCA 314
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Tremont Holdings Ltd appealed against a decision of Fogarty J in the High Court at Auckland which dismissed the company’s application for relief from a levy imposed by the Body Corporate 401803. The appeal was dismissed by the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The Body Corporate had passed resolutions terminating three agreements under which it had guaranteed the payment obligations of third parties associated with the complex developer, Vermillion Wagener Ltd, under leases of three units within the complex. Shortly afterwards, Vermillion transferred ownership of the three units to Tremont. The Body Corporate’s legal advice was that the guarantees were ultra vires or outside its legal powers. At a subsequent extraordinary general meeting the Body Corporate passed ordinary resolutions, among other things, to remove two persons from its committee and to reduce the number of members of the committee to seven and the quorum to four. It also passed a resolution to ratify the committee’s earlier decision to terminate the agreements and to raise a special levy of $165,000 plus GST to fund the necessary legal action. Tremont voted against all resolutions at the general meetings. So did eight other unit owners. The owners who voted against the resolutions owned 40 units between them. The Body Corporate’s challenge to the validity of the agreements was subsequently upheld in the High Court. Muir J declared that the Body Corporate was acting ultra vires in entering into the agreements and set them aside. Summary judgment was entered for the Body Corporate. In a judgment delivered concurrently today, this Court has dismissed an appeal by Vermillion and Tremont. Tremont applied to the High Court under s 210 of the Unit Titles Act 2010 (the UTA 2010) for declarations that (a) only those unit owners who voted in favour of the August 2013 resolutions could be levied by the Body Corporate for the costs of the legal and other work outlined to challenge the agreements and that unit owners who voted against such resolutions were to be exempt from the levies or costs; and (b) any contingency fund to which all owners contributed was not to be used to fund the legal and other costs arising from the August 2013 resolutions. Fogarty J dismissed the application and ordered costs in favour of the Body Corporate. He also dismissed a claim, not apparently pleaded, that the August 2013 resolutions were invalid because they were not special resolutions. On appeal, Mr Rainey submitted that the Judge erred in finding that the effect of the Body Corporate’s resolutions would not be unjust or inequitable for Tremont because the company was being sued as the lessor of units, not in its capacity as a member of the Body Corporate. He submitted that it would be unjust and inequitable for the Body Corporate to levy Tremont for fees to bring legal proceedings against itself, especially when it must also fund its own defence costs. The Court disagreed. The minority relief provided by s 210 of the UTA 2010 required the effect of the resolution to be unjust or inequitable for the minority. The minority here were the nine owners of the 40 units who voted against the resolutions. Tremont owned 20 of those units and constituted 50 per cent of the minority. Only three of its units were the subject of the litigation. Tremont had not attempted to satisfy the statutory threshold of showing that the effect of the resolutions would be materially unjust or inequitable for all nine opponents constituting “the minority”. There was no suggestion that the other eight owners within the minority might be similarly affected by the resolutions or that they sought any relief against their effect, and in particular an exemption from the levy for legal costs. The appeal was dismissed. The appellant must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis together with usual disbursements.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established