Acernus Aero Limited v Vincent Aviation Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA532/2013
[2014] NZCA 246

BETWEEN

ACERNUS AERO LIMITED
Appellant

AND

VINCENT AVIATION LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

29 May 2014

Court:

Ellen France, Harrison and White JJ

Counsel:

J R Sumner for Appellant
J K Scragg and P H Higbee for Respondent 

Judgment:

16 June 2014 at 11.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe appellant must pay the respondent costs for a standard appeal on a Band A basis together with an increase of 50 per cent and usual disbursements.

___________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Harrison J)

Introduction

  1. Acernus Aero Ltd appeals against a judgment of Miller J delivered in the High Court at Wellington,[1] ordering it to pay costs to the respondent, Vincent Aviation Ltd, following the earlier dismissal at trial of its claim for damages and other relief.[2]

Background

  1. Acernus owned a Cessna aircraft which it hangared at Vincent’s premises at Wellington Airport.  A dispute arose between the parties about fees.  A modest sum was at issue.  Acernus issued a proceeding in the High Court, seeking substantive and interim relief.  Clifford J determined an interim application in February 2012[3] before the proceeding came to trial before Miller J in February 2013. 

  2. Acernus pleaded five distinct causes of action.  The company abandoned the first three – for breaches of various contractual instruments – during trial.  Following trial, Miller J delivered his substantive judgment, dismissing Acernus’ remaining two claims for breach of contract.  In the result its claim failed entirely.

  3. Vincent filed a statement of defence and pleaded three counter-claim causes of action.  Miller J entered judgment for it on the first for $7,510.95 but dismissed the other two. 

  4. Towards the end of his substantive decision the Judge noted:

    [73]     This result might suggest that honours have been more or less evenly shared.  That is not so.  In my opinion the real motive for the litigation was Acernus’s desire to gain access to the small hangar through its claim for relief against forfeiture.  That claim was always both untenable and certain to meet resolute opposition; and it was withdrawn when I challenged Mr Toebes about the evidence for a lease after hearing the evidence of both principals.  Overall, Vincent has clearly been the successful party.  I am disposed to allow it costs on a 2B basis with provision for one counsel, subject to a deduction of perhaps 30 per cent for those issues on which it did not succeed.

  5. Despite Miller J’s guidance, the parties were unable to agree on costs.  Memoranda were filed and the Judge delivered his costs judgment.  In it he noted:[4]

    [4]       However, as I sought to make quite clear in my earlier judgment, overall the defendant was the successful party.  The plaintiff’s claim was in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Acernus Aero Limited v Vincent Aviation Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZCA 246
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Acernus Aero Limited appealed against a judgment of Miller J, who had ordered Acernus to pay costs to Vincent Aviation Limited. The underlying dispute arose from a disagreement between the parties about fees for hangaring a Cessna aircraft at Vincent's premises at Wellington Airport. Acernus initiated proceedings in the High Court, seeking damages and other relief, but its claims were dismissed. Vincent filed counter-claims, one of which was successful. Following the dismissal of Acernus' claim, Miller J ordered it to pay costs to Vincent on a 2B basis, with an increase to reflect Acernus' intransigent conduct of the litigation. Acernus appealed against the costs judgment on three grounds: the finding that Vincent was the successful party, the application of the test for increased costs, and the calculation of the costs award. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, finding that Acernus had not demonstrated any error in principle in the Judge's exercise of discretion. The Court was satisfied that Acernus had contributed unnecessarily to the time and expense of the appeal by pursuing arguments that lacked merit and had unjustifiably failed to accept a reasonable offer from Vincent. As a result, Acernus was ordered to pay Vincent costs for a standard appeal on a Band A basis, together with an increase of 50 per cent and usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

Acernus Aero Limited owned a Cessna aircraft which it hangared at the premises of Vincent Aviation Limited at Wellington Airport. A dispute arose between the parties regarding fees, with a modest sum at issue. Acernus initiated proceedings in the High Court seeking substantive and interim relief. The case proceeded to trial, during which Acernus abandoned three of its five pleaded causes of action. The remaining two claims for breach of contract were dismissed by Miller J, resulting in Acernus's complete failure in its claim. Vincent filed a statement of defence and three counter-claim causes of action, with Miller J entering judgment for Vincent on the first counter-claim for $7,510.95 and dismissing the other two. Miller J noted that Vincent was the successful party overall, and despite the parties' inability to agree on costs, the Judge awarded costs to Vincent on a Band A basis, subject to a deduction of 30 per cent for issues on which Vincent did not succeed. Acernus appealed against the costs judgment.

The matter came before the Court of Appeal of New Zealand as an appeal by Acernus Aero Limited against the costs judgment of Miller J in the High Court. The substantive judgment of the High Court, dismissing Acernus's claim, was not appealed. The appeal was heard on 29 May 2014, before Ellen France, Harrison, and White JJ. The grounds of appeal were outlined by J R Sumner for the Appellant and J K Scragg and P H Higbee for the Respondent. The Court of Appeal delivered its judgment on 16 June 2014, dismissing the appeal and ordering Acernus to pay Vincent costs for a standard appeal on a Band A basis together with an increase of 50 per cent and usual disbursements.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did Miller J err in treating Vincent as the successful party for the purposes of the costs award?
2. Did Miller J apply an incorrect test in awarding increased costs?
3. Was Miller J's approach to an adjustment for costs for time spent on Vincent's failed claim wrong in principle?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal held that Miller J did not err in treating Vincent as the successful party for the purposes of the costs award. The Court found that Acernus was plainly the unsuccessful party overall despite the modest success of Vincent on its counter-claim.
2. The Court held that Miller J did not apply an incorrect test in awarding increased costs. The Court accepted that Miller J had a proper ground to invoke his discretion to award increased costs based on Acernus' intransigent conduct of the litigation.
3. The Court held that Miller J's approach to an adjustment for costs for time spent on Vincent's failed claim was not wrong in principle. The Court found that it was open to Miller J to apply a global percentage adjustment to reflect an assessment of Vincent’s counter-claim contribution to the time taken by the proceeding as a whole.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the three main grounds of appeal against the costs judgment. Firstly, the Court addressed the contention that Miller J erred in treating Vincent as the successful party. The Court noted that Acernus initiated and pursued the proceeding with intensity and expedition, claiming damages estimated to be in the range of $200,000 to $450,000. Acernus pleaded five separate causes of action, three of which were abandoned during trial, and it failed on the other two. Vincent filed its defence and counter-claims in reaction to Acernus’ determination to proceed. The Court found that Acernus was plainly the unsuccessful party overall, and thus the Judge's finding that Vincent was the successful party was justifiable.

Secondly, the Court considered whether Miller J applied an incorrect test in awarding increased costs. The Court held that Miller J enjoyed the benefit of familiarity with the facts derived from conducting the trial and it was unnecessary to replicate the grounds in support which Miller J accepted. The Court found that Miller J had a proper ground to invoke his discretion to award increased costs based on Acernus' intransigent conduct of the litigation.

Lastly, the Court assessed Miller J's approach to an adjustment for costs for time spent on Vincent's failed claim. The Court found that it was open to Miller J to apply a global percentage adjustment to reflect an assessment of Vincent’s counter-claim contribution to the time taken by the proceeding as a whole. The Court rejected the submission that Miller J should have followed the methodology established by this Court in Paper Reclaim Ltd v Aotearoa International Ltd, as it found the case to be very different due to the shorter duration of the trial.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in assessing costs, the Court of Appeal will not easily overturn a trial judge's costs award unless the judge proceeded on a wrong principle, gave undue or insufficient weight to certain factors, or was plainly wrong. In this case, the Court found that Miller J did not err in his exercise of discretion when awarding costs in Vincent's favour.