Fowler Homes Southern Lakes Limited v Bose

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read
IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND INVERCARGILL REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA WAIHŌPAI ROHE

CIV-2017-425-000030

[2017] NZHC 2989

UNDER the Construction Contracts Act 2002

BETWEEN

FOWLER HOMES SOUTHERN LAKES LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

MICHELLE NEETA BOSE AND ROBERT JAMES WOOD

Defendants

Hearing: 4 December 2017 (Determined on the papers)

Counsel:

R S Cunliffe for Plaintiff M R Taylor for Defendants

Judgment:

4 December 2017


COSTS JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS


[1]                 On 21 July 2017 the Court issued a judgment dismissing the plaintiff’s application for summary judgment. At [93] of the judgment, the Court said:1

I will apply the practice recognised by the Court of Appeal in NZI Bank Ltd v Philpott [1990] 2 NZLR 403.

[2]The second order made at [95] was an order reserving costs and disbursements.

[3]                 The Court has received a memorandum from the defendants in which they now seek an award of costs. Whilst noting that costs were reserved, the basis of their application is that the single cause of action pleaded in the original statement of claim


1      Fowler Homes Southern Lakes Ltd v Bose and Wood [2017] NZHC 1707.

FOWLER HOMES SOUTHERN LAKES LTD v BOSE AND WOOD COSTS [2017] NZHC 2989 [4 December 2017]

has now been replaced, in an amended statement of claim, by two causes of action, one in contract and one for breach of an indemnity. This, the defendants say, means that the claim under the Construction Contracts Act which was the basis of the initial claim has now effectively been discontinued.

[4]                 Thus, they say, a hearing cannot and will not be conducted in respect of the claim which was before the Court on the summary judgment application and therefore the Court should, in its discretion, determine costs on the plaintiff’s unsuccessful application.

[5]                 The plaintiff opposes the application. It says that although the cause of action pleaded in the first statement of claim under the Construction Contracts Act does not appear in the amended statement of claim, the proceeding remains a claim to recover money which the plaintiff says is due and owing under the construction contract. Therefore it would be inappropriate to make a determination on costs when the claim between the parties remains to be determined at a substantive hearing.

[6]                 The principle in NZI Bank Ltd v Philpott is well known and frequently applied. The basis for the decision of the Court of Appeal is well-summarised in this passage from the judgment of Heron J:2

Having regard to the difficulty in determining those matters until the case itself is concluded, in many cases the best course will be for the Judge or Master to reserve the question of costs until the litigation is determined … We repeat however that the incidence of costs is best settled when the result of the litigation is known. Hence the widespread practice as we see it of reserving costs in such situations.

[7]                 Although the basis upon which the plaintiff seeks to recover its…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fowler Homes Southern Lakes Limited v Bose and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 2989
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fowler Homes Southern Lakes Limited brought a claim against Michelle Neeta Bose and Robert James Wood in the High Court of New Zealand, Invercargill Registry, seeking recovery of a debt under a construction contract. The claim was initially brought under the Construction Contracts Act 2002, but later amended to include claims in contract and for breach of an indemnity. The defendants applied for costs on the basis that the initial claim under the Construction Contracts Act had effectively been discontinued, making the plaintiff's application for summary judgment unsuccessful. The plaintiff opposed the application, arguing that the proceeding remained a claim to recover money under the construction contract, and therefore, it would be inappropriate to make a determination on costs when the claim between the parties remains to be determined at a substantive hearing.

The court considered the legal issues raised by the defendants' application for costs. The court noted that the principle in NZI Bank Ltd v Philpott, which recognised the practice of reserving costs until the litigation is determined, was well established. The court held that although the basis upon which the plaintiff sought to recover its alleged debt from the defendants had been repleaded, the litigation between the plaintiff and the defendants had not been determined. The defendants' liability (if any) remained at large, and ultimately, the defendants may be found liable to the plaintiff for the sum for which it sued. The court dismissed the defendants' application for determination of costs, finding that it was not soundly based. The court also noted that it was not necessary to consider the defendants' application for an increase in costs, as that too was an issue for the judge to consider when determining costs at the conclusion of the case.

The court's decision was based on the principle that the incidence of costs is best settled when the result of the litigation is known. The court held that the plaintiff was entitled to costs as though this were an interlocutory application, which had not succeeded. However, as counsel had not been heard on the application, the court reserved costs on this application as well. The court referred to the application for costs so that it could be taken into account when costs were assessed, overall, at the conclusion of the case. The court dismissed the defendants' application for costs, finding it was not soundly based and not necessary to consider the defendants' application for an increase in costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.