Fowler Homes Southern Lakes Limited v Bose

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND INVERCARGILL REGISTRY

CIV-2017-425-000030 [2017] NZHC 1707

UNDER the Construction Contracts Act 2002

BETWEEN

FOWLER HOMES SOUTHERN LAKES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

MICHELLE NEETA BOSE AND ROBERT JAMES WOOD Defendants

Hearing: 18 July 2017

Appearances:

R S Cunliffe for Plaintiff/Applicant
M R Taylor for Defendants/Respondents

Judgment:

21 July 2017

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE OSBORNE

[ON PLAINTIFFʼS SUMMARY JUDGMENT APPLICATION]

Introduction

[1]      The plaintiff, a builder, contracted to build a house for the defendants.  The

Construction Contracts Act 2002 applies.1

[2]      As the construction of the house proceeded, the plaintiff issued a number of payment claims which are not the subject of this litigation.  This litigation relates to two particular payment claims:

1.      payment  claim  (PC) 7C served  30  July 2016  for $42,572.92  (GST

inclusive) for variations;

1      The contract was signed on 23 May 2015.  The provisions of the Construction Contracts Act

2002 apply as they existed before amendments to the Act which came into force on 1 December

2015: Construction Contracts Act 2002, s 11A.

FOWLER HOMES SOUTHERN LAKES LTD v BOSE and WOOD [2017] NZHC 1707 [21 July 2017]

2.PC 8 served 9 September 2016 for a final payment of $43,000 (GST inclusive); and a payment of $42,006.36 (GST inclusive) for prime cost (p.c.) sums and variations.

[3]      The defendants sent responses to each of the payment claims on 8 August

2016 and 15 September 2016 respectively.

[4]      The  plaintiff  claims  $127,579.34  (GST  inclusive)  representing  the  two payment  claims,  together with  compounding interest  at  the  contractual  rate  and solicitor/client costs.

[5]      The plaintiff applies for summary judgment. [6]         The application is opposed.

The issues

[7]      The defendants assert that the plaintiff’s payment claims do not comply with

the requirements of the Act. The plaintiff asserts that they comply.

[8]      The plaintiff asserts that the defendants’ responses do not constitute payment schedules which comply with the requirements of the Act. The defendants assert that they comply.

[9]      In the event the Court finds that the defendants failed to serve compliant payment schedules in response to valid payment claims, two consequential issues arise. They are as to the plaintiff’s entitlement to:

(1)     interest; and

(2)     costs.

Plaintiff ’s summary judgment principles

[10]     The starting point for a plaintiff’s summary judgment application is r 12.2(1)

High  Court  Rules,  which  requires  that  the  plaintiff  satisfy  the  Court  that  the

defendant has no defence to any cause of action in the statement of claim or to a particular cause of action.

[11]     I  summarise  the  general  principles  which  I  adopt  in  relation  to  this application:

(1)      Commonsense, flexibility and a sense of justice are required.2

(2)The onus is on the plaintiff seeking summary judgment to show that there is no arguable defence.  The Court must be left without any real doubt or uncertainty on the matter.3

(3)The  Court  will  not  hesitate  to  decide  questions  of  law  where appropriate.4

(4)The Court will not attempt to resolve genuine conflicts of evidence or to assess the credibility of statements and affidavits.5

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fowler Homes Southern Lakes Limited v Bose and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 1707
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fowler Homes Southern Lakes Limited, a builder, contracted with the defendants to build a house. The dispute involved two payment claims: PC 7C for $42,572.92 for variations and PC 8 for a final payment of $43,000 and $42,006.36 for prime cost sums and variations. The defendants responded to each claim, disputing the amounts. Fowler Homes applied for summary judgment. The defendants opposed the application, arguing that the payment claims were invalid and their responses were compliant. The court had to determine whether the payment claims complied with the Construction Contracts Act 2002 and whether the defendants’ responses were compliant payment schedules. If the payment claims were valid, the court also had to decide whether Fowler Homes was entitled to interest and costs.

The court found that PC 7C did not substantially comply with the Act’s requirements. It was not sufficiently detailed and comprehensible for the defendants to understand the basis of the variations claimed. The invoices attached to PC 7C failed to identify the construction work, the rationale for treating it as a variation, and how the figures claimed were derived from subcontractors’ and suppliers’ invoices. The court also found that the defendants’ response to PC 7C was not a compliant payment schedule. Similarly, the court found that PC 8 did not comply with the Act’s requirements for the same reasons as PC 7C. The defendants’ response to PC 8 was also not a compliant payment schedule for the same reasons.

Because the court found that the payment claims were not valid, it dismissed Fowler Homes’ application for summary judgment. The court also found that the application for interest and costs must fail. The defendants were given 10 working days to file a defence. The costs and disbursements of the application were reserved, and the proceeding was adjourned generally to a date to be allocated by the Registrar as the first case management conference date.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.