Commerce Commission v Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

SC 39/2006
[2007] NZSC 36

BETWEENCOMMERCE COMMISSION


Appellant

ANDFONTERRA CO-OPERATIVE GROUP LIMITED


Respondent

Hearing:12 December 2006

Court:Elias CJ, Blanchard, Tipping, McGrath and Anderson JJ

Counsel:D J Goddard QC and L Theron for Appellant


J A Farmer QC and A K Rawlings for Respondent

Judgment:30 May 2007 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A.The appeal is allowed and all relevant orders made in the courts below are set aside. 

B.The Court declares that the capital referred to in reg 9(1) of the Dairy Industry Restructuring (Raw Milk) Regulations 2001 is the respondent’s equity capital.

C.The respondent is to pay the appellant costs of $15,000 plus disbursements to be fixed, if necessary, by the Registrar. 

D.In the absence of agreement costs below are to be fixed by the courts below.

REASONS

(Given by Tipping J)

Introduction

[1]       This case concerns the meaning of reg 9(1) of the Dairy Industry Restructuring (Raw Milk) Regulations 2001.  These regulations were passed pursuant to the Dairy Industry Restructuring Act 2001 which implemented a substantial restructuring of New Zealand’s dairy industry.  The Act facilitated the amalgamation of the three main dairy co-operatives in New Zealand.  The amalgamated entity was named Fonterra Co-operative Group Limited and is the present respondent.  Fonterra controls over 98% of milk produced by New Zealand dairy farmers.  Its dominance in the relevant market was such that specific authorisation was required for the amalgamation.  This was granted by s 7 of the Act.  Some regulation of the new entity was seen as necessary.  Among the measures introduced was an obligation on Fonterra to supply raw milk to independent processors[1] at a price which, absent agreement, was to be determined by a formula set out in the regulations.  The ultimate question on the appeal concerns the meaning of the words “the cost of capital rate used by [Fonterra] in calculating the price of a co-operative share” which appear in reg 9(1) as an ingredient of the price-fixing formula. 

[1]     They being processors not associated with Fonterra. 

[2]       The 2001 Act expressly authorised the making of regulations requiring Fonterra to supply milk, prescribing the terms of supply and specifying the methodology for determining the prices to be paid.[2]  This authorising provision reflects the general statutory purpose of promoting the efficient operation of local markets for dairy goods by regulating Fonterra’s activities in order to ensure contestability.[3]  This expression of legislative purpose is reiterated in the statements of purpose and principles in subpart 5 of the Act, which deals generally with dairy market regulation and Fonterra’s obligations in that regard.[4]  These provisions are all plainly directed towards creating a level playing field for all processors in relation to their raw milk costs.  They form an important part of the legislative context in which the Raw Milk Regulations were made and against which the crucial provisions in those regulations must be interpreted.

[2]Sections 115(1)(a) and (b). 

[3]Section 4(f). 

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Fonterra Co-operative Group Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NZSC 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Supreme Court of New Zealand was asked to determine the meaning of the phrase "cost of capital rate used by [Fonterra] in calculating the price of a co-operative share" as it appears in reg 9(1) of the Dairy Industry Restructuring (Raw Milk) Regulations 2001. The capital referred to in the regulation is Fonterra's equity capital. The Court held that the lower the return which the shareholding dairy farmers receive on their capital in Fonterra, the higher is the price which they are deemed to be paid for their milk, and the higher the default milk price will be. The Court allowed the appeal and set aside the orders made in the courts below. The Court also declared that the capital referred to in reg 9(1) is Fonterra’s equity capital. The Court ordered Fonterra to pay the appellant costs of $15,000 plus disbursements to be fixed, if necessary, by the Registrar. The Court further ordered that in the absence of agreement costs below are to be fixed by the courts below.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the interpretation of regulation 9(1) of the Dairy Industry Restructuring (Raw Milk) Regulations 2001, which was passed to facilitate the restructuring of New Zealand's dairy industry. The amalgamated entity, Fonterra Co-operative Group Limited, controls over 98% of milk produced by New Zealand dairy farmers. Regulation 9(1) requires that the discount rate used by Fonterra in calculating annualised share values must be the same as the cost of capital rate used by Fonterra in calculating the price of a co-operative share. The dispute centers on whether the cost of capital rate refers to the rate of return on Fonterra's equity capital or its weighted average cost of capital (WACC). The Commerce Commission argues that the rate should be based on equity capital, while Fonterra contends that WACC, which includes both debt and equity capital, should be used.

The matter was initially heard in the High Court, where MacKenzie J ruled in favor of Fonterra, stating that the WACC rate was a valid "cost of capital rate" for the purposes of regulation 9(1). The Commerce Commission appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal, which dismissed the appeal. The Commission then appealed to the Supreme Court of New Zealand. The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the orders made in the courts below, and declared that the capital referred to in regulation 9(1) is Fonterra's equity capital.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the correct interpretation of the phrase "cost of capital rate" in regulation 9(1) of the Dairy Industry Restructuring (Raw Milk) Regulations 2001?
2. Does the phrase "cost of capital rate" in regulation 9(1) refer to Fonterra's equity capital or its weighted average cost of capital (WACC)?

Held
1. The appeal is allowed and all relevant orders made in the courts below are set aside.
2. The Court declares that the capital referred to in reg 9(1) of the Dairy Industry Restructuring (Raw Milk) Regulations 2001 is the respondent’s equity capital.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's judgment focused on interpreting the phrase "cost of capital rate" in regulation 9(1) of the Dairy Industry Restructuring (Raw Milk) Regulations 2001. The court concluded that the phrase refers to Fonterra's equity capital, not its weighted average cost of capital (WACC). The court rejected Fonterra's argument that the plain meaning of "cost of capital rate" is the WACC rate because it was the rate used by Fonterra. Instead, the court held that the meaning of the phrase must be determined by its context and purpose in the regulations. The court reasoned that the phrase must refer to a specific type of capital and that the context and purpose of the regulations indicate that the capital referred to is equity capital. This conclusion was supported by the fact that the discount rate for calculating annualised share value must relate to a proper return on equity capital, as the return the shareholders receive on their shares is necessarily the cost to Fonterra of its equity capital. The court also noted that the purpose of the regulation is to establish the appropriate discount rate for calculating annualised share value, which is a rate applicable to equity capital. The court's decision was based on statutory interpretation principles, which require the meaning of an enactment to be ascertained from its text and in the light of its purpose. The court also considered the social, commercial, and other objectives of the enactment. The court's decision is binding on lower courts and sets a legal precedent for interpreting similar phrases in future cases.