Butcher v Body Corporate 342525

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WHANGAREI REGISTRY

CIV-2015-488-0086 [2016] NZHC 3128

UNDER

the Declaratory Judgments Act 1908 and

Sections 173 and 210 of the Unit Titles
Act 2010

BETWEEN

ANTHONY JOHN BUTCHER AND RUTH BARBARA BUTCHER, LARRY LAWRENCE SMALL AND KM TRUSTEE SERVICES LTD, IVOR ANTHONY MILLINGTON, NEVILLE EADE, ROBYN KATHLEEN STENT Plaintiffs

AND

BODY CORPORATE 342525

Defendant

Hearing: 29 August - 1 September 2016

Appearances:

B E Brill for the Plaintiffs
TJG Allan and S F Powrie for the Defendant

Judgment:

20 December 2016

JUDGMENT OF MUIR J

This judgment was delivered by me on Monday 20 December 2016 at 4.00 pm

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date:…………………………

Counsel/Solicitors:

B E Brill, B E Brill Ltd, Paihia

TJG Allan, Grove Darlow & Partners, Auckland

S F Powrie, Grove Darlow & Partners, Auckland

BUTCHER v BODY CORPORATE 342525 [2016] NZHC 3128 [20 December 2016]

Contents

Introduction

Paragraph

1

Background 2
The issues 14
The Third cause of action 22
Abuse of Process – Legal Principles 42
What the plaintiffs say 45
Analysis 49
Abuse of process 49
Irrelevance of Butcher consent 63
Result on the third cause of action 71
First cause of action – the legality of resolutions 72
Voting rights under the Act 78
The legislative context 78
Voting eligibility of plaintiffs 85
Result on voting issues 87
Remaining arguments under the first cause of action 88
Alleged requirement for Special Resolutions at EEGM 88
Audit dispensing resolution 93
Ratification 98
The Body Corporate acting in a “trustee capacity” 100
Conclusion on the first cause of action 102
Second cause of action – minority relief under s 210 103
Result 111

Costs

Appendix A Remedial works resolutions

113

Introduction

[1]      This litigation represents a further chapter in long running disputes between a minority of five and a majority of 17 owners of apartments in the “Bridgewater” development located in Paihia, Northland. The minority have consistently contended for what they describe as “targeted repairs” in response to leaky building issues identified in the development.  By contrast, the majority have, throughout, supported what came to be termed a “holistic repair”.

Background

[2]      In a lengthy judgment issued in Wheeldon v Body Corporate 342525 on 30

April 2015 I found that:1

(a)      the Body Corporate was entitled to embark on a repair of the whole building without first giving individual unit owners the opportunity to effect their own repairs;

(b)s 138(d) of the Unit Titles Act 2010 (the UTA) obliged the Body Corporate to repair or maintain any building element that related to or served more than one unit or the common property;

(c)      the  “holistic”  repair  contemplated  by  the  Body  Corporate  was authorised under s 138 having regard to the identified defects, their location and building’s design;

(d)      the proposed works did not constitute “betterment”; and

(e)      a resolution of the Body Corporate on 9 November 2014 in terms that the Committee was “delegated authority to investigate and appoint a lead consultant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Butcher v Body Corporate 342525 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 3128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved a dispute between a minority of five apartment owners and the majority of 17 owners of the Bridgewater development in Paihia, Northland. The minority had consistently sought what they described as “targeted repairs” in response to leaky building issues, while the majority had supported a “holistic repair.” The litigation was a continuation of a dispute that had been ongoing for several years. In this case, the plaintiffs, the minority of five, sought declarations and relief against the majority in their capacity as the Body Corporate of Bridgewater. The defendants, the majority, denied the allegations and counterclaimed for costs. The plaintiffs brought three causes of action. The first sought declarations that the resolutions passed at the 2015 Annual General Meeting, the 2015 Extraordinary General Meeting, and the Emergency Extraordinary General Meeting were unlawful, invalid, or of no effect. The second sought relief under section 210 of the Unit Titles Act 2010 on the basis that the resolutions passed at the AGM, EGM, and EEGM were unjust and inequitable to the minority. The third sought a declaration that the resolutions were “ultra vires and of no effect” on the basis that the works undertaken represented voluntary upgrades unnecessary to satisfy the requirements of section 49(1) of the Building Act 2004. The court found that the plaintiffs were barred from bringing their third cause of action by the principles established in Henderson v Henderson, as it was a re-litigation of an issue that had been determined in a prior proceeding. The plaintiffs were also barred by issue estoppel. Even if those bars did not apply, the evidence upon which the plaintiffs sought to rely was neither credible nor cogent. The first cause of action was dismissed. The plaintiffs had been lawfully disenfranchised from voting at the AGM, EGM, and EEGM because they had not paid the levies in question. All of the resolutions in question were therefore passed by the requisite majorities and were valid. The second cause of action was also dismissed. The plaintiffs were not entitled to relief under section 210 of the Act because they had not voted against the resolutions in question. The court granted a declaration that the audit dispensing resolution passed at the 2015 AGM was invalid to the extent it purported to dispense with audit review for “future accounts periods.” The defendants were entitled to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.