Body Corporate 172108 v Manchester Securities Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV 2021-404-001066

[2022] NZHC 2982

BETWEEN

BODY CORPORATE 172108

Plaintiff

AND

MANCHESTER SECURITIES LIMITED

(in liquidation) First Defendant

AND

FLAT BUSH FINANCE LIMITED

Second Defendant

AND

ROBERT JAMES CUMMINS

Third Defendant

Hearing: 17 October 2022

Appearances:

K P Sullivan for the Applicant

K M Wakelin for the Respondents

Judgment:

15 November 2022


JUDGMENT OF VAN BOHEMEN J

[application for particular discovery]


This judgment was delivered by me on 15 November 2022, at 11:00 am Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date……………………………..

Solicitors/Counsel:

K P Sullivan, Barrister, Wellington Reeves Lawyers Limited, Wellington Grove Darlow & Partners, Auckland

BODY CORPORATE 172108 v MANCHESTER SECURITIES LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) [2022] NZHC 2982
[15 November 2022]

[1]                  The plaintiff, Body Corporate 172108, applies for orders requiring particular discovery by the second and third defendants, Flat Bush Finance Ltd (Flat Bush) and Robert Cummins (the Defendants). The first defendant, Manchester Securities Ltd (in liquidation) (Manchester), has taken no part in the proceeding.

[2]Specifically, the Body Corporate seeks orders that:

(a)The Defendants provide affidavits stating whether documents within categories identified by the Body Corporate are or have been in their possession;

(b)The Defendants make all such documents available for inspection; and

(c)Claims to privilege and confidentiality made in an affidavit sworn by Mr Cummins on behalf of the Defendants be set aside.

[3]The Defendants oppose the application.

Relevant background

[4]                  The Body Corporate has been engaged in numerous proceedings involving the three defendants over the parties’ rights and liabilities in relation to building repairs to the Hobson Apartments situated at 196 Hobson Street, Auckland, particularly with respect to Unit 12A, which comprises the top floor of the building.1

[5]                  Manchester has been the registered proprietor of Unit 12A since 2006. When it took title to Unit 12A, Manchester was the trustee of the Manchester Securities Trading Trust (the Trust) and owned Unit 12A on behalf of the Trust.

[6]                  Sage Investments Ltd (Sage) has been a registered first mortgagee on the title since Manchester took title to Unit 12A. To date, Sage has been the primary funder of the remediation works to Level 12.


1      The background to and litigation  history  of  the  dispute  between  the  Body  Corporate  and Mr Cummins, Manchester and Flat Bush is set out in Cummins v Body Corporate 172108 [2022] NZHC 774 [Second Caveat Judgment] at [12] – [68].

[7]                  Manchester is no longer the trustee of the Trust. In March 2019, Manchester resigned as trustee and Mr Cummins became sole trustee. However, at the direction of Mr Cummins, Manchester has not transferred title to Unit 12A to Mr Cummins.

[8]                  Mr Cummins is the sole director and shareholder of Manchester and the sole director and shareholder of Flat Bush.

The debt owed by Manchester to the Body Corporate

[9]                  Since April 2012, Manchester has incurred but has not paid levies issued by the Body Corporate.

[10]              On 3 March 2017,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Body Corporate 172108 v Manchester Securities Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 2982
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Court involves an application for particular discovery by Body Corporate 172108 against Flat Bush Finance Limited and Robert Cummins. The Body Corporate seeks orders requiring the defendants to provide affidavits stating whether documents within categories identified by the Body Corporate are or have been in their possession, to make all such documents available for inspection, and to set aside claims to privilege and confidentiality made in an affidavit sworn by Mr Cummins on behalf of the defendants. The defendants oppose the application. The Court finds that the defendants' affidavit of documents does not comply with the High Court Rules and the Listing and Exchange Protocol, and that the claims to privilege and confidentiality are invalid and should be set aside. The Court also finds that the scope of discovery should be determined by reference to the pleadings, and that the Body Corporate's application for discovery is not an opportunity to debate the merits or utility of the Body Corporate's substantive application. The Court grants the application for orders requiring particular discovery by the defendants, but does not consider the additional orders sought by the Body Corporate necessary or appropriate. The Court also sets aside the claims to privilege and confidentiality made in Mr Cummins' affidavit of documents, except for the claim to privilege for correspondence between the defendants and their solicitors.

The Court makes the following orders: (a) the defendants are to provide discovery of certain documents; (b) the above documents are to be made available to the Body Corporate for inspection; (c) except for the claim to privilege for correspondence between the defendants and their solicitors, the claims to privilege and confidentiality made in Mr Cummins' affidavit of documents sworn on 5 November 2021 are to be set aside; and (d) any claims to privilege or confidentiality are to be made in accordance with the High Court Rules and the Listing and Exchange Protocol. The Body Corporate is entitled to 2B costs. If the Body Corporate wishes to seek increased costs, or if the parties are unable to agree on costs, the parties may file memoranda of no more than four pages.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established