Smith v Ministry of Social Development

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CRI-2023-404-649

[2024] NZHC 696

BETWEEN

CASEY JOHN BURTT SMITH

Appellant

AND

MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT and NEW ZEALAND POLICE

Respondents

Hearing: 11 March 2024

Counsel:

YY Mortimer-Wang for Appellant

J Blythe and K Grant for Respondents

Judgment:

27 March 2024


JUDGMENTOF BECROFT J

[Appeal against sentence]


This judgment was delivered by me on 27 March 2024 at 4pm Registrar/Deputy Registrar

……………………………………

Solicitors/counsel:

YY Mortimer-Wang, Auckland Meredith Connell, Auckland

SMITH v MINISTRY OF SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT & ANOR [2024] NZHC 696 [27 March 2024]

This appeal

[1]    Mr Casey John Smith appeals against a sentence of two years, three months and two weeks’ imprisonment imposed on him by Judge AM Wharepouri in the Manukau District Court on 4 December 2023.1

The charges

[2]    The relevant charges, to which Mr Smith pleaded guilty, arise from two tranches of dishonesty offending.

[3]    The first relates to fraudulently obtaining, or attempting to obtain, payments under various Ministry of Social Development (MSD) COVID-19 subsidy schemes.

[4]    The second is what is colloquially known as “money laundering”—and in particular, fraudulently obtaining access to bank accounts and transferring funds out of them.

MSD charges

(a)two charges of using a forged document;2

(b)three charges of dishonestly using a document;3 and

(c)two representative charges of dishonestly using a document.4

[5]    The relevant facts are best conveniently summarised now. Between 13 April 2020 and 21 April 2022, Mr Smith dishonestly submitted 43 applications to MSD for wage subsidies or leave support payments. Of these, 19 were in his own name and 24 were in the names of others who were unknown to him, using their real details and names, including Inland Revenue Department numbers.


1      Police v Smith [2023] NZDC 27246 [December 2023 Sentencing].

2      Crimes Act 1961, s 257(1)(a). Maximum penalty 10 years’ imprisonment.

3      Section 228(1)(b). Maximum penalty 10 years’ imprisonment.

4      Section 228(1)(b). Maximum penalty 7 years’ imprisonment.

[6]    Five of those applications were successful. A total of $26,946.80 was paid into bank accounts controlled by Mr Smith. This accounts for the two charges of using a forged document and the three charges of dishonest use of a document.

[7]    The two representative charges of dishonestly using a document relate to 15 offences where Mr Smith used his own name and 22 offences involving applications in the name of other individuals or companies. In total, there were 38 applications. None were accepted by MSD. If successful, Mr Smith would have obtained a further

$207,515.20 from these applications.

[8]    Of the money Mr Smith received, $14,059.20 was paid into an account in the name of a specific individual. That individual’s wallet was stolen in early 2020, and the Westpac accounts in his name were opened on 26 April 2020. Mr Smith “doctored” the person’s driver’s license to include Mr Smith’s own photo in order to open these Westpac accounts. The other bank account in this individual’s name is solely captured by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Smith v Ministry of Social Development and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZHC 696
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Smith v Ministry of Social Development, the appellant, Casey John Burtt Smith, appeals against a sentence of two years, three months, and two weeks' imprisonment imposed by Judge AM Wharepouri in the Manukau District Court. The appeal focuses on three grounds: whether the starting point for sentencing properly reflected the totality of Smith's offending, whether the Judge erred in finding the offending was aggravated by a breach of trust, and whether the Judge adequately considered the impact of a custodial sentence on Smith's young daughter. The court first examines the totality principle, acknowledging that while the sentencing Judge did not explicitly consider the totality of Smith's offending, the cumulative sentence of home detention and imprisonment was not disproportionate. The court then addresses the breach of trust argument, finding that the use of COVID-19 subsidy schemes operated on a high trust model, and any fraud was indeed a breach of trust. Finally, the court reviews the discount for the impact of imprisonment on Smith's daughter, concluding that the five per cent reduction allowed by the Judge was within the appropriate range. The appeal is ultimately dismissed, and the original sentence stands.