McGougan v Deput International Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2015-485-001049 [2016] NZHC 3170

BETWEEN

MICHAEL JOHN MCGOUGAN AND

BRIAN FREDERICK DINGLE First Plaintiffs

BEVAN MALCOLM SANSON Second Plaintiff

AND

DEPUY INTERNATIONAL LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 12 December 2016

Counsel:

D J Goddard QC and L Theron for Plaintiffs

C A McLachlan QC with J L W Wass, D A Campbell and O J Welsh for Defendant

Judgment:

20 December 2016

JUDGMENT OF COLLINS J

Introduction

[1]      This judgment answers the following question:

Are 25 of the plaintiffs1  in this proceeding estopped from suing the defendant  (DePuy)  in  New  Zealand  for  compensatory damages  in circumstances where:

(1)they commenced proceedings in England seeking compensatory damages against DePuy in relation to conduct   that   forms   the   basis   of   their   claim   in New Zealand; and

(2)a court of competent jurisdiction in England has determined that a sample of the New Zealand claimants

1      In  this  judgment  the  term  “plaintiffs”  is  used  in  reference  to  proceedings commenced in New Zealand and the term “claimants” is  used in reference to proceedings commenced in England.

MCGOUGAN v DEPUY INTERNATIONAL LTD (No. 2) [2016] NZHC 3170 [20 December 2016]

were barred by the law of New Zealand from seeking compensatory damages against DePuy?

[2]      In the context of this case, the question posed in paragraph [1] raises the following two sub-questions:

(1)Were the 25 plaintiffs parties to, or privies of the claimants in, the sample proceedings determined by the court in England?

(2)If not, is it nevertheless an abuse of process for the 25 plaintiffs to continue their claim for compensatory damages in New Zealand?

[3]      This judgment explains why the 25 plaintiffs are estopped from bringing their claim for compensatory damages in New Zealand because they were privies to the sample claimants in the proceedings determined by the High Court of Justice in England.  This judgment also explains why, in the alternative, it would be an abuse of process to permit the 25 plaintiffs to continue their claim for compensatory damages in New Zealand.

[4] To assist readers this judgment is divided into two parts. Part I sets out the background and explains the issues in further detail. Part II explains the conclusions summarised in [3].

PART I BACKGROUND

[5]      In  an  earlier  judgment  (ACC  bar  judgment)2   I  answered  the  following

question posed by the plaintiffs:3

May  claims  for  compensatory  damages  be  brought  by  the  plaintiffs  in New Zealand for personal injury they have suffered in this country, and for which they have cover under the Accident Compensation Act 2001 … in circumstances where the conduct giving rise to their claims occurred in a foreign jurisdiction?

2      McGougan v DePuy International Ltd [2016] NZHC 2511.

3 At [1].

[6]      In concluding the answer to that question was “no”, I reasoned that s 317(1) of the Accident Compensation Act 20014 prevented the plaintiffs from bringing their claims for compensatory damages in New Zealand because they had cover under that Act, even though the conduct giving rise to their claims…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read McGougan v Deput International Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 3170
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

McGougan v DePuy International Limited was a case in which 25 plaintiffs sought damages from DePuy for injuries sustained due to a defective medical implant. DePuy argued that the plaintiffs were estopped from claiming damages in New Zealand, where they had cover under the Accident Compensation Act, because they had already initiated proceedings in England. The court had to decide whether the plaintiffs were estopped from claiming damages in New Zealand and, if so, whether it would be an abuse of process to allow them to do so.

The court concluded that the plaintiffs were estopped from claiming damages in New Zealand because they were privies to the parties in the English proceedings. The court found that the plaintiffs had an interest in the outcome of the English proceedings, had agreed to a procedure that would determine the issue of whether the Accident Compensation Act barred their claims, and had voluntarily stood aside while the New Zealand sample claimants argued the case. The court also found that the plaintiffs' claims constituted an abuse of process because they had agreed to a procedure that would determine the outcome of their claims and had chosen to pursue a similar strategy to one that had been previously struck out as an abuse of process.

The court reserved leave to the parties to file further memoranda if they could not agree on costs and to return to the court for the formulation of any orders that flowed from the decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.