Clutha District Council v Otago Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTEPOTI ROHE

CIV-2020-412-000113

[2022] NZHC 510

BETWEEN

CLUTHA DISTRICT COUNCIL

Applicant

AND

OTAGO REGIONAL COUNCIL

Respondent

Hearing: 30 June 2021

Appearances:

P J Page and S R Peirce for the Applicant

P A C Maw and M A Mehlhopt for the Respondent

Judgment:

18 March 2022


JUDGMENT OF NATION J


Introduction

[1]    A District Council had a consent to take water from the Clutha/Mata-Au River for a community water scheme. It wanted to renew that consent for a period of 35 years. The Environment Court fixed the duration at 25 years, in part because water from the scheme was being used for dairy shed wash. The District Council says that end use of the water was not a relevant concern. It appeals the Environment Court’s decision.

Background

[2]    The Clutha District Council (District Council) had a resource consent to take water from the Clutha/Mata-Au River (the river) for the Stirling (Bruce) Water Scheme (the scheme) that expired on 1 September 2018. The scheme provides water for

CLUTHA DISTRICT COUNCIL v OTAGO REGIONAL COUNCIL [2022] NZHC 510 [18 March 2022]

distribution to rural and urban destinations, including farming properties in the Clutha district, the townships of Stirling and Benhar, and the Cherry Lane suburb in Balclutha.

[3]    The District Council applied to the Otago Regional Council (the Regional Council) for a new consent to take water from the river for the scheme. Under the Regional Plan: Water for Otago (the Regional Water Plan), the application was for a controlled activity. In granting a new consent, the Regional Council could decide the duration of the new consent. The District Council applied for 35 years, the maximum available under the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA).1 The Regional Council granted the consent for 25 years.

[4]    The District Council appealed the Regional Council’s decision to the Environment Court. In a decision on 19 November 2020, the Environment Court upheld the decision made by the Regional Council.2 The District Council appealed the Environment Court’s decision to this Court.

[5]An appeal is allowed only as to argued errors of law.

[6]    In making its decision, the Environment Court considered that a significant proportion of the water taken from the river for the scheme was used by dairy farms for washing down dairy sheds. Before this Court, the District Council contended this was an error of law because the potential or actual effects of how water was used by people receiving water from the scheme were too remote and lacking in a sufficient nexus to the actual authorised take for those effects to be a relevant consideration in determining an appropriate duration for the new consent.

[7]    Although that was the crux of the appeal, in its notice of appeal, the District Council contended there had been seven errors of law and 15 questions of law which this Court had to consider on appeal. I deal with the argued questions of law…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Clutha District Council v Otago Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 510
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the Clutha District Council (the Council) had a resource consent to take water from the Clutha/Mata-Au River for the Stirling (Bruce) Water Scheme (the scheme). The scheme provides water for distribution to rural and urban destinations, including farming properties in the Clutha district, the townships of Stirling and Benhar, and the Cherry Lane suburb in Balclutha. The Council applied to the Otago Regional Council (the Regional Council) for a new consent to take water from the river for the scheme. Under the Regional Plan: Water for Otago (the Regional Water Plan), the application was for a controlled activity. The Council applied for 35 years, the maximum available under the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA). The Regional Council granted the consent for 25 years. The Council appealed the Regional Council’s decision to the Environment Court, which upheld the decision made by the Regional Council. The Council appealed the Environment Court’s decision to the High Court. The Court held that the Environment Court was not limited by either the terms of the Council’s original application for a water permit or the terms of the notice of appeal from considering the potential contamination of groundwater from the discharges of dairy shed wash onto land. The Court found that the Environment Court was able to have regard to the consequential effects of the end use of the resource that is the subject of the resource consent application, but with limits of nexus and remoteness. The Court held that the Environment Court was required to consider the environmental effects of the consented activity because they were relevant to determining the appropriate duration of the consent. The Court found that the end use of water for dairy shed wash and the subsequent discharge to the environment had a sufficient nexus to the take and were not so remote as to be matters which the Environment Court could not consider when fixing the duration for the water take consent for the scheme. The Court also held that the Environment Court had the discretion to determine the weight to be given to proposed plan changes and that the determination it made was not one that could be challenged as involving an error of law. The Court found that the Environment Court did not err in law in considering the potential effects of the end use of water from the scheme for dairy shed wash in agreeing the duration of the water take consent for the scheme should be 25 years. The District Council’s appeal is accordingly dismissed. The Regional Council is entitled to costs on a 2B basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established