McGougan v DePuy International Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

FOR A COURT READY (FEE REQUIRED) VERSION PLEASE FOLLOW THIS LINK

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA582/2016
 [2018] NZCA 91

BETWEEN

MICHAEL JOHN MCGOUGAN AND BRIAN FREDERICK DINGLE
First Appellants

BEVAN MALCOLM SANSON
Second Appellant

AND

DEPUY INTERNATIONAL LIMITED
First Respondent

ACCIDENT COMPENSATION CORPORATION
Second Respondent

CA45/2017

BETWEEN

MICHAEL JOHN MCGOUGAN AND BRIAN FREDERICK DINGLE
First Appellants

BEVAN MALCOLM SANSON
Second Appellant

AND

DEPUY INTERNATIONAL LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

28 and 29 November 2017

Court:

French, Asher and Gilbert JJ

Counsel:

D J Goddard QC for Appellants
C A McLachlan QC and J L W Wass for DePuy International Ltd
V E Casey QC and E M Gattey for Accident Compensation Corporation

Judgment:

13 April 2018 at 2.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeals are dismissed.

BThe appellants must pay DePuy International Ltd costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis with usual disbursements.  We certify for two counsel. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Asher J)

Table of Contents

Para No

Introduction
Relevant background

The English proceedings

The issues
Appeal against the first judgment — the statutory bar in s 317

The issue
Section 317
The purpose of the ACC Act
Section 321
The Sentencing Act 2002
The presumption against denial of access to the courts
The territorial scope of the ACC Act
Deterrence
Conclusion

Appeal against the second judgment — estoppel

Issue estoppel
Privies
Relevant history
Conclusion on issue estoppel
Special circumstances

Abuse of process

Conclusion
Result

[1]
[2]
[7]
[13]
[15]
[15]
[21]
[25]
[41]
[49]
[50]
[56]
[62]
[63]
[64]
[64]
[74]
[78]
[91]
[93]
[99]
[105]
[106]

Introduction

  1. Two hip implant systems designed and manufactured by DePuy International Ltd (DePuy), have failed.  Forty-one New Zealanders who received DePuy hip implants between 2006 and 2009 claim the products were defective and caused them personal injury.  Their claims are represented by the three appellants.  In the two decisions of Collins J that are the subject of this appeal, the appellants have been stopped from pursuing claims for compensatory damages in New Zealand.  The first judgment concludes the claims to compensatory damages in New Zealand are barred by s 317 of the Accident Compensation Act 2001 (the ACC Act).[1]  The second, that 25 of the claimants are estopped from seeking compensatory damages in any event by a judgment of the English and Welsh High Court, and the continuation of the proceedings in New Zealand would be an abuse of process.[2]  The appeals against each of these decisions were heard together, and we determine them both. 

Relevant background

  1. The basic facts are not in contention for the purposes of this appeal.  The hip implants in question are known as DePuy ASR XL Acetabular System or ASR Hip Resurfacing System products (the ASR Implants).  Their manufacturer,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGougan v DePuy International Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 91
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of McGougan v DePuy International Ltd was heard by the High Court of Australia, where the central issue was the interpretation and application of Section 321 of the Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) Act. The dispute arose from the obligations and rights of individuals who have received compensation under the ACC Act and subsequently claim damages in New Zealand or elsewhere. The court was tasked with clarifying the scope and effect of Section 321, particularly in relation to the repayment of ACC entitlements by individuals who receive additional compensation.

The legal issues at the heart of the case involved the interpretation of Section 321, which allows the Corporation to require a person to either take reasonable steps to enforce a right to bring proceedings or to assign the right to the Corporation. The court had to determine whether Section 321 required individuals to account for all damages received or merely to repay an amount equivalent to the compensation they received under the ACC Act. The case hinged on the interpretation of whether the provision mandated repayment of all damages received by an individual, or only up to the amount of the ACC entitlement.

The court ruled that Section 321 does not require individuals who recover in proceedings overseas or in New Zealand to account for all damages received to ACC. Instead, it mandates that individuals can be compelled to repay an amount equal to the compensation they received under the ACC Act. This interpretation aligns with the legislative intent to ensure that a person who has cover under the Act does not receive more than their entitlements under the Act. The court rejected the earlier misstatement of Section 321 by Collins J, clarifying that it does not require individuals to account for all damages received but only to repay an amount equal to the compensation they received under the ACC Act.

The court's decision clarified the scope and effect of Section 321 of the ACC Act, providing guidance on the obligations of individuals who have received compensation under the Act and subsequently claim damages in New Zealand or elsewhere. The final orders would likely reflect the court's interpretation, ensuring that the Corporation can require repayment of ACC entitlements without mandating individuals to account for all damages received.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 321 of the ACC Act provides:321Powers of Corporation when person has right to bring proceedings(1)Subsection (2) applies when—(a)any entitlement is required to be provided under this Act for personal injury to a person; and(b)the person has the right to bring proceedings for damages in New Zealand or elsewhere for the personal injury.(2)When this subsection applies, the Corporation may require a person to do one of the following things, at the person’s option and at the Corporation’s expense:(a)to take all reasonable steps to enforce the right; or(b)to assign the right to the Corporation, and to do all other things necessary to enable the right to be enforced by the Corporation, within a reasonable period.(3)Subsection (4) applies when—(a)any entitlement has been or is required to be provided under this Act for personal injury to a person; and(b)the person has received a sum of money by way of damages, compensation, or settlement of any claim in New Zealand or elsewhere for the personal injury.(4)When this subsection applies, the Corporation may, as the case requires,—(a)deduct, from the cost of the entitlement required to be provided to a person, a sum equivalent to the net amount received by way of damages, compensation, or settlement; or(b)recover from the person, as a debt due, the entitlement provided.(5) Nothing in subsection (4) applies to—(a)any money paid on a claim by the person under an insurance contract (other than an accident insurance contract under the Accident Insurance Act 1998) taken out by the person:(b) any payment from a retirement scheme (within the meaning of section 6(1) of the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013):(c) [Repealed](d) any damages awarded under any Act. This provision means that a person who has cover under the ACC Act may be required to take reasonable steps to enforce a right to bring proceedings in New Zealand or elsewhere. If a person succeeds in such a claim and receives damages, compensation or settlement, ACC may deduct a sum equivalent to the net amount of compensation paid to that person. In other words, a person who receives damages must repay any entitlements received under the ACC Act up to the amount of damages received, but is not obliged to account to ACC for any damages that remain after the entitlement is repaid. Some confusion as to the effect of s 321 appears to have arisen in the High Court. Collins J stated that s 321 “ensures a person who has cover does not receive more than their entitlements under the Act”.[32] We accept Mr Goddard’s submission that this misstates the effect of s 321. Section 321 does not require persons who recover in proceedings overseas or in New Zealand to account for what is received to ACC. Rather, such persons can be compelled to repay an amount equal to the compensation they received under the ACC Act. [32]Statutory bar decision, above n 1, at [90]. Simler J made a similar statement in Allen (No 2), above n 4, at [47]: “In each case the Corporation is entitled to take the benefit of the injured person’s rights or award.”