Saddle Views Estate Ltd v Dunedin City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV-2016-412-000085

CIV-2016-412-000137 [2017] NZHC 1727

BETWEEN

SADDLE VIEWS ESTATE LIMITED

Appellant

AND

DUNEDIN CITY COUNCIL Respondent

Hearing: 6-9 June 2017

Appearances:

T J Shiels QC for Appellant
M R Garbett for Respondent

Judgment:

25 July 2017

JUDGMENT OF DUNNINGHAM J

[1]      Saddle Hill, near Mosgiel, is a local landmark.  The earliest known record of its distinctive profile was made by Captain James Cook in 1770 when he sailed past this area and recorded seeing “a remarkable saddle hill laying near the shore…”. Although some quarrying and mining occurred on the hill prior to 1960, it was limited in scale.  However, in 1960, Downer and Co Limited (Downer) commenced quarrying rock from the smaller of the two hills joined by the saddle, known as Jaffray’s Hill.  Quarrying has continued thereafter for over 50 years.

[2]      In 2011, the Dunedin City Council (the Council) applied to the Environment Court for a declaration regarding the existence and extent of any rights to quarry Saddle Hill under the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA).  Those and related proceedings have had a convoluted history.  Initially the Environment Court found that no consent had ever issued for the 1960 quarrying operations, and therefore no

deemed resource consent could exist under the RMA.

SADDLE VIEWS ESTATE LIMITED v DUNEDIN CITY COUNCIL [2017] NZHC 1727 [25 July 2017]

[3]      That decision was appealed to the High Court and that Court held that the Environment Court had made two errors in assessing the relevant evidence.1     It allowed the appeal and set aside the declaration of the Environment Court.  It did not make any alternative declarations but it did make a finding that a consent was granted, although the precise terms of the consent could not be accurately defined. That issue was the subject of a fresh application to the Environment Court for a

declaration.

[4]      In an interim decision,2 and then a final decision,3 the Court made a range of findings, the practical effect of which was that, while a consent had been granted in

1960 under s 38A of the Town and Country Planning Act 1953 (TCPA 1953), there was no longer any right to quarry in reliance on that consent.

[5]      Saddle Views Estate Limited (SVEL), the current owner of the quarry, takes issue with the Environment Court’s interim and final decisions, both on procedural and substantive grounds.  It has appealed both decisions to this Court under s 299 of the RMA.  That section confers a right of appeal on a question on law only.  While some of the grounds of appeal in respect of the interim decision are overtaken by the outcome in the final decision, there remain live issues on appeal in respect of both decisions.

[6]      Helpfully, SVEL has categorised the grounds of appeal into issues, whether they are raised in relation to one or both of the Environment Court’s decisions. These issues are as follows:

Issue 1 - Jurisdiction

The Environment Court made an error…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Saddle Views Estate Ltd v Dunedin City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 1727
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Saddle Views Estate Limited (SVEL) appealed to the High Court against two Environment Court decisions. The decisions related to the existence and extent of any rights to quarry Saddle Hill under the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA). The High Court found that the Environment Court had made two errors of law in assessing the relevant evidence, including that a consent was granted in 1960 to quarry Jaffray’s Hill to supply rock for the construction of a new airport at Momona. However, the precise terms of the consent could not be accurately defined. SVEL appealed both decisions to the High Court, arguing that the Environment Court had no jurisdiction to make the declarations it did, and that the declarations were wrong in law and contrary to the principles of res judicata and/or issue estoppel. SVEL also argued that the Environment Court breached fair trial principles, natural justice principles and s 27(1) of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act, and/or displayed apparent bias. The High Court found that the Environment Court erred in law by making declarations 2 and 3 because they were neither necessary, nor desirable to make in the circumstances. The second declaration was made on a hypothetical issue which was neither sought by the parties nor required to resolve the issues in dispute. The third declaration was made on an issue which was moot in light of the findings in declaration 1. The High Court also found that there was no error in law in making the first declaration. It found that the Environment Court had jurisdiction to make the first declaration as it was a logical step in addressing whether the quarry was authorised under the RMA through s 10 as an existing use right or under s 383 as a “deemed consent” and, if so, what the extent of those rights were. The High Court found that the Environment Court had not breached fair trial principles, natural justice principles, or s 27(1) of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act, and that there was no apparent bias. The Court found that the Environment Court was not content to confine itself to the positions adopted by the parties. It openly acknowledged that it was taking a “mild inquisitorial role... in order to establish the facts”. The Court had a wider role in simply adjudicating between the parties when dealing with appeals of resource consent applications and of plans. The Court had a statutory responsibility to place the best evidence it could before the Court. The Court was not seeking to reach a particular outcome, but was open to amending its view in light of submissions if it accepted those submissions as correct. The High Court found that the Environment Court had jurisdiction to make the first declaration and no error of law was established. The second and third declarations were set aside. In all other respects, the appeal failed. Costs were reserved.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established