Downey v Ministry of Social Development

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA579/2023
 [2024] NZCA 53

BETWEEN

NATHAN PETER IRVINE DOWNEY
Applicant

AND

MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT
Respondent

Hearing:

14 February 2024

Court:

Collins, Woolford and Mander JJ

Counsel:

N P Chisnall KC and C G Farquhar for Applicant
T R Simpson for Respondent

Judgment:

11 March 2024 at 2.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

The application for leave to bring a second appeal against sentence is declined.

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Mander J)

  1. Nathan Downey was charged with making fraudulent claims against a wage subsidy scheme established to support businesses and employers during the COVID‑19 pandemic.  He pleaded guilty to 14 charges of dishonestly using a document and was sentenced by Judge Wharepouri to 20 and a half months’ imprisonment in the Manukau District Court.[1] 

    [1]Ministry of Social Development v Downey [2023] NZDC 18670 [Sentencing notes].

  2. Harvey J dismissed an appeal based on whether the sentencing Judge had erred by imposing a sentence of imprisonment rather than home detention.[2]  Mr Downey now seeks leave to bring a second appeal.

Background

  1. In response to the COVID-19 pandemic, a wage subsidy scheme was established by the Government to support businesses and employers who were expected to suffer a decline in revenue as a result of the pandemic and the subsequent lockdowns.

  2. Between 23 March 2020 and 24 August 2020, Mr Downey submitted 19 applications for the wage subsidy using the details of a company of which he was the sole director and shareholder.  The company was not a registered employer, nor did it have any employees.  Mr Downey used the names of people who had formerly done contracting work for the company and other individuals he knew.  He also made up fictitious names to list as employees on the applications. 

  3. The Ministry of Social Development paid $196,076 to the company’s bank account, over which Mr Downey had sole access and control.  Six of the applications that claimed a further $66,781.20 were declined.  Of the money received, $74,363.73 was paid to contractors for work completed on behalf of the company.  The remaining $121,712.27 was spent by Mr Downey on company and personal expenses that included online gambling, adult entertainment clubs, and fast food.

District Court sentencing

  1. In sentencing Mr Downey, the District Court Judge adopted a starting point of three years and 10 months’ imprisonment to which he applied a 25 per cent discount for Mr Downey’s guilty pleas, a 15 per cent credit for remorse and the payment of reparation, and a further 15 per cent deduction in recognition of Mr Downey’s addiction issues and rehabilitative efforts.  The Judge declined to commute the resulting short-term sentence of imprisonment to one of home detention.  He considered that denunciation and deterrence were the key sentencing purposes and that they would not be adequately served by a sentence of home detention.[3]

The High Court appeal

[3]Sentencing…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Downey v Ministry of Social Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZCA 53
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Downey v Ministry of Social Development, Nathan Downey appealed against the decision of the High Court to dismiss his appeal against his sentence. Downey had been found guilty of making fraudulent claims against a wage subsidy scheme established during the COVID-19 pandemic. He pleaded guilty to 14 charges of dishonestly using a document and was sentenced to 20 and a half months' imprisonment. The High Court had dismissed Downey's appeal, which was based on whether the sentencing judge had erred by imposing a sentence of imprisonment rather than home detention. Downey sought leave to bring a second appeal.

The legal issues that the Court of Appeal was required to decide were whether the sentencing judge had erred in imposing a sentence of imprisonment rather than home detention, and whether the approach taken by the High Court treated the offending as a special species of fraud, making imprisonment the presumptive sentence.

The Court of Appeal found that there was no presumption in the Sentencing Act for or against the commutation of a short-term sentence of imprisonment to one of home detention, either generally or in respect of particular types of offences. The Court considered that there was no material error in the sentence imposed that required a different sentence to be substituted. The Court found that the sentencing judge had considered the individual facts of the particular case and the circumstances of the offender, and had come to the conclusion that the requirements of deterrence and denunciation meant no sentence other than a term of imprisonment was appropriate in the circumstances. The Court concluded that the issues raised had no broad application beyond the circumstances of this particular case and that there was no argument reasonably available that the court below was in error.

The Court of Appeal declined the application for leave to bring a second appeal against sentence. The Court found that the sentencing judge had considered the individual facts of the particular case and the circumstances of the offender, and had come to the conclusion that the requirements of deterrence and denunciation meant no sentence other than a term of imprisonment was appropriate in the circumstances. The Court found that the High Court had endorsed the sentencing judge's assessment of Mr Downey's culpability and the seriousness of the offending. The Court concluded that there was no argument reasonably available that the court below was in error.

The final orders of the Court of Appeal were that the application for leave to bring a second appeal against sentence was declined.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established