Burns v Police

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CRI 2016-409-000063

CRI 2016-409-000065 [2016] NZHC 2116

BETWEEN

NIKITA BURNS

Appellant

AND

NEW ZEALAND POLICE Respondent

CRI 2016-409-000064

BETWEEN  NIKITA BURNS Appellant

ANDMINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT Respondent

Hearing: 6 September 2016

Counsel:

C M Yardley for Appellant
E J Henderson for Respondent

Judgment:

7 September 2016

JUDGMENT OF SIMON FRANCE J

[1]      Ms Burns appeals a sentence of two years and three months’ imprisonment

imposed in relation to three discrete incidents of offending.1

Facts

Red Cross offending

[2]      In the immediate aftermath of the Christchurch earthquakes many residents were in dire circumstances.  Amongst other initiatives, the New Zealand Red Cross

1      Burns v NZ Police; Burns v Ministry of Social Development [2016] NZDC 2360.

BURNS v NZ POLICE [2016] NZHC 2116 [6 September 2016]

received donations from the community and made grants of temporary assistance to people  and  families  in  need.    Over  a  six  month  period  Ms  Burns  made  13 applications using false names and other people’s addresses.  She succeeded on ten occasions, obtaining $18,000.

[3]      The offending struck at the heart of a community in crisis.   Its deplorable nature is obvious.   The District Court Judge emphasised this in his sentencing remarks, and no repetition is needed.  He described it as callous and I agree.

[4]      An  aspect  of  the  summary  of  facts  to  which  the  Judge  referred  was  a statement that the true residents of the addresses used by Ms Burns had themselves been disadvantaged as a consequence.   It was suggested that their legitimate applications were declined because the address had already been the subject of a grant.  Enquiries made prior to the appeal suggest this may have been overstated.  It seems the most that can be said is that one family’s application for winter assistance was delayed by two months as a consequence.

Ministry of Social Development offending

[5]      Over a three year period, Ms Burns falsely claimed she had separated from her partner.   She also claimed on two occasions to have obtained employment in other centres for the purposes of obtaining relocation assistance.  This aspect of the offending involved creating false documents which purported to be issued by what were imaginary businesses.

[6]      Ms Burns unlawfully obtained around $28,000.  The Ministry has calculated that had she sought the benefit she may have been entitled to, namely an unemployment benefit, she may have received $15,000 over the relevant period. Somewhat benevolently in my view, the loss to the Ministry is therefore assessed as being only $13,000.

Car rental

[7]      On one occasion Ms Burns hired a rental car.  She failed to return it.  It was located  two  weeks  later.    Loss  of  $2,300  is  claimed.    As  far  as  can  be  now

ascertained, that appears to be a rental figure for the period.  It does not appear that any damage was done.

Ms Burn’s circumstances

[8]      Ms Burns is 40 years of age.  She has two children, neither of whom live with her.  She was assessed as remorseful and somewhat…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Burns v Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 2116
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, Nikita Burns appealed against the sentence imposed by the District Court for three separate incidents of offending. The offending included defrauding the Red Cross during the aftermath of the Christchurch earthquakes, falsely claiming benefits from the Ministry of Social Development, and failing to return a rental car. The appeal was dismissed by Justice Simon France. The key legal issue in this case was whether the sentence of two years and three months' imprisonment was manifestly excessive. The court considered the starting points for each set of offences and the uplift for past offending. The court found that while the starting points were excessive, the totality adjustment made by the sentencing judge mitigated the impact. However, the court found the uplift was inappropriate given that none of Ms Burns' previous offences had attracted a sentence of imprisonment.

The court emphasised the gravity of the Red Cross frauds, which were committed during a time of crisis in the community. The court found that a sentence at the top of the range for the underlying culpability factors was appropriate. The starting point of 27 months' imprisonment for the Red Cross frauds was not considered excessive. However, the starting points for the other two sets of offences were considered excessive. The court found that six months for the rental car incident was excessive and two months was appropriate. For the benefit fraud, the court found that at least six months' imprisonment as an uplift was appropriate due to the positive deceit involved in creating false employment scenarios. The court concluded that the final starting point of three years and six months' imprisonment was manifestly excessive by six months. However, the court was hesitant to reduce the sentence due to the generous mitigation reduction accorded to Ms Burns. The appeal was ultimately dismissed as the end sentence was not considered manifestly excessive.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established