Southland Building Society v Allison

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV-2012-412-000401 [2012] NZHC 2614

BETWEEN  SOUTHLAND BUILDING SOCIETY Plaintiff

ANDCATHERINE ISOBEL ALLISON First Defendant

ANDWILLIAM ARTHUR ALLISON Second Defendant

Hearing:         9 October 2012

with additional written submissions 12 and 17 October 2012 (Heard at Dunedin)

Appearances: O G Paulsen for Plaintiff

D More for Defendants

Judgment:      5 November 2012

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE [as to striking out of defence]

The plaintiff ’s strike out application

[1]      The  plaintiff  applies  for  orders  striking  out  the  defendants’ statement  of

defence and counterclaim and entering judgment for the plaintiff.

The factual background

[2]      The  material  background  as  identified  in  the  pleadings  (through  the defendants’ admissions of allegations in the statement of claim) and through additional matters of undisputed background which are before the Court by way of

affidavit follows.

SOUTHLAND BUILDING SOCIETY V ALLISON HC DUN CIV-2012-412-000401 [5 November 2012]

[3]      The Allison family farm was at Hawea Flat, Central Otago.   Mr Allison worked as a self-employed farmer since 1979.   Mr and Mrs Allison bought the homeblock from Mr Allison’s parents in the early 1980’s and had increased the size of the farm to some 1165 acres (390 owned and 775 leased).

[4]      In 2008 the Allisons were looking for a new bank.   The manager of the Cromwell branch of the plaintiff (“SBS”), Grant Williams, who styled himself “Agribusiness Solutions”, prepared an “Agribusiness Loan Report” for submission to SBS’s lending committee.  A first version was dated 28 November 2007.   The Allisons were then looking for funding of $4,350,000.   They referred to plans for subdivisions of 1.5 ha blocks.  They referred to valuation reports of the subdivided blocks.  The SBS lending committee rejected this first application.  A second (very similar) version of the report, also prepared by SBS’s Grant Williams, was dated 14

February 2008.  The funding request was reduced to $4,150,000.   The reports are appended to this judgment as Appendix 1 and Appendix 2.

[5]      SBS on the second application agreed to provide funds.  SBS made loans to AT Company Limited, a company owned by the Allisons as trustees of their family trust.  Two loans were made in May 2008 and a further loan two months later.  A final loan was made in September 2009 but this was obtained mainly to clear arrears which had accrued on the first loan.  Altogether $3,520,000 principal was involved. Mortgage security had been taken.

[6]      Mr  and  Mrs  Allison,  as  trustees  of  the  family  trust,  also  entered  into guarantees of the loan repayment.   Before doing so they received advice on their obligations from a solicitor, Kerry Richard Ayers, who certified to SBS the fact of his advice and the Allisons’ indication that they fully understood their liability.   The guarantee made the Allisons liable as the principal debtors.

[7]      In 2011 the Allisons defaulted on repayment.   SBS realised its mortgage securities leaving a shortfall of over $2,000,000.  AT Company Limited is now in receivership.     SBS  in  this  proceeding  sues  the  defendants  pursuant  to  their guarantees.

[8]      The Allisons…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Southland Building Society v Allison and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2614
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Southland Building Society sought to recover a debt from Catherine Isobel Allison and William Arthur Allison. The debt arose from guarantees given by the Allisons to support loans made by the Society to a company, AT Company Limited, owned by the Allisons. The loan company defaulted, and the Society was owed a substantial sum. The Allisons admitted the facts pleaded by the Society but denied liability, asserting a defence based on the Society's alleged breach of a duty of care. They argued that the Society had a duty to ensure that the loans made to their company were prudent. The court considered the application to strike out the defence. The court first noted the principles applicable to a strike out application, including the need for the cause of action to be clearly untenable. The court then considered the contractual clause precluding set-off or counterclaim, which was determinative of the parties' rights. The court found that the contractual provision precluded the Allisons from asserting their cross claims as a justification for non-payment of the loans. The court also considered the formulation of the duty of care and found it to be untenable, as it conflicted with established equitable principles governing the relationship between lender and guarantor. The court concluded that the defence was unsustainable and granted the application to strike out the defence, ordering judgment for the Society.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.