Ubix Business Solutions Limited v Southern Image Solutions Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV 2012-412-000583 [2012] NZHC 2595

BETWEEN  UBIX BUSINESS SOLUTIONS LIMITED Plaintiff

ANDSOUTHERN IMAGE SOLUTIONS LIMITED

First Defendant

ANDDARYN JARVIE Second Defendant

Hearing:         26 September 2012 (And on the Papers) Counsel:       R M Harrison for Plaintiffs

D P Robinson for Defendants

Judgment:      5 October 2012

JUDGMENT OF WHATA J

[1]      Ubix Business Solutions Limited (“Ubix”) entered into a licence agreement with Mr Jarvie.  The agreement provided exclusive rights to Mr Jarvie’s company, Southern  Image  Solutions  Limited  (“SIS”),  to  sell  Ubix  products  in  the  Otago Region.  Part of the arrangement involved income support in the start up phase and monthly payments of $12,000 were made to Mr Jarvie to a total of $48,000.  Only one of the products was sold, and Mr Jarvie advised that he was not prepared to continue.     Ubix  proposed  additional  support,  but  that  was  not  acceptable  to Mr Jarvie.    SIS  then  gave  notice  of  cancellation  of  the  licence  agreement  for misrepresentation.   Ubix refused to accept that cancellation.   Ubix now seeks an interim  injunction  preventing  SIS  and  Mr Jarvie  from  supplying  any  competing

product or service for the contractual termination period of six months.

UBIX BUSINESS SOLUTIONS LIMITED V SOUTHERN IMAGE SOLUTIONS LIMITED HC DUN CIV

2012-412-000583 [5 October 2012]

[2]      I must resolve whether Ubix has a seriously arguable case based on breach of contract and if so whether the balance of inconvenience favours an interim injunction on the terms sought by Ubix.

Background

[3]      Ubix  and  its  sister  company,  Konica  Minolta  Business  Solutions  New Zealand Limited (“Konica Minolta”) are in the business of selling and servicing a range of copiers and printers known as multifunctional devices (“MFDs”).  Ubix is leading an initiative to introduce a range of products into the New Zealand market, known as the Develop Brand, through local suppliers and backed by Konica Minolta service and support network.

[4]      Daryn Henry Jarvie is the sole director of Southern Image Solutions Limited (“SIS”).  Mr Jarvie is a married man with six children including two preschool and two school aged dependants.  He also financially supports one of his older children who is soon to begin tertiary studies.   Other than his wife who has a job for four hours per week, he is the sole income earner for his family.  Until October 2007 he managed a division of a recruitment company before joining Konica Minolta.  He enjoyed a career in sales with Konica Minolta and achieved a management position running the Invercargill Konica Minolta branch.   He was in the process of exiting Konica Minolta in 2011 when he was approached by the CEO for Konica Minolta to participate in “Project D”.  Project D related to the promotion and distribution of the “Develop” brand of MFDs. This was to coincide with the national relaunch of Ubix.

[5]      Mr Jarvie says that he was presented with pricing information that indicated that the difference between the transfer price and the sale price to a client would represent a good margin and that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ubix Business Solutions Limited v Southern Image Solutions L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2595
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ubix Business Solutions Limited (“Ubix”) sought an interim injunction against Southern Image Solutions Limited (“SIS”) and its sole director, Mr Daryn Jarvie, to prevent them from supplying any competing product or service for six months. The injunction was sought in the context of a licence agreement between Ubix and SIS that had been cancelled by SIS on the basis of alleged misrepresentation by Ubix. Ubix argued that SIS was not entitled to terminate the licence agreement and that Mr Jarvie had breached the agreement by engaging in competing activities. SIS counterclaimed that the licence agreement was properly cancelled because Ubix had made misrepresentations regarding the pricing structure, product differentiation, and marketing campaigns.

The court was required to decide whether Ubix had a seriously arguable case for breach of contract and if so, whether the balance of convenience favoured an interim injunction on the terms sought by Ubix. The court found that Ubix had a seriously arguable case for breach of contract based on the terms of the licence agreement, which provided for exclusivity and non-competition. While SIS argued that the licence agreement was lawfully cancelled due to misrepresentations by Ubix, the court found that these claims were not so strong as to render Ubix’s claim not seriously arguable.

The court also considered the balance of convenience issue. Ubix argued that the premature cessation of the licence agreement and Mr Jarvie’s employment with a competitor would place a competitor at a serious commercial advantage and that damages were not an obvious remedy in this context. SIS argued that an injunction in this context would be unfair given the weak market for the Ubix machines and the misrepresentations by Ubix. The court found that the proper outcome was injunctive relief in the form of a prohibition on solicitation of all prospects identified by Mr Jarvie through and during his performance under the licence agreement.

The court granted an interim injunction preventing Mr Jarvie from directly or indirectly selling or offering to sell to any person identified in Exhibits AC8, AC9, AC10 and AC11 in the Territory any products or services which are similar to the Products. The period of the injunction will be limited to the remainder of the termination period. The court invited counsel to provide a list of the affected persons, the last day for the injunction, and to agree on the precise terms of the proposed injunction. The court also invited submissions on costs if the parties could not agree.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established