| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA609/2021 [2022] NZCA 483 |
| BETWEEN | DAMIEN MITCHELL GRANT AS RECEIVER OF BASSETT 43 LIMITED (IN RECEIVERSHIP) |
| AND | ANDREW LAURIE MONTGOMERIE |
| Hearing: | 13 September 2022 |
Court: | Gilbert, Goddard, Simon France JJ |
Counsel: | A S Botterill and K A Cocks for Appellant |
Judgment: | 17 October 2022 at 10.00 am |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
A The appeal is allowed.
BThe respondent must provide to the appellant all books, records and documents of Bassett 43 Ltd in his possession or control.
CThe respondent must pay costs to the appellant for a standard appeal on a band A basis with usual disbursements.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Goddard J)
The issue before this Court
The appellant (the Receiver) was appointed receiver of Bassett 43 Ltd (the Company). Mr Montgomerie, the respondent, was at that time the sole director of the Company. The Receiver wrote to Mr Montgomerie on a number of occasions seeking information about the property and affairs of the Company. The requests variously referred to ss 12 and 14 of the Receiverships Act 1993.
Section 12 of the Receiverships Act, which is at the heart of this appeal, reads as follows:
12 Obligations of grantor
(1)A grantor and, in the case of a grantor that is a body corporate, every director of the grantor, must—
(a) make available to the receiver all books, documents, and information relating to the property in receivership in the grantor’s possession or under the grantor’s control:
(b)if required to do so by the receiver, verify, by statutory declaration, that the books, documents, and information are complete and correct:
(c)give the receiver such assistance as he or she may reasonably require:
(d)if the grantor is a body corporate that has a common seal, make the common seal available for use by the receiver.
(2)On the application of the receiver, the court may make an order requiring the grantor, or if the grantor is a body corporate, a director of the grantor to comply with subsection (1).
Mr Montgomerie did not respond to those requests. The Receiver then applied to the High Court for an order under s 12(2) of the Receiverships Act requiring Mr Montgomerie to produce books, records and documents of the Company.
Before that application was made, Mr Montgomerie had been adjudicated bankrupt. That meant he was disqualified from holding office as a director of the Company, and automatically ceased to hold that office.[1]
[1]Companies Act 1993, ss 151(2)(b) and 157(1)(c).
The High Court accepted Mr Montgomerie’s submission that in those circumstances, it had no jurisdiction to grant the application.[2] Powell J held that an order could be made under s 12 only if Mr Montgomerie was, at the time the order was made, a director of the Company for the purposes of the Receiverships Act. However when he was adjudicated bankrupt, Mr Montgomerie ceased to hold office as a director.[3] The Judge…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Grant v Montgomerie and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] NZCA 483
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and ordered Mr Montgomerie to provide all books, records, and documents of Bassett 43 Ltd in his possession or control to the Receiver. Mr Montgomerie was also ordered to pay costs to the Receiver for the appeal. The decision highlights the importance of ensuring that receivers can access necessary information to carry out their duties effectively, even if it involves former directors of the company.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was initially heard in the High Court, where Montgomerie argued that the court lacked jurisdiction to grant the application as he was no longer a director of the company due to his bankruptcy. The High Court agreed with Montgomerie and dismissed the application. The Receiver appealed to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeal was heard on 13 September 2022, and the judgment was delivered on 17 October 2022.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the High Court have jurisdiction to make the order under section 12 of the Receiverships Act?
2. Can the orders sought be made under section 14 of the Receiverships Act?
3. Can the orders sought be made under section 34 of the Receiverships Act?
4. Should an order be made under section 12 of the Receiverships Act?
Held
1. The High Court had jurisdiction to make the order under section 12 of the Receiverships Act.
2. The orders sought cannot be made under section 14 of the Receiverships Act.
3. The orders sought cannot be made under section 34 of the Receiverships Act.
4. An order should be made under section 12 of the Receiverships Act.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court considered the meaning of the term "director" in section 2(1) of the Receiverships Act, which includes both current and former directors. The purpose of section 12 of the Receiverships Act is to ensure that receivers can obtain the information they require to carry out their functions. The Court concluded that it was clear that the purpose and context of section 12 required a broader reading of the term "director" that extends to former directors. The Court found that the High Court had jurisdiction under section 12 of the Receiverships Act to make the order sought by the Receiver against Mr Montgomerie.
Section 14 of the Receiverships Act allows a receiver to inspect books or documents that relate to the property in receivership and that are in the possession or under the control of a person other than the grantor. However, the Receiver's requests to Mr Montgomerie were to provide information, not to permit inspection of it at Mr Montgomerie's home or workplace. Therefore, section 14 is not relevant to the application before the Court.
Section 34 of the Receiverships Act enables the High Court to provide directions to receivers to guide them in the performance of their functions. It is not intended to enable a receiver to seek orders against some other person requiring them to do or refrain from doing any act. Therefore, the High Court does not have jurisdiction under section 34 of the Receiverships Act to make an order against any person requiring that person to produce books, records and information of the company.
Finally, the Court found that an order should be made requiring Mr Montgomerie to deliver up to the Receiver all books, records and documents of the Company that are in his possession or control. The Court did not consider that Mr Montgomerie's claim that he no longer has any relevant material should preclude the making of an order under section 12. Mr Montgomerie will be required to conduct a comprehensive search for any relevant material he might still hold in hard copy or electronic form, and to exercise any control (legal or practical) that he may have over material in the hands of third parties, in order to comply with the order.