| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA |
| CA129/2023 [2024] NZCA 257 |
| BETWEEN | FRANCISC CATALIN DELIU |
| AND | AUCKLAND DISTRICT COURT |
| AND | NEW ZEALAND POLICE |
| AND | ATTORNEY-GENERAL |
| Court: | Wylie, Mander and Muir JJ |
Counsel: | Appellant in person |
Judgment: | 21 June 2024 at 11 am |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
AThe application for recall is declined.
BMr Deliu must pay the third respondent costs for a standard application on a band A basis together with usual disbursements.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Wylie J)
Introduction
On 4 March 2024, this Court issued a judgment allowing, in part, an appeal brought by Mr Deliu against a judgment of Harvey J given in the High Court at Auckland.[1] In that judgment, this Court quashed certain directions given by the District Court and remitted the matters the subject of those directions back to that Court for reassessment.[2] The appeal was otherwise dismissed.[3]
Mr Deliu has applied for an order that one aspect of the Court’s decision be recalled. He takes issue with a sentence contained in [43] of the judgment. That sentence reads as follows:
We are also mindful that Mr Deliu’s oft-repeated demand that Judges recuse themselves has little prospect of success.
The first respondent abides the decision of this Court in relation to Mr Deliu’s recall application. The second respondent has taken no steps. The third respondent opposes Mr Deliu’s application.
The application for recall
Mr Deliu contends that the sentence noted above was “improperly made”. Mr Deliu asserts that the sentence: is factually incorrect, was made without notice to him, was made without allowing him opportunity to comment, and leaves the impression that his “applications to recuse lack merit”. He accepts that he has “recused judicial officers dozens of times”, stating “[he] know[s] of no litigant who has ever obtained more disqualifications of judicial officers”. He says that the impugned sentence leaves “a wrong impression that [he] pursue[s] baseless applications to recuse” and that this could cause him prejudice.
The third respondent opposes the application on the basis that none of the three established grounds for recall is met.[4]
The judgment
[4]Saxmere Ltd v Wool Board Disestablishment Co Ltd (No 2) [2009] NZSC 122, [2010] 1 NZLR 76 at [2], citing Horowhenua County v Nash (No 2) [1968] NZLR 632 (HC) at 633.
In the High Court, Mr Deliu had sought judicial review of a number of procedural rulings made by the District Court in the course of criminal proceedings he faces.[5] Inter alia, Mr Deliu sought review of a decision made by Judge Collins in the District Court declining to recuse himself,[6] and of a subsequent decision made by Judge M B Sharp, also in the District…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Deliu v Auckland District Court and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] NZCA 257
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal examined whether Mr Deliu's concerns met the criteria for recall, which include the presence of an error of law, a material irregularity, or a serious miscarriage of justice. The Court noted that while Mr Deliu had frequently made applications for judicial recusal, many had been declined. The sentence in question was made in the context of the Court’s broader analysis of the District Court’s decision to indefinitely adjourn the criminal proceedings. The Court concluded that Mr Deliu's dissatisfaction with the characterisation of his recusal applications did not meet the threshold for recalling the judgment.
Consequently, the Court of Appeal declined Mr Deliu's application for recall. It ordered that Mr Deliu pay costs to the Attorney-General for the standard application on a band A basis, along with usual disbursements. The Court's decision underscored the limited grounds upon which a judgment may be recalled, emphasizing the importance of meeting established criteria.
Background
Background to the litigation
Mr Deliu applied for recall of a specific sentence in the Court of Appeal's judgment. This application followed the Court of Appeal's earlier judgment which allowed part of his appeal against the High Court's decision. The Court of Appeal had concluded that the High Court had erred in its analysis of the District Court's decision to indefinitely adjourn Mr Deliu's applications for recusal, thus effectively suspending the criminal proceedings. The recall application was opposed by the Attorney-General, who argued that none of the established grounds for recalling a judgment were met. The Court of Appeal reviewed the application on the papers and issued its decision.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the sentence in the Court of Appeal's judgment should be recalled as it was improperly made.
2. Whether the grounds for recall, as established in Saxmere Ltd v Wool Board Disestablishment Co Ltd, have been met.
Held
1. The application for recall is declined.
2. Mr Deliu must pay the third respondent costs for a standard application on a band A basis together with usual disbursements.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court of Appeal issued a judgment on 4 March 2024, allowing in part an appeal brought by Mr Deliu against a judgment of the High Court. Mr Deliu subsequently applied for recall of a specific sentence in the judgment. The sentence in question noted Mr Deliu's frequent unsuccessful requests for judicial recusal. Mr Deliu contended that the sentence was improperly made as it was factually incorrect, made without notice and opportunity for comment, and prejudicial. The Court of Appeal considered the grounds for recall as established in Saxmere Ltd v Wool Board Disestablishment Co Ltd. The Court concluded that Mr Deliu's concern did not meet the recognised criteria for recall. The Court found that Mr Deliu's concern about the sentence being factually incorrect, made without notice and opportunity for comment, did not establish any of the established grounds for recall. The Court noted that while Mr Deliu has indeed made numerous recusal applications, many of which were unsuccessful, this did not amount to the judgment being improperly made. The Court observed that the sentence was followed by a brief explanation of the Court's reasoning, clarifying that a judge exercising their judicial functions does not become ineligible to hear the matter. The Court concluded that Mr Deliu's application for recall did not succeed, and he was ordered to pay the third respondent's costs. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that to successfully recall a judgment, the grounds must be established under the criteria set out in prior authority, and Mr Deliu's concerns did not meet these criteria.