Deliu v Auckland District Court

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA129/2023
 [2024] NZCA 39

BETWEEN

FRANCISC CATALIN DELIU
Appellant

AND

AUCKLAND DISTRICT COURT
First Respondent

NEW ZEALAND POLICE
Second Respondent

ATTORNEY-GENERAL
Third Respondent

Hearing:

31 October 2023

Court:

Wylie, Mander and Muir JJ

Counsel:

Appellant in Person
No appearance for First and Second Respondents
J E L Carruthers for Third Respondent

Judgment:

4 March 2024 at 11 am

Reissued:

4 March 2024

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed in part. 

BThe District Court’s directions the subject of proceeding CIV-2021-404-449 are quashed and the matters the subject of those directions are remitted back to the District Court for reassessment in accordance with this judgment.

CThe appeal is otherwise dismissed.

D    There is no order for costs or disbursements. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Mander J)

  1. The appellant, Francisc Deliu, is presently the subject of two separate prosecutions.  Relevantly he currently resides overseas.  On 20 April 2021, Judge E P Paul in the District Court at Auckland directed that various applications filed by Mr Deliu in respect of the prosecutions were not to be heard until he answers warrants issued for his arrest.[1]  This direction has had the effect of indefinitely adjourning the prosecutions unless and until Mr Deliu returns to the jurisdiction.

    [1]R v Deliu DC Auckland CRI-2018-004-3571, 20 April 2021 [minute of Judge Paul (20 April 2021)].

  2. In two separate proceedings, Mr Deliu applied to judicially review:

    (a)Judge Paul’s direction of 20 April; and

    (b)other procedural rulings made by the District Court in the course of the criminal proceedings.  

Mr Deliu sought a range of remedies, including declarations that his rights to be tried without undue delay and to natural justice had been breached. 

  1. Both proceedings were considered by Harvey J in the High Court at Auckland.  Other than in respect of one ground, Harvey J dismissed the review applications and declined to grant Mr Deliu relief.[2]  Mr Deliu has appealed this decision.

Background

  1. In February 2017, Mr Deliu was charged with two charges of assault with a weapon.  He instructed counsel, pleaded not guilty and elected trial by jury. 

  2. In July 2017, in the course of dealing with an application to extend interim name suppression, a dispute arose between Mr Deliu and the presiding Judge — Judge Collins — regarding Mr Deliu’s apparent use of a cell phone in court.  As a result, Mr Deliu made an oral application that the Judge recuse himself.  The Judge declined to recuse himself.[3]  

    [3]R v Deliu DC Auckland CRI-2017-004-1442, 5 July 2017 [decision of Judge Collins (5 July 2017)]. 

  3. At a subsequent call-over in September 2017, Judge Collins allocated a five‑day trial to commence in the week of 22 January 2018, although with the caveat that the matter might not be reached on that date. 

  4. In October 2017, Mr Deliu applied for various orders, including for the recusal of certain…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Deliu v Auckland District Court and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZCA 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Deliu v Auckland District Court is an appeal brought by Francisc Deliu against the Auckland District Court and the New Zealand Police in relation to directions made by a District Court Judge in relation to two separate criminal proceedings against him. Deliu is presently residing overseas. In April 2021, Judge Paul issued directions that various applications filed by Deliu in relation to the criminal proceedings were not to be heard until he answered outstanding warrants for his arrest. This effectively indefinitely adjourned the prosecutions unless and until Deliu returns to the jurisdiction. Deliu applied to the High Court for judicial review of Judge Paul’s direction and other procedural rulings made by the District Court in the course of the criminal proceedings. The High Court dismissed the review applications and declined to grant Deliu relief. Deliu appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal in part. It found that the High Court erred in not quashing Judge Paul’s directions not to hear and determine Deliu’s pre-trial applications that were the subject of proceeding CIV-2021-404-449, and in not remitting the matter back to the District Court for its reconsideration. The Court of Appeal quashed the directions and remitted the matter back to the District Court for reassessment in accordance with the judgment. The Court of Appeal otherwise dismissed the appeal. There was no order for costs or disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

Francisc Catalin Deliu is the subject of two separate prosecutions in New Zealand, currently residing overseas. In February 2017, Deliu was charged with two counts of assault with a weapon, for which he pleaded not guilty and elected a trial by jury. A dispute arose in July 2017 over Deliu's use of a cell phone in court, leading to an oral application for the presiding judge to recuse himself, which was declined. In October 2017, the trial was scheduled for January 2018, but was later vacated due to other matters. Deliu, fearing for his and his family's safety, filed an affidavit seeking to be tried in absentia and to have the proceedings adjourned indefinitely on 10 January 2018, subsequently leaving New Zealand. On 17 January 2018, a new trial date was set for 16 April 2018, with the Crown agreeing to a trial in Deliu's absence. Concerns over Deliu's fitness to stand trial were raised in the period leading up to the new trial date, leading to the engagement of a forensic psychiatrist on 16 April 2018. The judge observed that proceeding without Deliu would have been an option but for the issue of his fitness to stand trial. The judge issued a warrant for Deliu's arrest, which both the Crown and Deliu's counsel agreed was a step available under the Bail Act 2000. Towards the end of April 2018, Deliu was charged with two unrelated offences of attempting to pervert the course of justice. In February 2021, Deliu applied for a witness summons to secure the attendance of a named Crown prosecutor for the purpose of giving evidence at the pre-trial hearing, which was denied by Judge Paul on 12 March 2021. On 20 April 2021, Judge Paul issued a further minute, directing that Deliu's applications to dismiss or stay his charges and other applications he had filed were not to be heard and determined until he answered his warrants. This decision led to the indefinite adjournment of the prosecutions unless and until Deliu returns to New Zealand.

Deliu filed two applications for judicial review in the High Court at Auckland, challenging various decisions and approaches taken by several District Court judges over the course of the criminal proceedings. The first application (CIV-2020-404-1439) sought to challenge decisions and approaches taken by various District Court judges on procedural issues made over the course of the criminal proceedings. The second application (CIV-2021-404-449) concerned Judge Paul's directions noted above. Both proceedings were considered by Harvey J in the High Court at Auckland. Harvey J dismissed the review applications and declined to grant Deliu relief. Deliu has appealed this decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Court of Appeal err in determining that it was open to Judge Paul to adjourn the proceedings indefinitely pending Deliu's return to this country?
2. Did the Court of Appeal err in "repleading" Deliu's grounds for review?
3. Did the Court of Appeal err in ascribing blame to Deliu for the delay in the progress of the criminal proceedings?
4. Did the Court of Appeal err in failing to exercise its discretion to grant relief?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal held that the Court of Appeal erred in determining that it was open to Judge Paul to adjourn the proceedings indefinitely pending Deliu's return to this country.
2. The Court of Appeal held that the High Court did not err in "repleading" Deliu's grounds for review.
3. The Court of Appeal held that the High Court did not err in ascribing blame to Deliu for the delay in the progress of the criminal proceedings.
4. The Court of Appeal held that the High Court erred in failing to exercise its discretion to grant relief by quashing Judge Paul's directions and remitting the matter back to the District Court for reassessment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal found that the description of Deliu as a fugitive from justice was exaggerated and not legally correct. The Court considered that the District Court had various powers of adjournment and jurisdiction to regulate its own proceedings. However, the Court found that Judge Paul's decision to place the criminal proceedings indefinitely on hold could not be reconciled with the fact that Deliu was not, on the materials before the Court, a fugitive seeking to avoid the justice system. The Court held that Judge Paul took into account, as a material consideration, a factor which the High Court subsequently concluded was incorrect. It was a factor which ought not have influenced the District Court direction to decline to hear Deliu's various applications. The Court acknowledged the concerns of Judge Paul that by remaining overseas Deliu can be considered as being in a "win-win" situation by remaining outside the jurisdiction and therefore beyond the Court's sanction. However, the Court accepted that there were other relevant factors that Judge Paul failed to take into account in exercising his discretion. As a result, the Court held that the High Court erred in failing to quash Judge Paul's direction adjourning Deliu's extant applications on an indefinite basis. The Court also found that the High Court did not err in "repleading" Deliu's grounds for review, in ascribing blame to Deliu for the delay in the progress of the criminal proceedings, or in failing to exercise its discretion to grant relief. However, the Court held that the High Court erred in not remitting the matter back to the District Court for reassessment in accordance with the Court's judgment.