Otago Fish & Game Council v Otago Regional Council

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTEPOTI ROHE

CIV-2019-412-104

[2021] NZHC 3258

UNDER the Resource Management Act 1991

IN THE MATTER

of appeals under ss 299 and 300 Resource Management Act 1991

BETWEEN

OTAGO FISH & GAME COUNCIL

Appellant

AND

OTAGO REGIONAL COUNCIL

First Respondent

AND

LINDIS CATCHMENT GROUP INCORPORATED

Second Respondent

AND

DIRECTOR-GENERAL OF CONSERVATION

Third Respondent

Hearing: 19, 20 April 2021

Appearances:

M F McClelland QC, P D M Tancock and M A Baker-Galloway for Appellant

A J Logan and T M Sefton for First Respondent P J Page and B Irving for Second Respondent

P D Williams and K Gaskell for Third Respondent
(P D Anderson (for Royal Forest and Bird Protection Society of New Zealand Inc) (intervening) excused)

Judgment:

30 November 2021


JUDGMENT OF OSBORNE J


OTAGO FISH & GAME COUNCIL v OTAGO REGIONAL COUNCIL [2021] NZHC 3258 [30 November 2021]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction[1]

The parties[3]

The Lindis catchment[7]

PC5A[12]

The gallery scheme — to replace the races[20]

The competing scenarios in the Environment Court hearing[26]

The consideration of trout in the Judgment[29]

Appeals to the High Court

Appeals on questions of law only[47]

Mootness — the concept[55]

Mootness — the respondents’ submissions[60]

Mootness — the appellant’s submissions[66]

Fish & Game’s appeal grounds[69]

Question 1 — were one or more of the findings of the Environment Court contrary to the express provisions of the RMA or Conservation Act and in making the findings, did the Environment Court err in coming to conclusions

that no reasonable decision-maker could have reached?[73]

“Pest” as a descriptor for trout[75]

Discussion[97]

Question 2 – did the Court wrongly interpret Objective B1 of the NPSFM

in respect of trout?[103]

Discussion[114]

Question 5 – did the Environment Court err by taking the wrong approach

to and/or adopting the wrong legal test for s 7(h) RMA?[117]

Question 3 — did the Environment Court apply the wrong legal test when determining that the current degraded river (status quo) was the relevant

environmental baseline to assess the effects on trout?[129]

Discussion[145]

Question 4 — does “safeguarding the life supporting capacity of … water …

and ecosystems” in s 5 of the RMA rightly include the sustainable

management of trout and their habitat?[149]

Discussion[174]

Question 6 — was the conclusion that the lower minimum flow better protected habitat requirements for invertebrates and indigenous fish than a higher minimum flow of 900 l/s a conclusion that could not

reasonably have been come to on the evidence?[177]

Discussion[197]

Question 8 — did the Environment Court apply the wrong legal test when interpreting the terms “limit” and “over-allocation” from the

NPSFM to the Regional Plan and Lindis River?[201]

Mootness [211]
Outcome [212]
Costs [213]

This judgment was delivered by me on 30 November 2021 at 4.50 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

Introduction

[1]                 The Lindis River (the Lindis) runs from headwaters near the Lindis Pass to the river’s confluence with the Clutha/Mata-Au…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Otago Fish & Game Council v Otago Regional Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZHC 3258
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Otago Fish & Game Council v Otago Regional Council is a legal dispute concerning the management of water resources in the Lindis River, a tributary of the Clutha River in New Zealand. The Otago Fish & Game Council (Fish & Game) appealed against the Environment Court's decision on a plan change (PC5A) related to the minimum flow (MF) and primary allocation of water in the Lindis River. Fish & Game argued that the Environment Court made several errors of law in its decision, which would impact the sustainable management of trout and their habitat in the river.

The High Court considered eight questions of law raised by Fish & Game in its appeal. The Court found no errors of law in the Environment Court's decisions on questions 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, and 7, but did find an error of law in relation to question 4. The Court held that the Environment Court did not err in its interpretation and application of section 5 of the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA) and related provisions in part 2 of the RMA. However, the Court found that the Environment Court erred in its interpretation of the term "limit" and the concept of "over-allocation" in relation to the National Policy Statement for Freshwater Management (NPSFM) and the Otago Regional Plan: Water (ORP:W). Although the Court found an error of law in relation to question 8, it concluded that the error was not material and did not affect the outcome of the case.

The Court dismissed Fish & Game's appeal and ordered that costs and disbursements would follow the event, unless the parties were able to agree on costs within a specified timeframe. The Court's decision upheld the Environment Court's judgment on the plan change and the management of water resources in the Lindis River.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established