Privy Council Appeals Nos. 47 and 52 of 1998
(1) "W" Appellant (2) "J" Appellant
v. and v.
"W" Respondent Raewyn Anne Bell Respondent
FROM
THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
---------------
JUDGMENT OF THE LORDS OF THE JUDICIAL
COMMITTEE OF THE PRIVY COUNCIL,
Delivered the 19th January 1999
------------------
Present at the hearing:-
Lord Browne-Wilkinson
Lord Steyn
Lord Hoffmann
Lord Hobhouse of Woodborough
Lord Millett
[Delivered by Lord Hoffmann]
------------------
1. The question in these appeals is whether an action for exemplary damages can be maintained against a defendant in respect of conduct which is also a criminal offence and which has been the subject of a criminal prosecution. The Court of Appeal decided by a majority that no such action could be maintained. Against that decision the plaintiffs appeal to Her Majesty in Council. In one case, the defendant had been convicted and, in the other, he had been acquitted.
2. The main purpose of exemplary damages (sometimes called punitive damages) is to punish the defendant. This gives rise to two separate but related questions. The first, which their Lordships will call the wider question, is the extent to which the civil law ought to concern itself with punishment at all, this being more obviously the province of the criminal law. The second, which their Lordships will call the narrower question, is the interaction, in cases in which exemplary damages are in principle available, between the civil remedy and the fact or possibility of a criminal prosecution. As both are intended to punish, there is in a general sense a possibility of double punishment, or double jeopardy, which the law ordinarily regards as unfair and contrary to principle.
3. On the wider question there is a difference between the law of England on the one hand and the law of Australia and New Zealand on the other. In Rookes v. Barnard [1964] AC 1129, at page 1221 Lord Devlin, speaking for the House of Lords, viewed the whole concept of exemplary damages with disfavour, saying that it might well be thought to confuse the civil and criminal functions of the law. The House therefore decided to confine awards of exemplary damages to certain categories of cases which were "not, generally speaking, within the criminal law and could not, even if the criminal law was to be implied, conveniently be defined as crimes". These categories were, first, oppressive, arbitrary or unconstitutional action by servants of the government; secondly, cases in which the defendant’s conduct has been calculated to make a profit for himself which may well exceed the compensation payable to the plaintiff; and thirdly, cases in which an award of exemplary damages is expressly authorised by statute. In cases in which the conduct was also a criminal offence, Lord Devlin said at page 1230:-
"I do not care for the idea that in matters criminal an aggrieved party should be given an option to inflict for his own benefit punishment by a method which denies…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read "W" v. "W" and "J" v. Bell (New Zealand) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] UKPC 2
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi