IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY
CIV 2013-412-000465 [2014] NZHC 2897
BETWEEN SADDLE VIEWS ESTATE LIMITED
Appellant
AND
DUNEDIN CITY COUNCIL Respondent
Hearing: 8 & 9 September 2014 Counsel:
C S Withnall QC and T J Shiels QC for Appellant
M R Garbett and R J Brooking for RespondentJudgment:
20 November 2014
JUDGMENT OF WHATA J
SADDLE VIEWS ESTATE LIMITED v DUNEDIN CITY COUNCIL [2014] NZHC 2897 [20 November 2014]
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction [1] Central issues in the Environment Court [4] The immediate background to this appeal [5]
The wider context
The site and the quarry [6]
Statutory regime in 1960 [6] The planning history [11] The wider history [13]
The Court’s reasons [14] Sections 9 and 10 [16] Jurisdiction [18]
Alleged errors of law
First alleged error of law – Wrong approach to hearsay evidence [20]
Assessment [23]
Second alleged error of law – Assessing weight statements against
interest [26]
Third and eighth alleged error of law: Misinterpretation of the
Edwards letter and wrongly held consent could not be a s 38A
consent [28] Assessment [32] Fourth alleged error of law: Wrongly treating documents as
referring to “existing use rights” [36] Assessment [39] Fifth alleged error of law: Wrong interpretation of documents in
light of later terminology and planning practice [40] Assessment [42] Sixth alleged error of law: Wrong test in the evaluation of
circumstantial evidence [44] Assessment [45] Seventh alleged error of law: Wrong treatment of newspaper
reports [47] Assessment [48] Ninth alleged error of law: Wrong interpretation of the word
“character” [49]
Assessment [52]
Tenth alleged error of law: Wrong interpretation of s 38A of
the TCPA [62]
Eleventh alleged error of law: Irrelevant findings of conflict
of interest [64]
Twelfth alleged error of law: Speculation about invalidity [68] Assessment [69] Thirteenth alleged error of law: Speculation about “planning
approval” in respondent’s concession [70] Assessment [72] Fourteenth alleged error of law: Burden of proof [73] Assessment [75] Fifteenth alleged error of law: Disregarding relevant evidence
of the existence of a consent [77] Assessment [81] Sixteenth alleged error of law: True and only proper finding was
that a consent existed [84] Materiality of errors [85] Relief [88]
Resolution
Burden of proof [89]
General principles [93] NZBORA [95] The statutory frame [98] Natural meaning [102] Justification [106] The proper approach [114] Applying the three steps [115] Evidence of consent [116] Evidence as a whole [126]
Outcome [130] Result [136] Cautionary note – need for consensus on scope [137]
Costs [138]
Introduction
[1] The Environment Court made a declaration that a large, 55 year old quarry was not authorised by a consent. The owner of the quarry, Saddle Views Estate Limited (Saddle Views) appeals under s 299 of the Resource Management Act 1991 (the RMA) on the basis that the Environment Court made 16 errors of law - a truly remarkable feat, if correct, given that the Court was essentially engaged in a single issue inquiry.
[2] It transpires that the Court made one clear…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Saddle Views Estate Ltd v Dunedin City Council and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] NZHC 2897
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi