Downey v Ministry of Social Development

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CRI-2023-404-000446

[2023] NZHC 2589

BETWEEN

NATHAN DOWNEY

Appellant

AND

MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT

Respondent

Hearing: 11 September 2023

Appearances:

C Farquhar for the Appellant O M Salt for the Respondent

Judgment:

15 September 2023


JUDGMENT OF HARVEY J


This judgment is delivered by me on 15 September 2023 at 3 pm.

.....................................................

Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:           Tucker & Co, Auckland

Meredith Connell, Auckland Counsel:           Claire Farquhar, Barrister, Auckland

DOWNEY v MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT [2023] NZHC 2589 [15 September 2023]

Introduction

[1]    Nathan Downey was convicted of 14 charges of dishonestly using a document after fraudulently acquiring approximately $196,000 from the government’s COVID- 19 wage subsidy scheme and unsuccessfully attempting to obtain a further $66,781. Of that amount, some $57,000 was paid to contractors and the balance spent on personal expenses. The full amount taken was eventually repaid. On 25 August 2023, Mr Downey  was  sentenced  to  20  and  a  half   month’s   imprisonment   by   Judge A M Wharepouri in the Manukau District Court.1

[2]    Mr Downey appeals against the decision to impose a sentence of imprisonment on three key grounds. First, the Judge failed to recognise and place any weight on significant personal mitigating features such as remorse, rehabilitative efforts, full restoration of the loss to MSD, and his low risk of reoffending. Secondly, the Judge erred by promoting the purposes of denunciation and deterrence as paramount when sentencing Mr Downey. Thirdly, the Judge erred in dismissing the argument that his rehabilitation was best completed in the community. In doing so, he failed to take account of the negative impacts of imprisonment. In short, Mr Downey argues that the Judge erred in not imposing a sentence of home detention.

[3]    The Ministry of Social Development (MSD) opposed the appeal. Mr Salt for MSD sought confirmation of the starting point imposed here to assist with future sentencings for this type  of  offending  in  the  District  Court.  Ms  Farquhar  for  Mr Downey agreed with that request.

[4]    The issue for determination on this appeal is whether Judge Wharepouri erred in imposing a sentence of imprisonment rather than one of home detention.

Offending

[5]    The COVID-19 Wage Subsidy became available on 17 March 2020. It was established by the government at that time to provide employers whose business had suffered a COVID-19 related decline with a subsidy to pay their employees.2


1      Ministry of Social Development v Downey [2023] NZDC 18670.

2      See Work and Income “2020 COVID-19 Wage Subsidy” < Mr Downey was the sole director and shareholder of Protective Systems Ltd (PSL). Between March 2020 and August 2020 he submitted 19 separate applications, 13 of which were successful, in the name of PSL for the wage subsidy. However, PSL never had any of its own employees. Mr Downey provided the details of numerous purported employees, some of whom were entirely fictitious, others who were people known to him, including as contractors who…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Downey v Ministry of Social Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 2589
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nathan Downey appeals against his sentence of 20 and a half months' imprisonment imposed by Judge A M Wharepouri in the Manukau District Court. The appeal is based on three grounds: the Judge failed to recognise significant personal mitigating features, erred by promoting the purposes of denunciation and deterrence as paramount, and erred by dismissing the argument that his rehabilitation was best completed in the community. The Ministry of Social Development opposed the appeal and sought confirmation of the starting point imposed to assist with future sentencings. The central issue is whether the Judge erred in imposing a sentence of imprisonment rather than one of home detention.

The court considered whether the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive or wrong in principle. The court found that the Judge was entitled to find that deterrence and denunciation weighed heavily, and indeed, were determinative in this case as to the type of sentence to be imposed. The reasons for that were explored in detail in Judge Wharepouri’s decision. The court found no error in the Judge’s approach and dismissed the appeal.

The court also made some comments on the starting point imposed by Judge Wharepouri for Mr Downey’s offending. The court considered that the starting point he determined is entirely appropriate for this kind of offending, taking account of the relevant background circumstances including the purpose of the scheme during an unprecedented national pandemic.

In summary, the appeal is dismissed. The Judge's decision to impose a sentence of imprisonment rather than one of home detention is upheld. The starting point of three years and 10 months' imprisonment is confirmed as appropriate for this kind of offending.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established