Body Corporate 172108 v Manchester Securities Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2018-485-225

[2020] NZHC 198

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 172108

Plaintiff

AND

MANCHESTER SECURITIES LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 10 December 2019

Counsel:

J B Orpin-Dowell and T J Allan for plaintiff M C Harris and H E McQueen for defendant

R J Cummins (given leave to make submissions in his capacity as the shareholder and director of the defendant)

Judgment:

19 February 2020

Reissued:

28 February 2020


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE JOHNSTON


Introduction and background

[1]                 This is a winding up proceeding in which the plaintiff, Body Corporate 172108 (BC 172108), seeks an order for the appointment of a liquidator over the defendant, Manchester Securities Ltd (Manchester).

[2]                 Litigation between the parties has now been ongoing for more than 10 years. The factual background is complex and has already been recorded in detail in a series of judgments in this Court and the Court of Appeal. A relatively brief summary will suffice here:

BODY CORPORATE 172108 v MANCHESTER SECURITIES LIMITED [2020] NZHC 198

[19 February 2020]

(a)BC 172108 is the Body Corporate for Hobson Apartments, a 12-storey apartment block in Hobson Street in Auckland;

(b)The ownership arrangements for levels 1–11 inclusive are orthodox with BC 172108 owning common areas including the external walls and the unit title holders owning their apartments;

(c)Level 12 is different. As I understand the position, other than such things as stairwells and lift shafts, Manchester owns everything above level 11. This reflects the fact that level 12 was constructed separately, after the rest of the building;

(d)By late 2009 it had become apparent that the building was not weathertight and that extensive remedial work was necessary to all levels;

(e)BC 172108 proposed a scheme for the building’s remediation pursuant to s 48 of the Unit Titles Act 1972 (repealed);

(f)Given the unusual ownership arrangements, a key issue was the contribution if any to be made by Manchester to the cost of remedial work to the common areas on levels 1–11. BC 172108 contended that Manchester should contribute 11.88 per cent of this cost, that being the percentage of the total building area reflected by level 12. Manchester contended that as it would have to shoulder full responsibility for remedial work on level 12 it should not be expected to contribute to the cost of such work on common areas below that;

(g)The parties were unable to resolve this issue, and BC 172108 commenced proceedings in this Court;

(h)There followed a series of defended hearings and Heath J issued several judgments, the last in August 2010.1 His Honour ultimately approved a scheme that required Manchester to carry the cost of remedial work to level 12 and contribute to the cost of remedial work on the common areas of levels 1–11. The latter obligation was capped at 11.88 per cent of the total costs of remedial work to the building;

(i)Inevitably, there were delays and substantial cost escalations;

(j)In March 2013 BC…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 172108 v Manchester Securities Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 198
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Body Corporate 172108 v Manchester Securities Ltd involved a winding-up proceeding where the plaintiff, Body Corporate 172108, sought an order for the appointment of a liquidator over the defendant, Manchester Securities Ltd. The long-standing dispute between the parties centred around the contribution of Manchester towards the cost of remedial work required for the weathertightness of Hobson Apartments, a 12-storey apartment block in Auckland. The primary legal issues for the court to decide were whether Body Corporate 172108 was a creditor of Manchester, whether Manchester was unable to pay its debts, and whether the court should exercise its discretion to decline to make an order winding up Manchester.

The court determined that Body Corporate 172108 was indeed a creditor of Manchester, as Manchester had failed to comply with the statutory demands served on it. The court held that Manchester was unable to pay its debts, as it could not meet its current obligations, including the judgment debt payable to Body Corporate 172108, and its ongoing obligations for remedial work on level 12 of the apartment block. The court rejected Manchester's argument that its alleged counterclaim against Body Corporate 172108 should be taken into account when assessing its ability to pay its debts, holding that it was commercially unrealistic to do so.

In exercising its discretion, the court concluded that the risk of permitting an insolvent company to continue trading outweighed the potential futility of winding up Manchester. The court was concerned that if Manchester were not wound up, the risks for one group of creditors or another would escalate. The court made an order appointing Christopher Carey McCullagh and Stephen Mark Lawrence jointly as liquidators of Manchester Securities Ltd, on the condition that Manchester paid the judgment debt, body corporate levies, and costs awards to Body Corporate 172108 by 4:00 pm on Wednesday, 11 March 2020. The court reserved the matter of costs for later determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established