Saddle Views Estate Ltd v Dunedin City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV 2013-412-000465 [2014] NZHC 2897

BETWEEN

SADDLE VIEWS ESTATE LIMITED

Appellant

AND

DUNEDIN CITY COUNCIL Respondent

Hearing: 8 & 9 September 2014

Counsel:

C S Withnall QC  and T J Shiels QC for Appellant
M R Garbett and R J Brooking for Respondent

Judgment:

20 November 2014

JUDGMENT OF WHATA J

SADDLE VIEWS ESTATE LIMITED v DUNEDIN CITY COUNCIL [2014] NZHC 2897  [20 November 2014]

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction  [1] Central issues in the Environment Court  [4] The immediate background to this appeal  [5]

The wider context

The site and the quarry  [6]

Statutory regime in 1960  [6] The planning history  [11] The wider history  [13]

The Court’s reasons  [14] Sections 9 and 10  [16] Jurisdiction  [18]

Alleged errors of law

First alleged error of law – Wrong approach to hearsay evidence       [20]

Assessment  [23]

Second alleged error of law – Assessing weight statements against

interest  [26]

Third and eighth alleged error of law: Misinterpretation of the

Edwards letter and wrongly held consent could not be a s 38A

consent  [28] Assessment  [32] Fourth alleged error of law: Wrongly treating documents as

referring to “existing use rights”  [36] Assessment  [39] Fifth alleged error of law: Wrong interpretation of documents in

light of later terminology and planning practice  [40] Assessment  [42] Sixth alleged error of law:  Wrong test in the evaluation of

circumstantial evidence  [44] Assessment  [45] Seventh alleged error of law: Wrong treatment of newspaper

reports  [47] Assessment  [48] Ninth alleged error of law:  Wrong interpretation of the word

“character”  [49]

Assessment  [52]

Tenth alleged error of law:  Wrong interpretation of s 38A of

the TCPA  [62]

Eleventh alleged error of law:  Irrelevant findings of conflict

of interest  [64]

Twelfth alleged error of law:  Speculation about invalidity                  [68] Assessment  [69] Thirteenth alleged error of law:  Speculation about “planning

approval” in respondent’s concession  [70] Assessment  [72] Fourteenth alleged error of law:  Burden of proof  [73] Assessment  [75] Fifteenth alleged error of law:  Disregarding relevant evidence

of the existence of a consent  [77] Assessment  [81] Sixteenth alleged error of law: True and only proper finding was

that a consent existed  [84] Materiality of errors  [85] Relief  [88]

Resolution

Burden of proof  [89]

General principles  [93] NZBORA   [95] The statutory frame  [98] Natural meaning  [102] Justification  [106] The proper approach  [114] Applying the three steps  [115] Evidence of consent  [116] Evidence as a whole  [126]

Outcome  [130] Result  [136] Cautionary note – need for consensus on scope  [137]

Costs  [138]

Introduction

[1]      The Environment Court made a declaration that a large, 55 year old quarry was not authorised by a consent.   The owner of the quarry, Saddle Views Estate Limited (Saddle Views) appeals under s 299 of the Resource Management Act 1991 (the RMA) on the basis  that the Environment Court made 16 errors of law - a truly remarkable feat, if correct, given that the Court was essentially engaged in a single issue inquiry.

[2]      It transpires that the Court made one clear…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Saddle Views Estate Ltd v Dunedin City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2897
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Saddle Views Estate Limited v Dunedin City Council, the High Court of New Zealand considered an appeal by Saddle Views Estate Limited against the Environment Court's declaration that a large, 55-year-old quarry was not authorized by a consent. Saddle Views argued that the Environment Court made 16 errors of law, which the Court found to be a remarkable number for a single issue inquiry. The Court identified two material errors: the Environment Court's finding of a conflict of interest without affording the parties an opportunity to submit on its significance, and the assumption that the Council could not impose conditions at the time of the alleged grant of consent. These errors materially affected the weight given by the Court to the key evidence supporting the grant of the consent. The Court, at the request of the parties, examined the central issue of whether a consent was granted, finding that the Council had not discharged the burden of showing on the balance of probabilities that consent for a quarry was not granted. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the declaration of the Environment Court was set aside. However, the Court noted that in the absence of a written record of the consent, it would be difficult for any Court to definitively find that the removal of the entire hill is expressly allowed by consent. The parties were advised to seek consensus on the proper scope of the activity, considering the full legal and factual matrix as at the time of the grant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established