Body Corporate 172108 v Manchester Securities Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2009-404-6868

[2021] NZHC 365

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 172108

Applicant

AND

MANCHESTER SECURITIES LIMITED

37th Respondent

CIV-2019-404-1445

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 172108
Applicant

AND

MANCHESTER SECURITIES LIMITED

Respondent

Hearing: 11 September 2020

Appearances:

J B Orpin-Dowell and T J G Allan for Body Corporate 172108 No appearance for Manchester Securities Ltd (in liquidation) K Sullivan for R J Cummins

Additional submissions received:

16 September 2020

Date of Judgment:

3 March 2021


JUDGMENT OF POWELL J

[Application for joinder of R J Cummins as a party]


This judgment was delivered by me on 3 March 2021 at 3.30 pm pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date:

BODY CORPORATE 172108 v MANCHESTER SECURITIES LIMITED [2021] NZHC 365 [3 March 2021]

[1]                 Robert Cummins has applied pursuant to rr 4.50 and 4.52 of the High Court Rules 2016 in order to be joined as a party in the present proceedings either in substitution or in addition to the present respondent, Manchester Securities Ltd (“Manchester”) which is now in liquidation.

[2]                 The proceedings in issue form part of a protracted and complex dispute over remediation carried out in respect of Hobson Apartments, a 12-storey apartment block located in Hobson Street, Auckland. Manchester is the legal owner of Level 12, which is constructed separately to the rest of the building and is “aesthetically and physically different”, with the only common property on the 12th floor being “the lift and stairwell shafts, ducts and a small recessed area at the rear on the eastern side”.1

[3]                 The history of the matter has been succinctly summarised by Gwyn J in a recent judgment:2

As at October 2009, the building had suffered damage as a result of severe water ingress. The Body Corporate applied under s 48 of the Unit Titles Act 1972 for a scheme of remediation empowering it to carry out repairs under a single building contract to the whole of the complex, including both private and common property.

In 2010–2011, in three judgments, Heath J settled a remediation scheme giving responsibility for the repairs to levels 1 to 11 to the Body Corporate and the Level 12 repairs to Manchester.3 The outcome of those judgments was that a scheme was approved involving a single contract for the repair of the building (the scheme) Manchester would be able to appoint a joint project manager for the Level 12 work. Heath J, noting the unusual ownership structure, allocated costs on the basis that Manchester be required to contribute to the repairs of the common property on levels 1–11 as well as paying for all of the Level 12 work, but with its liability capped at 11.88 per cent of the total cost of repairs to the whole building.4

As the Court of Appeal subsequently described it, after the terms of the scheme were decided there were lengthy delays, escalations and disputes between the parties.5 Manchester had…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 172108 v Manchester Securities Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZHC 365
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Body Corporate 172108 v Manchester Securities Ltd, the High Court of New Zealand was called upon to decide whether Robert Cummins, the new trustee of Manchester Securities Trading Trust, could be joined as a party in the proceedings against Manchester Securities Limited, which was in liquidation. The dispute arose from a protracted remediation process for the Hobson Apartments in Auckland, with Manchester owning Level 12 of the building and the Body Corporate managing the rest. The central issue was whether Cummins could be substituted for Manchester in the litigation, given that Manchester had retired as trustee and Cummins had been appointed in its place. Cummins argued that he needed to be joined as a party to ensure that the proceedings could progress without delay, as Manchester had no legitimate ongoing interest in the matter. The Body Corporate, on the other hand, contended that Cummins' application was premature and an abuse of process, as he had not yet taken legal ownership of the trust assets.

The court found that Cummins' application did not meet the requirements of the relevant High Court Rules. Specifically, the court held that there had been no death, bankruptcy, or devolution of Manchester's estate by operation of law, as required by r 4.50. Additionally, r 4.52 did not apply because there had been no change or transmission of interest or liability. The court also noted that Cummins' attempt to be joined as a party only in his capacity as trustee amounted to an attempt to delay payment of sums owed to the Body Corporate. Given the history of litigation between the parties, the court concluded that Cummins' application was an abuse of process. However, the court decided not to dismiss the application outright, as it would not assist in resolving the underlying issues. Instead, the court ordered that Cummins must register a transfer of the title to the unit on Level 12 from Manchester to himself and pay the Body Corporate all amounts owed by Manchester. If Cummins completed these steps within 14 days, he would be joined as a party to the proceedings. If not, the application for joinder would be dismissed.

The court's decision highlights the importance of ensuring that the right parties are involved in litigation, particularly in complex cases involving multiple proceedings and parties. The court also emphasized the need to prevent abuse of process and to ensure that proceedings move forward in a fair and efficient manner. The outcome of this case will likely have implications for future litigation involving trustees and their beneficiaries, as well as for the ongoing remediation process for the Hobson Apartments.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established