Bromley Industries Ltd v Martin and Judith Fitzsimons Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA786/2008
[2009] NZCA 382

BETWEENBROMLEY INDUSTRIES LIMITED


Appellant

ANDMARTIN AND JUDITH FITZSIMONS LIMITED


First Respondent

ANDMARTIN RICHARD FITZSIMONS AND JUDITH ANNE FITZSIMONS


Second Respondents

CA785/2008

AND BETWEEN             BROMLEY INDUSTRIES LIMITED


Appellant

ANDLAGOON DEVELOPMENTS LIMITED


First Respondent

ANDDAVID STANLEY LEES


Second Respondent

Hearing:17 August 2009

Court:O'Regan, Ronald Young and Venning JJ

Counsel:O G Paulsen for Appellant


T Sissons and J J Moss for Respondents

Judgment:27 August 2009 at 3 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeals are allowed.

BJudgment is entered for the appellant against the respondents in CA786/2008 in the sum of $137,914.07 together with interest from 20 July 2008 at the Judicature Act rate.

CJudgment is entered for the appellant against the respondents in CA785/08 in the sum of $54,151.50 together with interest from 20 July 2008 at the Judicature Act rate.

DThe respondents must pay the appellant costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis, plus usual disbursements.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Venning J)

Introduction

[1]       The appellant (Bromley) supplied solid surface bench tops to the first respondents (MFL and Lagoon) pursuant to distribution agreements.  The second respondents guaranteed payment of money owing by MFL and Lagoon under the agreements. 

[2]       Bromley brought summary judgment proceedings against the respondents to recover the price of product supplied.  In the case of MFL Bromley claimed $137,914.07 and in the case of Lagoon, $54,151.50. 

[3]       In the High Court Associate Judge Christiansen accepted Bromley had supplied product to the value claimed: Gran-Marbello International Ltd v Martin and Judith Fitzsimmons Ltd HC CHCH CIV-2008-409-1406 9 December 2008.  He also accepted that MFL and Lagoon had arguable cases for equitable set-off against Bromley’s claims but found that the provisions of the distribution agreement precluded the respondents from raising the claims as a defence to Bromley’s claim for payment.  Despite that finding, in the exercise of the Court’s residual discretion, the Associate Judge declined to enter summary judgment.  Bromley appeals from that decision.

Background

[4]       Under the distribution agreements Bromley appointed MFL and Lagoon as distributors, within their respective territories, to sell Bromley’s product, which was described as “premium quality residential and commercial solid surface bench tops”.  MFL commenced business in the Christchurch area on 31 May 2005.  Lagoon commenced business in the Queenstown area on 25 August 2007. 

[5]       Bromley’s business relationship with the respondents and other distributors was not successful from its point of view.  Bromley sustained substantial losses from the outset.  When Mr Bills reviewed the position on behalf of Bromley he concluded the problems related to the auto-quoting system (which had led to Bromley seriously underpricing the products it supplied to its distributors) and the distributors’ mark-up. 

[6]       In May 2008 Mr Bills moved to change the quoting system.  He also remained concerned whether the distributor model was sustainable for Bromley.  In his regular updates to the distributors, particularly during May 2008, he expressed his concerns bluntly.  For example, he said that with the competition in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bromley Industries Ltd v Martin and Judith Fitzsimons Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZCA 382
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bromley Industries Limited brought an action in the High Court against Martin and Judith Fitzsimons Limited (MFL) and Lagoon Developments Limited (Lagoon) for the recovery of the price of products supplied under distribution agreements. The High Court Associate Judge found that Bromley had an arguable case for summary judgment but declined to enter judgment in the exercise of the Court’s residual discretion. Bromley appealed to the Court of Appeal, which allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the High Court for the entry of judgment in Bromley’s favour. The Court of Appeal held that there was an arguable case that Bromley had repudiated the distribution agreements, which MFL and Lagoon were entitled to cancel, but that the claims for set-off were excluded by the distribution agreements. The Court of Appeal also held that the Associate Judge was plainly wrong to exercise the residual discretion against the entry of summary judgment. Finally, the Court of Appeal held that the point that David Lees was not bound by the guarantee he had signed because it incorrectly identified him as the principal debtor, rather than Lagoon, could not be raised for the first time on appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Bromley Industries Limited supplied solid surface bench tops to Martin and Judith Fitzsimons Limited (MFL) and Lagoon Developments Limited under distribution agreements. MFL and Lagoon were distributors within specific territories. The second respondents guaranteed payments for the obligations of MFL and Lagoon. Bromley brought summary judgment proceedings against the respondents seeking payment for the products supplied. Bromley claimed $137,914.07 from MFL and $54,151.50 from Lagoon. The High Court found that MFL and Lagoon had arguable cases for equitable set-off against Bromley's claims. However, the court declined to enter summary judgment. Bromley appealed against this decision.

Bromley brought summary judgment proceedings in the High Court against MFL and Lagoon seeking payment for the supplied products. The High Court found that Bromley had supplied the products as claimed but also that MFL and Lagoon had arguable cases for equitable set-off against Bromley's claims. Despite this finding, the court declined to enter summary judgment in favour of Bromley. Bromley appealed to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeals were heard together on 17 August 2009 and judgment was delivered on 27 August 2009.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is there an arguable case Bromley repudiated the distribution agreement?
2. Is there an arguable case MFL and Lagoon cancelled the distribution agreements?
3. Are MFL and Lagoon’s claims for equitable set-off excluded by the provisions of the distribution agreement?
4. Was the Associate Judge wrong to decline summary judgment in the exercise of the Court’s residual discretion?
5. Is Mr Lees bound by the guarantee?

Held
1. There is an arguable case that Bromley repudiated the distribution agreement with MFL and there is an arguable case that Lagoon had a basis to consider that Bromley repudiated the agreement with it.
2. There is an arguable case that both MFL and Lagoon cancelled the distribution agreements.
3. The claims for equitable set-off by MFL and Lagoon are excluded by the provisions of the distribution agreement.
4. The Associate Judge was plainly wrong to decline summary judgment in the exercise of the Court's residual discretion.
5. Mr Lees is bound by the guarantee.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal was allowed by the Court of Appeal of New Zealand in the case of Bromley Industries Ltd v Martin and Judith Fitzsimons Ltd and Lagoon Developments Limited. The Court addressed several key issues, starting with whether Bromley repudiated the distribution agreements with MFL and Lagoon. The Court found that there was an arguable case that Bromley repudiated the agreement with MFL, particularly considering the meeting on 3 June 2008, and a weaker but still arguable case for Lagoon. The Court then considered whether MFL and Lagoon were entitled to cancel the agreements, finding that while there was an arguable case that MFL and Lagoon had the right to cancel under the Act, they were not entitled to do so under the specific terms of the distribution agreements. The Court further held that the claims for equitable set-off were excluded by the terms of the distribution agreements, specifically clause 10.1(d). Despite these findings, the Associate Judge had declined to enter summary judgment, a decision the Court of Appeal found to be an error. The Court emphasized that the exercise of the residual discretion should not be used to defeat the commercial purpose of the contractual bargain made by the parties. Lastly, regarding the guarantee provided by Mr Lees, the Court held that despite a technical error in the guarantee document, Mr Lees was bound by the guarantee as he had not expressly pleaded the Contracts Enforcement Act 1956. This decision highlights the importance of contractual clarity and the proper exercise of judicial discretion in commercial disputes.